I've seen many different thoughts on this and all of them are possible. Anyone notice though that the font is orange? Doesn't LGs sig say if she was any color she'd be orange? I know in one of the games he used Green and I attached it to Plantling and was right even though I ended up dismissing the idea.
I have no idea how this says anything about her either way but I just wanted to point it out as it might help us later in the game.
Again, since I haven't seen Bob give this kinds of clue about color before it isn't something I'm quite ready to buy yet. Maybe if more people confirm they've seen this sort of clue before I would but for now I'm not wanting to put too much stock in it.
Grins: She looked guilty before the vote shifting last night. Now she looks even more so to me. She put together a great post, but unfortunately it looks like all of her time was spent trying to defend herself instead of looking at anyone else. .
Hooked, I realize that my first post today was indeed addressing some of what was said in the first game day, but perhaps you missed that I said at the end of it that I would address new thoughts in a separate post. Which I did..about 13 minutes before you posted this.
Clown: The apparent protection of Grins based on the "clue" concerns me. Especially because she never mentioned it or responded to it.
It didn't make sense to address it in day one as one of the intended recipents understood it. You were the other one by the way. I thought you'd have remembered when we were considering what roles others might have had when we were a team. I have answered it today however.
I agree with your thoughts on Ogre, Bkw, Emo, DD, King and Z.
Ok, Blue...this post concerns me very much...it is like a I challenge you post...no "mod powers" are not allowed in the game....to make your case, but I'm sure if a serious matter came up the mod of the game COULD go into something to find out the details. Having said that, I think it would have to be a much more serious matter than this and do not any way think it should be asked of RB or RB even consider it...as the rules say "you can say whatever you want".
Are you going to tell me when communicating evil or good...you have never "watched" PMs??? Cause I have actually had a few ppl tell me you have when on a team with them, I think it was the last time I was on a team, I was told DO NOT PM....blue likes to watch PMs.
Anyway, I am not sure what to think of the "edit" thing and am not going to consider it any longer toward Grins..not after this post.
Yes Blue has used Mod powers during the game, she tried when a team mate of mine and I told her it was cheating. She didn't care but I wasn't going to turn in a player on my team lol.
Thanks to both of you for confirming this.
I say we put up JM Grins and Blue.
Why not your own name I wonder. :lipssealedsmilie: Sincerely if the majority of the town wants to break it down to 3 and tying it I'm not completely against that provided no one feels bullied. My own typos and silliness from feeling crappy or not put me and the town in the spot we're in and I'm willing to take any heat on me. However, I don't like
you picking the 3 people and think the town should. Seems the fair thing would be to take an informal poll and have everyone submit their top 3 suspects, and the 3 names that get picked the most should be the 3 that a tie is tried to be made on. And yes I fully realize that if the poll were to be made at this second I may well end up on it.
OK, well, i had thought i was going to multi quote, but seriously, the length of posts in this game, are crazy! so, in the interest of not making someone read an entire one page post:
Frankly Julz, I'm finding the long posts to be full of good content in day 2. I wish more players would contribute in this way seeing that we lost as many as we did last night. I was part of the laugh and games the first day but it is past time to start being more helpful.
Also, I asked you earlier if I was right about you trying to send a message in the thread recently. I have not yet pointed it out but will if I think it best for the town.
If I am voted to be lynched, please let it be for somethng that is more sunstantial than color codings.
Anyone following this train of thought is suspcious to me.
Sometimes I feel as if anyone that finds you suspicious is worthy of suspiscion to you.
The reason I point out this post is simply because of the style. I find that sometimes Grins, you use this kind of format with the hidden hyperlinks to the posts you speak of and then other times, you use posts with the quotes right out there for all to see without the extra clicking. I could do without these hidden post ones if I was asked but I question why you would use both formats in the first place.
g/o Hope you heal quickly from the throat infection g/o
why would you NOT want to point the post out at this time, Grins? Is the programming not working on your computer or are you just blowing smoke?
DD, first of all I find the reason for not posting a lot believable. Secondly after playing with you in a few games I haven't noticed the same things I did when you were mafia. When you are mafia you seem to get real giggly, when you're innocent (and have time) you can be a bit of a pit bull. No mafia member wants you on their trail as Blue schooled me on in my first game. Point being, I just am not thinking you're mafia. You aren't hiding, the posts you've made have been good ones (even if they have been pointed at me a lot of the time)
As for my posting style, well one thing that annoys me about some is how they make accusations and they don't bother to reference where someone said something. I find that behavior guilty and may always find it guilty. I realize however that I pull up a lot of quotes when I post and when there is the potential to be a post that would break the fricking server if I were to post every darn thing someone said...well I try to minimize it. Additionally I got some flack yesterday for my posting layout so I attempted to make my first post today as easy to read as I could. No attempt to hide anything really, if I were hiding I'd not post a link at all.
The reason I have not yet posted a link to JM's post is because if I was reading it right it would do more harm than good. I'm going to give her a
little bit to answer and if she doesn't know what I'm talking about I'll know I either misread it or she was blowing smoke and I'll make it available for all.
I say this every game, I ost my thoughts as I have them. Sorry if that isnt good enough. Rest assured you wont have to worry about it after this game.
What does that last part mean?
Grins, I don't 'use' friends. :angryfire: I do have morals, even though this is a game. And I would not hit her even if I was a mafia boss, which I am not.
Matt
Fair enough, it was not meant as a slam on your ethics or morals outside of the game. I even have good reason to believe that many don't out and out lie in the game itself. But please do me the favor of answering the original question and telling me why you would not hit her. Why not if she was the best person to hit for your team?
.
Was that last part really needed? I woulda looked over the post if you didnt add the last statment. Looks like you're tryin to reassure ppl that you're not mafia even when it's not neccassary.
It also is interesting that he only says he isn't the mafia boss. Why the distinction of not saying he isn't the boss? I realize the boss makes the hit, but on the team where I was the boss I took the counsel of everyone on my team I sure didn't make the call all on my own.
Ok...heres my reasoning:
emo is playing totally different then last game when he was mafia.
I just don't see LC as being mafia, JMO.
I also don't see beth and cool as mafia...they could be, who knows. I'm saying what I think.
Ice, you know me, I go with my gut feelings 50% of the time, and I am doing that now.
Matt
Emo was also told he gave obvious tells that he was mafia last time. Which would explain his decision to hardly say anything at all this time. It doesn't mean that he is mafia, but it sure doesn't mean he isn't. How can you not suspect LC after his own admission that his intention was to screw with our minds? And to not consider Beth or Cool? They have hardly said anything since last night. Again it doesn't mean they are guilty but why does that throw them to innocent?
Bala grins..and sighs....
...and the game gets serious...kewl....
As for clarification...anything can be possible...unless there is a rule that says it can't happen....
Hardy har har on the first part BalaBob. Yes, I finally got serious and started to post like I wasn't in some..oh I don't know...step throat induced fever? Now on the second part of his quote, any clues what he means?
