Mafia #14 -- The Play

[Lady G]

What?! He said that you didn't have good excuses for not posting? I think he was referring to DP. You seem a bit "panicked". Why?

No, not "panicked" I really am not trying to come off as defensive guy's, I don't want people to read into my post wrong and just want to clear up any questions about them.

I think the above is to HN. I find it odd that charlie hopes that HN gets hit tonight. Not lynched by the town, but hit by the mafia.

I see no way that this is good for the town.



Here is the scary part, I agree with Ogre's list so far. I know it is real early to make a list, but the top three I think should be watched. I also have a bad feeling about DP. I think they should have had a better excuse for not coming to the thread sooner.

Yes he said I think THEY should have had a better excuse. I just wanted to point out the fact everyone except DP had posted before him.

 

[judgemax]

alright its nighty night for me, I have to get the brats up early! ....

 

[clown-lover]

//game off
Ok just a point of contention here.. Can you guys please not post your notes within someone elses quotes. It makes it a pain to pull your stuff out so I can quote and reply.. If you would be so kind is to copy and paste the header and footer portion of the areas you are individually refering to then all anyone has to do is hit quote to reply.. Thanks
//Game On

, um, there was no mistake, I was innocent, and NJ was mafia?...what was the mistake?...

Well you really went wild in loosing your cool on that one.. There were some points when I thought you were crying on the other side of my screen.. I never said you weren't innocent during that incident just refreshing everyone of your mannerisms during that time.

again, I have tried to let it drop several times. read the posts, before you try and stick up for your team mates, are you trying to save her because your the one who told her to say grasping at straws?...

Um I think you have it backwards here unless you are calling blue a townie now. Read my posts I have taken a position on her posting thank you very much.

 

[Madcrawdad]

//Game On

OK so a couple of observations on posts that have been made since I took time out to watch my show..

I agree with you in regards to DP, but I'd rather he just retract all votes and die vs. us having to waste a night on him when we can find a mafia. (I tend to suspect there will be a strong push for DP to save Charlie.... Just a hunch).

I could agree with this but it would depend on which side he is really on.. If he is mafia let him stay there because he isn't doing them any good. As of this point he is nothing more than a vote for them. If he is one of us the loss of him won't hurt us townies any because he isn't contributing in any way shape or form to flush mafia from the bushes..

CL, can you clarify this post? It sounds like you're saying that if DP is mafia, let's keep him around. If we think he's a townie, let's get rid of him....

 

[johnlarson66]

Not coming to the thread sooner?? I think the only one on that "list" that didn't show early was DP. Let's see I posted like 3-4 times before you came on and posted...and not protecting him but Charlie posted quite a few before you came on also, oh went back and looked Jmax posted a few before you also...so yeah the only one on that list that didn't post before you was DP. Kinda odd for you to say we didn't have good excuses for not posting earlier when you in fact posted after 3 of the 4 on that list.:huh:

I meant they as in DP, instead of he or she, I siad they. I only meant to point out that DP did not have a good excuse for posting so late.

 

[johnlarson66]

Not coming to the thread sooner?? I think the only one on that "list" that didn't show early was DP. Let's see I posted like 3-4 times before you came on and posted...and not protecting him but Charlie posted quite a few before you came on also, oh went back and looked Jmax posted a few before you also...so yeah the only one on that list that didn't post before you was DP. Kinda odd for you to say we didn't have good excuses for not posting earlier when you in fact posted after 3 of the 4 on that list.:huh:

not defending JL, but I think when he said they he was referring to dp.

true, thanks

 

[jpappy789]

No she doesn't.. I'm not saying this is up to the level of the neon julie incident (I don't think she'll ever make that mistake again) But instead of concentrating at the job at hand she is concentrating on the minutia and being overly defensive.. In the past when innocent she really has let it slide and she isn't letting it slide.



