MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[joander123]

i do believe that BKW needs investigating, as they switched over to me very quickly on day 2.... to try and save JM.

The ones i was looking at were
BKW
DD
KOTD (obvi innocent now)
mee-mee

 

[mee-mee]

I hate that OgreMvK used me in his plea to stay alive. It was in him using my name that I knew he was not the detective. He had already twice before threw my name out there as a possible target.

I think mee-mee, dangerdoll, and malbri all need some sort of attention paid to them.

Looking at this game from the outside, my name would be on the list of possible mafia. I just hope we are able to lynch the rest of them before I am a prime target.

As far as mee-mee goes, the night time vote (which rbishop did not delete) after the votes were in makes me wonder. There has been a few other things.

I know a lot of you want to talk about it, but I am going to throw my vote out there (I can always change it). I like voting early.

I vote to lynch mee-mee

I think the mafia are on the run, big time. Good job everyone.

A list of 3 here

Hah that would suck. Zombie mafia without notice hit 2 unsuspecting innocents.

My top three:

(1) DD

(2) Ice

(3) jpappy

CL

CL has 3 for a list

Heres my list and reasons why. Once we get a top 3 or so we cam all agree on we can start pulling quotes and discuss.

Bkw - needs looking into, did a lot of protecting of JM

Jensons a lot of bandwagon jumping. Sit back see which way the vote is going and join as to not look conspicuous

Mee-mee last 10 minutes of day and throws a nonsense vote in a close match Then 2nd night she throws another worthless vote. Then after night falls and she looks at the posts and wants to vote Ogre even though he lost in a landslide. To late for the train?

Jpappys is after Jo with a vengance almost as fixated on him as I was Coler but so was KOTD

DD, I've always had trouble picking out her roles even when just watching. I think either innocent or bad at being mafia.

Mal not voting bears watching

CL pretty much just following others, thrown a few lists in here and there not much explanation to the reasons why.

Jl vacation slows his vote understandably, Ogre fingering him leans him to innocent

Jo I believe innocent, so must at least half of us or he'd be gone. Becomes a Mets fan and I'll throw my body in front of a car to save him from a hit lol.


Sploke Had no real opinion, I was to stuck on Coler, when he buddied up with Coler I started to suspect. Back to a 5.

Coler I'm convinced he is innocent, after all the accusations I threw he didn't answer any of them defensively

Zman Detective,obviously innocent

KOTD vig, innocent

We're getting far enough into the game where EVERYONE should have some idea. I could understand confusion in the early going with so much going on but by now you should know why you think what you think.

and it seems you have a list of 4 maybe..top 4...so why cant I have a list of three and now I will make it for...even though there are only 2 left...

 

[jpappy789]

3..Jpappy-read post 1000..2 wrong lynches no there was only one successful lynch and that was the lynching of Ogre...and and King wasnt even lynched...there was only Z and Ogre...not unless I missed something in Kings post or something between posts 998 and 1000...

Did you not see my explanation? It doesn't matter what word I used, I said that the mafia was mad because they missed coler on night 1 and the doc saved Dectective ZSandmann night 2. I never mentioned the lynching that gets voted on by the town! You said "two wrong lynches, no there was only one successful one" that sentence doesn't even make sense!!! Z and ogre?!?! I never said in one night!!! You seriously moved up on my mafia meter for your lame reasoning!

 

[mee-mee]

Edit...post 1024 should not even be in there...

 

[mee-mee]

Did you not see my explanation? It doesn't matter what word I used, I said that the mafia was mad because they missed coler on night 1 and the doc saved Dectective ZSandmann night 2. I never mentioned the lynching that gets voted on by the town! You said "two wrong lynches, no there was only one successful one" that sentence doesn't even make sense!!! Z and ogre?!?! I never said in one night!!! You seriously moved up on my mafia meter for your lame reasoning!

And I was just going by exactly what you typed...dont ya hate it when people take what ya say out of context and then get defensive...

Hmmm. Z, at least you have the towns help now. So let's see...you, KOTD, and Coler are for sure innocent. KOTD? Who is your top player for your hit? You don't have to answer if you don't want to....

and why the sudden interest in King's list of Mafia supposed...

