Mafia #33 - Bruce Campbell Vs. Army of Darkness

[Dangerdoll]

Was that a slip. Do you know it's an Ashly and not an Ash?

*GAH*...I missed that, now that makes me wonder even more...yes, Doll why would you say Ashly?

Well, since DD is a lady, it may be more natural for her to choose the feminine choice.

Although, I use the Ash/ly thing...this is true, but still just seemed a little odd.

wow! you guys really are grasping here. I only used Ashly brecause I was meaning to put the "LY" in parens but in my haste, left them off. If that makes me gyuilty, boy this game is simple, isn't it. And for a newbie even to cast suspicion toward that? I think if I was going to be evil Ash(LY), I would have been a bit more careful, no? However, I can see the slight suspicion, being day one and all and no one really having too much to go on anyway.

I have been on the same evil team as DD, she was no lady. :lipssealedsmilie:



I can see how DD would be a good choice to be the lone mafia. I don't think she made a slip and like rb's reason that I quoted above. I have been saying lone mafia, just because I have not liked the ash/ashly or ash/ly wording.

I have rb as more innocent. He, like yourself, is not that good at being bad.

:eek3:

JL First as for what I've done for the town was the same that I always do. I come out and say we need to get down to real work not chit chat and yet we still chat. I watched everyones post and styles and looked for the slightest changes. I have found no major change in the posting styles. But I have caught onto a few people that IMO have dropped the ball. One was pixs with the quick jump on RB after Hooked's vote and I asked for a reason and got the cold shoulder. Also If you notice i have been laying out what I think of what ZS did in this game to get my opinions out there and if you notice other folks agree or have themselves said something similer.

Second here is my list and why.

Most possible vet- IMO is DD she is always a low poster in the games I have played and if she stayed a low poster I dont think people would notice too much. Its a great cover.

Most possible middle of the road- It has to be pix because I asked questions of him and they were ignored. Second he has seemed to drop off the radar all together. (Note: Pix if your arthritis is acting up I'm sorry to hear that.)

Most possible Newb- It would have to be Aqua we haven't heard much of a peep out of them and on top of it They being a lone mafia may not know how to react to the situation so they best chose to just hang low and hope no one notices. I mean so far they have one post and its post #255 with "I dont get it where do I vote?" Now I dont know about you but when I started my first game I knew how to vote from reading the rules. But it maybe the Special Hit/turn vote is the one they are asking about because if you check the rules it dont say anything about that. It would be a rookie mistake that could easily be made and looked over. But that is how I see it.

Please feel free to pick my list apart and ask more questions. I will answer anyone you have.

Cat, I completely believe you are using the towns suspicion of the alleged "slip up" to your advantage. You haven't played "games" with me, you were in 1 game and that was the last one. So for you to say I've been laying low or whatever is the biggest farce I've seen.

I have another thought.... with all of us listng out all of our suspicions on multiple people, aren't we giving Ash(LY) an advantage of whom they might like to choose as their convertee? Ash(LY) can simply look at all of our lists and decide who is not on them and is little suspected as one they'd like to have on their side....

 

[Lady G]

That is why I would turn Lady G!

WA??? Why is that, cause I don't like to name who I would turn at this point?

I think just like suspect lists, they could prove useful as the game progresses.

See, yes...I could see maybe after a night fall or two saying who would be a good turn for the evil, but really at this point I only see it as being useful to the evil one. Maybe it is just me and my paranoid ways...but that is the only reason I see it to be useful at this point.

I think it's a good question because it aligns your thought processes with what Zsandman must have been thinking when he chose the first evil.

I'm thinking if it was me I would turn Plant. She seems to use a good combination of analysis, creativity, and subtlety.

No, I don't see how it helps in trying to figure out who or why Z chose who he did for a sole evil one. He would not know who they would pick for a turn, so it has nothing to do with Z and his choice.

 

[Lady G]

wow! you guys really are grasping here. I only used Ashly brecause I was meaning to put the "LY" in parens but in my haste, left them off. If that makes me gyuilty, boy this game is simple, isn't it. And for a newbie even to cast suspicion toward that? I think if I was going to be evil Ash(LY), I would have been a bit more careful, no? However, I can see the slight suspicion, being day one and all and no one really having too much to go on anyway.
:eek3:


Cat, I completely believe you are using the towns suspicion of the alleged "slip up" to your advantage. You haven't played "games" with me, you were in 1 game and that was the last one. So for you to say I've been laying low or whatever is the biggest farce I've seen.