We all should be suspicious all I was saying is that there is some merit to the list.. Not everyone but it does have possibilities. Right now I'm still looking at everyone but some more than others simply because they have made themselves more interesting than others.

Well first off I said from my perspective she seems defensvie all the times. I guess I mean that doesn't necessarily mean she is evil or good in itself. Last game she was grilled for her excuses and especially her responses to those that questioned her, she was innocent. The game before that when she was mafia she said some things that probably came across as defensiveness as well. Jm is just a naturally defensive person imo so I can't really use that to say she is evil unless it is glaringly obvious...

And I dont really understand your second response, I never questioned the list I infact agreed with it. All I said after that was that I like the list but I do not like how everyone seems to be agreeing with those same suspects. Although it is night 1 and there is not a whole lot to go on I still think people who appear too friendly and agreeable right off the bat are mafia trying to blend in with the town who ends up butting heads with one another and picking each other off the first few nights...

 

[Madcrawdad]

I know this is going to seem like a knit-pick...but these are "little" things I pick up on, you know you use "roflmao, lol, lmao" alot...you did this the game I played with you when you were evil too, just something to think about.

Funny you should mention that Lady G... Something I noticed about Judge is that she tends to use 'LMAO' ALOT when she plays scum. Kind of a nervous laugh I guess. I've actually been watching for it. I've seen it a few times so far, but nothing worth lynching on at this point.

With that said, when someone has a certain scumtell, it's not a good idea to broadcast it in the thread on Day 1. Pretty much makes that tell useless.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, guy's with 2 teams of Mafia..I think we may have a good chance of lynching one, if we (innocents) work together. Day one always seems to turn into a free for all and the mafia get a free ride. They have an advantage,
though in this game with 2 teams. I can say when I played the games with CIA/FBI and Old/New Mafia...being on the bad side was easy to look innocent since you could really look for baddies and "appear" to be innocent.
I ususally wait until later in day one to vote, because I like to see who votes who and reactions to these votes. But with haveing the 2 teams I think things are different, so I am going to get a vote out there.

For now I Vote to lynch Jmax, this is obviously subject to change. At this point if I were to change it would be to Charlie or JL I believe.

Yes Dp is still out there for me, but for now I think there are bigger and better because I'm almost positive he will "forget" to vote one night and suffer a UD. I realize he is not helping the town if he is innocent...but he is still a number and I would not want to take him out right now because of that. This game is all about numbers in the end, IF he is innocent, no he is of no help as far as finding Mafia...but he is a number.

 

[clown-lover]

Originally Posted by clown-lover
//Game On

OK so a couple of observations on posts that have been made since I took time out to watch my show..

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hooked Newbie
I agree with you in regards to DP, but I'd rather he just retract all votes and die vs. us having to waste a night on him when we can find a mafia. (I tend to suspect there will be a strong push for DP to save Charlie.... Just a hunch).

I could agree with this but it would depend on which side he is really on.. If he is mafia let him stay there because he isn't doing them any good. As of this point he is nothing more than a vote for them. If he is one of us the loss of him won't hurt us townies any because he isn't contributing in any way shape or form to flush mafia from the bushes..

CL, can you clarify this post? It sounds like you're saying that if DP is mafia, let's keep him around. If we think he's a townie, let's get rid of him....

Ok so it came out sort of wrong.. What I'm saying is that if DP is a mafia he really isn't doing them any good other than being a vote and there are more important targets to try and flush out. Its not that I'm against eliminating any mafia but I'm more engaged on trying to find out who the ring leader is by watching who is agreeing with who, who is voting with who in what order etc etc etc.. The things we all look at.

As a townie his loss really isn't going to be a big deal other than we'll be down one person because nothing he posts is of substance or informative in any way shape or form.. He doesn't shake the bushes, he doesn't add anything to the game other than... well you can see what he has added to the game thus far. If thats because of age or something else I have no clue but the reality is I do agree with HN in that an UD would help us if he is a mafia but not if he is a townie.