Mafia #14 -- The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
//Game On
OK so a couple of observations on posts that have been made since I took time out to watch my show..
I could agree with this but it would depend on which side he is really on.. If he is mafia let him stay there because he isn't doing them any good. As of this point he is nothing more than a vote for them. If he is one of us the loss of him won't hurt us townies any because he isn't contributing in any way shape or form to flush mafia from the bushes.
While I believe RP adds to the character of a game.. Get a little smile here and there as of this point the Roll Play from Charlie is a diversion. Nothing more.
Im not worried about being in danger from your vote to lynch me, I have nothing to hide. If people want to lynch me, an innocent..it will be the towns loss. Your defensiveness tells me youre hiding something. Confidence in yourself is always a plus, makes no differnce to anyone else unless you are right. You pegged me becasue I am smart and because YOU think that you think like RB..some pretty solid reasons there.
Its really quaint how yesterday you made one post to say hi and today you are out of the gates guns blazing on the Judge putting her on the complete defensive while you stay on the offensive. You at this point are on my radar because you have done nothing of true substance. I am not saying that the judge is or isn't mafia but at this point in the game as far as I'm concerned everyone is mafia including yourself. This ploy btw has been tried by many mafia.
Actually there is a great difference in her play to how she acts when she is innocent to when she is mafia.. She is acting just like she did in Game 5 where she started out quiet and then went completely on the defensive and ended up being mafia. Granted she is being driven to the defensive but her the biggest thing I have seen so far that points her as mafia was that list..
Okay, in digging through some old posts, I came across this one by Clown Lover. As we know, he ended up being Old School Mafia...
A couple of things struck me about this post...
1. Early on Day 1, there was a decent amount of support for lynching Dwarf Puffers. Clown Lover recommends in this post (and subsequent posts) that even if DP were mafia, it wouldn't hurt the town to keep him around.
2. CL calls Chas' waterboy roleplay just a diversionary tactic for Chas, who is mafia...CL eventually votes to lynch Chas on Day 1.
3. CL also goes after Blueiz....we now know that they were on separate mafia teams
4. CL also says that JMax is playing like she did in previous games as mafia.
Now there's always the possibility of distancing from teammates, or drawing in innocents, but I don't think that's the case here. From this post I am assuming:
A. Clown Lover and Dwarf Puffer are Old School Mafia teammates
B. Clown Lover and JMax are not teammates....I also don't think JMax and Blueiz are teammates (although I'm not as secure in this assumption as I am about the CL / DP link).
So, I vote to lynch Dwarf Puffers
FireDancer7905
I'm in love!
Oh wow Nightfall happened early today. Glad I had put in my vote when I did or I would have suffered an UD. Ice, sorry to see you go even though I had actually thought for awhile there you might be old school mafia. I admit to not paying much attention to your posts because of my suspicions, but I will be going back over them as I have time to see what you had to say regarding your suspects and what might have caused you to be the hit victim.
Where is everyone? I figured there would be many more posts for me to read through to get caught up on. I will not be available tomorrow much. My husband's work schedule this week is very crazy and he's got to go into work at hours that neither of us are used to. Our sleeping schedule and meals are all screwed up and it's also messing up my home school schedule.
I will however, check in as often as I can to catch up on posts and to help find the remaining mafia members.
I vote to lynch DeputyChiefJR. I made a case for him several days ago, but nobody seemed to pay much attention to it. Since then I've kept a very close eye on him and he's posted very, very little, and nothing that makes me believe he's innocent.
Where is everyone? I figured there would be many more posts for me to read through to get caught up on. I will not be available tomorrow much. My husband's work schedule this week is very crazy and he's got to go into work at hours that neither of us are used to. Our sleeping schedule and meals are all screwed up and it's also messing up my home school schedule.
I will however, check in as often as I can to catch up on posts and to help find the remaining mafia members.
I vote to lynch DeputyChiefJR. I made a case for him several days ago, but nobody seemed to pay much attention to it. Since then I've kept a very close eye on him and he's posted very, very little, and nothing that makes me believe he's innocent.
Attention innocent townies: we cannot go into the lynch with 5+ candidates...the mafia will run all over us... we need to come together.
I agree. I am willing to switch my vote. I've suspected DP just about as long as I've suspected DC.
Jensons, is looking more and more mafia to me though. I don't like her latest post...all she can say is RIP, toss out a revenge vote, and then leaves....no information at all for us to go on there.
I am skeptical of JM because I really don't trust Ogre.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
Beat me to it Mad... as soon as I put Sways vote in the ole spreadsheet, I was thinking... this ain't gonna work.
DP is probably my least favorite of my top three choices. But if everyone else is leaning that direction... And considering the fact that Ice seemed to trust Mad, I am willing to change.
There are ten left and I'm assuming between 2-4 mafia left. But the teams are divided and the biggest one of them is three. So we have some time to work this all out.
DP is probably my least favorite of my top three choices. But if everyone else is leaning that direction... And considering the fact that Ice seemed to trust Mad, I am willing to change.
There are ten left and I'm assuming between 2-4 mafia left. But the teams are divided and the biggest one of them is three. So we have some time to work this all out.
I think that it's possible based on the previous game w/ 2 teams that we could be at 5 mafia (2 OS, 3 NS) depending on the 'accident' role. So, I'm rethinking my vote for DP at this time.... Not because I don't think he's mafia, but because I'd like to lynch NS mafia tonight (and I think that he's likely OS).
- I don't think that JMax is NS mafia based on she and Blue going at it so publicly early on (distancing is one thing, but not a good idea to try to get your teammate lynched)....but I'm not positive. I don't necessarily like her for OS mafia either, based on CL's post.
- I don't think that DC is NS mafia. The hit on night 3 appears to be against him, and I think that came from NS mafia (as I would think that OS would have hit Lady G since they knew she was the doc). I don't necessarily like him for OS mafia either, as at some point DD came out and went after him for the same 'I wanted to follow HN's votes,' comment that I did.
- If mafia, I don't know which side Jensons would be on. She said the same stuff that Blue did about DD being detective (after she came out as mafia) and trying to draw mafia out. If mafia, would that put her on Blue's team or DD's? I'm still trying to understand why the heck Blue was coming to DD's aid with that nonsense, and why others on her team would also.
As I said earlier, I do like Swayde for mafia. Based on the fact that on Day 1 when some votes piled onto DP she never pulled off, I think that she would be New School mafia....
unvote DP, I vote to lynch Swayde
I don't follow your reasoning for voting for me. You want to lynch me because I did not back off someone I felt was mafia just because a couple of other people voted for him? Talk about a weak reason to vote for someone. You are a much better player than that. Now you've gone up several notches on my mafia-meter. This is the second time you've voted for me this game, with no case either time. Are you trying to protect DC or DP, or both?
