Mafia 46: In the Dark

[Opicana]

As I said before, I like Rich for scum, and now strongly suspect LG also.

It might be smarter to go for LG first, but it looks like some are gravitating to Rich. Would like to hear people's thoughts.

Mmmm....I could support a community LadyG vote, if that's the way the town goes.

 

[OgreMkV]

I'm still more sure of Rich than LadyG, but it really looks like a Rich LadyG mafia team left.

Let's just split the vote between them.

 

[OgreMkV]

Just for the record... I vote to lynch Rich

 

[Dangerdoll]

After reading the days events, I think we would be safest in voting for G tonight. Dud had broke the rules and outed from the game and his role was not revealed by Ice... but I think it was done that way in order to create this ton of talk, to make it not so easy for the votes.... I think things are being too thought out.... I'm going with it...

I vote to lynch Lady G

 

[[AC] C-note]

Lady G IS Mafia

By now everyone knows that Lucky has been removed for an apparent rules violation. Some are still questioning what he has said, and appear to be hesitant to claim that Lady G is mafia. These posts by Lucky and LG prove, without a doubt in my mind, that LG is mafia. Please read closely.

This is Lucky's first post where he comes out and confirms, without any doubt, that LG is mafia.

Hey guys sorry for the confusion. Noodles made a really good point, as a town it wouldn't of done any good to have a tie. So I was going to vote for who ever I thought would be the most mafia ish. Well between the two I musta been wrong because dawg was mafia. It was a random vote, but because my vote wasn't doing anything any way I thought why not. And I said I'll explain later because I had like a minute to try to post it, you can look that up!

But lady G, I expected you would vote for me, but it is blatantly obvious that you are the mafia and are just trying to get me out of the way. You have been laying low for a while now, and suddenly changed, as ogre pointed out. I dont know what caused this change in strategy. But I know, you know, that I know who you are. You and dog were a communicating mafia team. FACT. Obviously you can see she is panicing because thats why she is voting for me so early.

People of ACville, if I go out tonight, I can promise you one thing. Lady G is the culprit.

I vote to lynch LadyG

Put that in your pipe and smoke it. Mafia mistress

In this post, Lucky is definitely hinting that he is a communicating innocent.

You are assuming too much, I dont know how to put this, but I know without a doubt in my mind that LadyG is the mafia, and if you vote for her I promise it will not be a mistake.

If not fine, vote for me, and you will see I am as innocent as they come by, (and then some)

I'm sorry I cant explain myself, ane might get kicked for hinting, but trust me on this. LadyG is the mafia.

Here's one from LG now. Note that she's already voted for Lucky in an earlier post, and also defends herself, but she comes right out and says at some point here that she'd be willing to change her vote to Rich...as Rich AND Lucky are her main suspects.

This is absolutely the WRONG thing to say if she's innocent. Think about it. If you're innocent and someone claims that they're a communicating innocent with a confirmed 'mafia' read on you, you would absolutely know 100% that they are lying. They're no longer just a suspect to you...they are CONFIRMED mafia to you, and you don't offer to switch your vote.

I only have a couple minutes here right now, and hope to get back on after a while but I read through what has transpired since I was here last. I don't really have time to pull posts right now but I want to ask and answer a couple things I read.

First about Rich and I being "team mates" how many times have you guys really seen the mafia "teams" vote the same player? Yes, when there is a "train" going on a certain player and there is actually a team of Mafia maybe..but in this style game there were only 3 Mafia at the time (if they got their turn victim) why would 2 of the three vote the same player?

Second, I would be willing to change my vote to Rich I do believe him to be mafia also..he and Lucky are my top suspects right now.

To Lucky...how can you be sooooo sure about my being mafia? As far as I know the only way to be 100% certain about another player is A) they are your team mate, which I know I am NOT. B)Investigations, which again I know we don't have this game. What I see is you have experienced players with you, (Dawg was one) that have let you know or you have read past games and you know how easily ppl will jump to me. The town will decide, but you are blowing alot of smoke with your "I know she is" "Vote with me you wont regret it" posts.

Also to you Lucky, you DID say in your post that you voted me (last night) that you voted me to get ppl to talk, how are you now denying that?

And to whoever it was that said something about me "suddenly going to investigation mode" Sorry, I actually had a little time to read through and bring out some points..normally I only have like a half hour or so on here which gives me enough time to read through and post a quick thought or two. I simply had more time this morning and was able to actually post a bit more thoruough thoughts.

Here's Lucky now saying that he and noodles were CIs...and he isn't really just hinting anymore.

I cant say anything, but another way to be positive is if we tried to reqruit a certain someone, and lost a player because she was on the mafia. Cough cough.