 

[jpappy789]

And I was just going by exactly what you typed...dont ya hate it when people take what ya say out of context and then get defensive...



and why the sudden interest in King's list of Mafia supposed...

Ummm, no. You did take what I said, but in the completely different context. I simpley said that the mafia must be mad because they botched the murder of coler and becasue the doc saved ZS. I never mentioned ogre or KOTD...

I am interested in who KOTD is thinking because he basically has one night to hit someone. Revealing who it is might bring out some other players to their defence and then people's sides should be clear.

 

[mee-mee]

So we have till Saturday morning 5 am to put in a vote,,,and this time I am not going to get on the train late... since I dont have to work tomorrow I can post and read to my heart's content for the game...and maybe we can flush out some Mafia...or if we already have ...

 

[FireDancer7905]

Ok, I just got home. I explained why I voted for KOTD. I also said that I was leaving the house, which I did about 3 minutes after posting. I had no way to read OCler's post and retract my vote, and then vote accordingly. And I'm pretty sure the vig hit does go in before a lynching or mafia hit. I asked rb about it last game. Coler, I am not mafia. I played better as mafia than I do as a townie. Sorry. I am going to eat dinner, anxiously stare at my poor, lonely fishies, and post my thoughts on the players. Off topic: My hubby brought home a 20g long to replace my 10g. It's my b-day present!!!! I'm gonna re-stock what I lost, and add a school of cories! I'm very excited! ~brandy

 

[FireDancer7905]

My list, my reasons:

Innocent:

Jensons: I am innocent

Coler: Still sure he’s innocent

Zsandy: innocent, detective

CL: no mafia vibes, feel like he’s helping the town

KOTD: innocent, vigilante – sorry about the vote! I really had the best of intentions and was trying to keep my word

jl: ogre fingered him, he’s probably innocent, unless ogre did that to distance himself from jl and give the mafia a hand- but I’m not feeling that

Unsure/Hard to Read:

Sploke: no real read

Joander: still think he may be being guided by the other mafia, but have no proof, so unsure

Mee-mee: my feeling is innocent, just busy- though Ogre pulled this off pretty well, too

Mal: if DD isn’t mafia, then Malbri is

Mafia:

DD: still think she is suspicious – voted for jo, not Ogre, though a vote anywhere else would have no effect on stopping the lynch

Ice: didn’t vote, protecting jpappy, throwing me and mee-mee under the train

Jpappy: he is trying to get KOTD to spill who he will hit.. mafia trying to keep his own safe?

A final note on my innocence: I think that Ogre put his vote for KOTD to "go with" Coler's list. He didn't change it, though Coler cautioned me to, and left Coler with more evidence to muster against me. If I was mafia, it would make no sense for me to place my vote with Ogre, because I would know that it would bring heat down on me. As it stands, I explained my vote, and stand by that reasoning, though it was in fact a poor choice, yet again. I feel fairly comforatble with my mafia list above, and will vote for one of them "tonight."

~brandy

 

[IceH2O]

Go ahead and start a band wagon on me...You all will see that I AM AN INNOCENT...AND JL AND SPLOKE AND JPAPPY;;;you know I am an Innocent because now I change my list to you three....

1...Ice...
2...JL
3...Sploke...

you are probably the 3 remaining Mafia besides DD...and I am going to stick with you three and keep looking at DD. also...

I thought you were saying the 3 remaining mafia plus DD.I guess your trying to say your 3 remaining suspects.

and it seems you have a list of 4 maybe..top 4...so why cant I have a list of three and now I will make it for...even though there are only 2 left..

Heck the more people you list the better, even innocents and why

Ice: didn’t vote, protecting jpappy, throwing me and mee-mee under the train


If I was mafia, it would make no sense for me to place my vote with Ogre, because I would know that it would bring heat down on me.

Didn't vote? When haven't I voted. I vote 24 hours early when I know the day ends at 6 PM just to make sure I have a vote in lol.
Don't see where I'm protecting Jpappy either, just dropped him down on the list because I think you and mee mee are acting a little more strangley then him, or DD, for that fact.