I have another thought.... with all of us listng out all of our suspicions on multiple people, aren't we giving Ash(LY) an advantage of whom they might like to choose as their convertee? Ash(LY) can simply look at all of our lists and decide who is not on them and is little suspected as one they'd like to have on their side....

No, DD....I do not think it really points to you being evil, I have seen you make these "slips" before and it was nothing. I did comment on it yes, and I did add you as a possible choice for Z to pick, because well you are good plain and simple.
Now, Plants vote on you for this "slip" has made me wonder, add that with her post of "who would you turn" is making me wonder even more, because as I stated earlier...I REALLY see her as a good choice to be the only evil one to start the game off with:grinyes:

Yes, I agree with your last Paragraph and is the reason I really do not want to list who I think I would turn IF I were Ashly (yes, I said Ashly because IF it were me, I would be ASHLY...not ASH)

 

[dirtydawg10]

I didn't jump on any bandwagon. I voted first on pix, and am still the only vote there and am not pushing anyone to follow.

RB, what I was saying is you were starting the bandwagon to see who else would get on (I understand the choice of words is poor). I realized you were the first vote. Yet, you voted and then called everyone else out as not having a sack. The best way to influence people is not to tell people who to vote for but to vote first, make your case and hope others follow. To this point your plan is working flawlessly. You already have more recruits to back you up. Let's see who else piles on.

As for who I would flip - Not only do I have no freikin idea what type of player anyone here is - I'm not Evil Ash so I can't flip anyone anyway.

As for my suspect list - take a guess who's at the top
1. RB
2. Judge
3. DD
I am going on gut feelings here.

Now as for the Ash/Ashley thing...am I mistaken or are there to Ash/Ashley's? There is one good and one evil. In most cases I believe people are referring to Evil but in the future maybe this should be clarified as E-Ash or E-Ashley. Just my 2 cents for what it's worth.

 

[Lady G]

You know what...I really see Plant as a good choice, so I retract my vote on Pix and vote to lynch Plant. Of coarse this is subject to change for what ever reason I may see fit.

 

[Lady G]

RB, what I was saying is you were starting the bandwagon to see who else would get on (I understand the choice of words is poor). I realized you were the first vote. Yet, you voted and then called everyone else out as not having a sack. The best way to influence people is not to tell people who to vote for but to vote first, make your case and hope others follow. To this point your plan is working flawlessly. You already have more recruits to back you up. Let's see who else piles on.

As for who I would flip - Not only do I have no freikin idea what type of player anyone here is - I'm not Evil Ash so I can't flip anyone anyway.

As for my suspect list - take a guess who's at the top
1. RB
2. Judge
3. DD
I am going on gut feelings here.

Now as for the Ash/Ashley thing...am I mistaken or are there to Ash/Ashley's? There is one good and one evil. In most cases I believe people are referring to Evil but in the future maybe this should be clarified as E-Ash or E-Ashley. Just my 2 cents for what it's worth.

Yes, there is a evil and a good Ash/ly...guess we really should be more specific when posting on that one.:grinyes:

 

[dirtydawg10]

I meant TWO

Now as for the Ash/Ashley thing...am I mistaken or are there TWO Ash/Ashley's? There is one good and one evil. In most cases I believe people are referring to Evil but in the future maybe this should be clarified as E-Ash or E-Ashley. Just my 2 cents for what it's worth.

 

[Lady G]

Well, Crap Dawg...now I guess we will have to suspect you a little more...that was a typo after all:lipssealedsmilie:

 

[dirtydawg10]

Well, Crap Dawg...now I guess we will have to suspect you a little more...that was a typo after all:lipssealedsmilie:

:rofl:

 

[plantling]

No, DD....I do not think it really points to you being evil, I have seen you make these "slips" before and it was nothing. I did comment on it yes, and I did add you as a possible choice for Z to pick, because well you are good plain and simple.
Now, Plants vote on you for this "slip" has made me wonder, add that with her post of "who would you turn" is making me wonder even more, because as I stated earlier...I REALLY see her as a good choice to be the only evil one to start the game off with:grinyes:

Yes, I agree with your last Paragraph and is the reason I really do not want to list who I think I would turn IF I were Ashly (yes, I said Ashly because IF it were me, I would be ASHLY...not ASH)

Ummm, that's not why I voted DD. I didn't even list that as a reason.

As for lists, I look at it this way. Anything that narrows Evil Ash's choices is a good thing.