And for the hundreth time, I did not do it so people would talk. I did it so that mutes and quite mafia members who do nothing for the town but make blatanly obvious comments, like you, will be out of the way. And all the rest of the people have many post counts, which makes it easier to decipher a specific person. This is the last time I am explaining this so make sure to read it.

Again from Lucky about being a CI.

I never actually said what I am, there is no rule about hinting. If there is let me be taken from this game.

And ogre, very impressive. But why are you taking such an intrest in me? Those quotes have nothing to do with your accusations about rich and me why is that? You think that those quotes were defending dirty dog? Wow your mistaken, I was just oftaken by c-notes oddly aggresive behavior against him, which ended up being the right move.

Anyone else want to make the wrong decision and vote for me?

More from Lucky doing a little more than just hinting.

If either team chooses someone already on a team then a player from the choosing team dies. This will be your form of investigation. Death will be randomly chosen from the players of said team. Player will be notified by PM.

Taken from the rules, not the person that sent the reqruitment but a random selection on the team. If that is the case and I am already going anyway I could tell you why noods isn't around. But I have a good feeling you know.

Here's another one from LG. Defending herself against Lucky, but not as strongly as one would expect since if innocent she would KNOW that Lucky is mafia at this point.

Hmmm, you didn't say you did it so ppl would talk...look up at the post where you voted me Lucky...now what is highlighted? Then you post how you didn't want to start a train on me and was noticing others talking about me, hmmm if you thought I was really mafia woudn't you want others to notice and talk about me. What were you and your team mates going to try and bring me over, then you noticed others talking about me and it made you nervous? So you tried to post something to draw some heat off me?

Another reason maybe Noodles is gone is because you and the other team BOTH tried to turn her...causing her death, now you are trying to make it look like you are a CI and tried to turn me in the end loosing Noods because I was a Mafia? Nice twist there Lucky are you still talking with Dawg, is he telling you what to say and how to twist it to look like you are a CI instead of his team mate?:lipssealedsmilie:

Here is a VERY interesting post from LG. Note where she says to Lucky that 'I still THINK you and yours are trying your hardest to set me up.' Once again, WRONG THING TO SAY. If she's innocent, she KNOWS that Lucky is setting her up...doesn't just think it.

Using 'think' versus 'know' here is a really big deal if she's claiming innocence.

Actually, Lucky....if rules are broken it isn't taking one for the team, it is taking the game out as most the time the game is called when that happens.

Although I do not know that rules were actually broken, I still think you and yours are trying your hardest to "set me up" as you know I am not one of you, and most likely you tried to turn Noods when the CI's did also causing her death..that is what I believe

Finally, LG is off to bed, saying she should have a good read by morning. Don't you think that she'd still be coming at Lucky harder that this? I know that if I KNEW someone was scum that I'd be going through their posts with a fine-toothed comb and coming out with guns blazing. But she never really does.

Whatever you say Lucky....good night all, should have a good read by morning

I think that it's pretty clear that LG's reaction to Lucky (especially using 'think' vs. 'know') confirms that she's mafia.

As it's quite possible that it's 5 innocents versus 3 mafia at this point, and an incorrect lynch (with a successful mafia turn) could put the town at 3 v 4, and cost the game, I really think that we should go with the SURE THING.

I really like Rich for scum, but Lady G would be a confirmed mafia kill.

I vote to lynch Lady G

Feedback please.

 

[[AC] C-note]

current vote count

Rich 3 - Ogre 701/773, JL 753, Opi 763

LG 2 - DD 774, cnote 775

no votes from LG, Rich, MC ...and I think that Ice confirmed everyone still has a retraction available, as any votes for Lucky didn't count.

 

[Opicana]

Okay, C-Note. I am with you 100% on this one. You bring up a valid point about going for the sure thing...I'm convinced LadyG is also Mafia, so may as well.

I retract my vote on Rich and vote to lynch LadyG.

 

[[AC] C-note]

Addendum to posts 775/776

Just wanted to edit both 775 & 776 by way of post...

Post 775
Got the number of remaining players wrong. It's 9, not 8 as I had listed. Worst case scenario, town could be at 6 v 3. I still think the game can be lost though IF:

Incorrect lynch
Successful mafia turn
CIs accidentally target mafia for recruit

Post 776

I listed Rich, LG and MC as not voting....maelstrom has also not voted.

 

[Lady G]

Well, this is my only chance to be here today...haven't really had much of a chance to read all that has happened and I have to go to work so I wont be here for nightfall...

All I can tell you C-Note about your posts to me are well, I learned a LONG time ago in these games rather you are innocent or not you can't "defend" your self to hard or ppl twist your words and use it against you as a way to get you lynched.

Anyway..I vote to lynch Rich

 

[Dangerdoll]

wow G... I would think you would've had more than that...