Mafia 42: Assassin in the Palace (The Play)

[noodles62]

Tisk Tisk Egg Noodles, this may not be a good idea at all.

Just for the record - I prefer ramen noodles - not egg noodles! LOL

 

[bkw1982]

Ogre you broke one of the "Don'ts" on my list.

If the conversation was in private where the assassin couldn't read it then i'd be all for the list idea. But beacuase the assassin knows that some of the list will contain the king they can easily narrow it down. The one thing that we can not do is give the assassin information.

IMO there isn't a viable way to work outloud as a group to catch the assassin.

Besides whats the differnce between "making a list" and "putting 2 votes on four ppl"? They're both just list, except one has players with votes. In fact your idea is worst then 4 ppl 2 votes idea.

I also see no point in prolonging the votes, oh self proclaimed Captain of the guards.

Just for the record - I prefer ramen noodles - not egg noodles! LOL

Gotcha, Egg Noodles it is.

I know this is a new format, but don't you think you're passed playing the "im a confused" card. If you can come up with an idea to catch an assassin i dont think you're confused at all.


Still waiting on Mal to speak up

 

[noodles62]

Gotcha, Egg Noodles it is.

I know this is a new format, but don't you think you're passed playing the "im a confused" card. If you can come up with an idea to catch an assassin i dont think you're confused at all.

Well, :silly: to you! This is what, my 3rd game and a totally different format. Confusion should be understood. I will not "use it and play it up", but come on!...So far I have no idea how to catch an assassin, but your playing style has always stuck out to me......could be nothing but paranoia but regardless, we are wasting time. We have 2 votes so far and not really much to go on and still...nothing from Mal.

 

[Madcrawdad]

(Im basing this on the voting period ends if someone not only gets 5 votes, but if they just get the majority at that the time. Example: 4-3-2 split between 3 ppl. Clarification please MAD)[/B].

A person must receive the majority of the votes, based upon living players (not upon votes cast). With 9 alive at this point, a candidate will need to receive 5 votes to be lynched.

The exception is if the day goes on for too long and I impose a deadline. If at the time of the deadline nobody receives the required number of votes, the high vote getter is lynched.

 

[bkw1982]

Thanks mad..

Egg Noodles there are 3 votes.....Skimmy Mcskimmerson

Mal-Z
Bkw-Dawg
Dawg-Bkw

 

[noodles62]

OK! So I don't do math.....

 

[noodles62]

Well, this is going too slow. I vote to lynch Malbri just for the lack of participation....this is subject to change of there is anything of substance posted....Gotta go spend time w/ the hubby -will check back later......

 

[Madcrawdad]

Vote count thru post #67

Mal (2) - Z(49), Noodles(67)
BKW (1) - Dawg(50)
Dawg(1) - BKW(51)

No votes from: Ice, Jbradt, LG, Mal, Ogre

With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to lynch...

 

[OgreMkV]

Ogre you broke one of the "Don'ts" on my list.

If the conversation was in private where the assassin couldn't read it then i'd be all for the list idea. But beacuase the assassin knows that some of the list will contain the king they can easily narrow it down. The one thing that we can not do is give the assassin information.

Well, since you didn't publish your list of Don'ts...

It doesn't matter if some of the lists contain the king or not. We would never be able to post lists as guards without putting the king on some of them because the assassin would know instantly who the king is.

IMO there isn't a viable way to work outloud as a group to catch the assassin.

Potentially true...

Besides whats the differnce between "making a list" and "putting 2 votes on four ppl"? They're both just list, except one has players with votes. In fact your idea is worst then 4 ppl 2 votes idea.

I also see no point in prolonging the votes, oh self proclaimed Captain of the guards.

The difference is that the lists (as previously stated) do not divide this group into two smaller groups giving the assassin a chance to work out which group the king is in and halving his workload.

 

[OgreMkV]

To even things up I vote to lynch bkw