MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[ZSandmann]

Agreed, jpappy and DD are my top two. Had a rough day at work so I'm chilling for a bit but I promise to get back on the ball ASAP. I'd like to see lists, at least Top 3 from everyone, I imagine the two? remaining Mafia will be laying low now. Also, we are up to four deaths now so there may be a ghost vote after the next Night. We also need to remember the Random Post and who knows what other Shamylanian twists rb has cooked up. I love this Round so far, it has been a blast.

 

[Cory Lover]

My top three:

(1) DD

(2) Ice

(3) jpappy

CL

 

[ZSandmann]

Right now lists are fine but before we vote we need reasons too. I could be way off, I'm sure I'm off. Someone has to be tricking me like HN did last Round.

 

[IceH2O]

Heres my list and reasons why. Once we get a top 3 or so we cam all agree on we can start pulling quotes and discuss.

Bkw - needs looking into, did a lot of protecting of JM

Jensons a lot of bandwagon jumping. Sit back see which way the vote is going and join as to not look conspicuous

Mee-mee last 10 minutes of day and throws a nonsense vote in a close match Then 2nd night she throws another worthless vote. Then after night falls and she looks at the posts and wants to vote Ogre even though he lost in a landslide. To late for the train?

Jpappys is after Jo with a vengance almost as fixated on him as I was Coler but so was KOTD

DD, I've always had trouble picking out her roles even when just watching. I think either innocent or bad at being mafia.

Mal not voting bears watching

CL pretty much just following others, thrown a few lists in here and there not much explanation to the reasons why.

Jl vacation slows his vote understandably, Ogre fingering him leans him to innocent

Jo I believe innocent, so must at least half of us or he'd be gone. Becomes a Mets fan and I'll throw my body in front of a car to save him from a hit lol.


Sploke Had no real opinion, I was to stuck on Coler, when he buddied up with Coler I started to suspect. Back to a 5.

Coler I'm convinced he is innocent, after all the accusations I threw he didn't answer any of them defensively

Zman Detective,obviously innocent

KOTD vig, innocent

We're getting far enough into the game where EVERYONE should have some idea. I could understand confusion in the early going with so much going on but by now you should know why you think what you think.

 

[IceH2O]

This is about the order I'm thinking though a couple near the top can be flipped around.

I moved Jpappy down just because I was on KOTD for the same reason and he turned out to be innocent.

I just don't like mee-mees voting record.

Jensons waits till the last moments before throwing a vote. Almost like she is waiting to see if she can tip the vote to take out who she thinks is more dangerous to her.

 

[johnlarson66]

I hate that OgreMvK used me in his plea to stay alive. It was in him using my name that I knew he was not the detective. He had already twice before threw my name out there as a possible target.

I think mee-mee, dangerdoll, and malbri all need some sort of attention paid to them.

Looking at this game from the outside, my name would be on the list of possible mafia. I just hope we are able to lynch the rest of them before I am a prime target.

As far as mee-mee goes, the night time vote (which rbishop did not delete) after the votes were in makes me wonder. There has been a few other things.

I know a lot of you want to talk about it, but I am going to throw my vote out there (I can always change it). I like voting early.

I vote to lynch mee-mee

I think the mafia are on the run, big time. Good job everyone.

 

[Sploke]

Wow well played everyone, nicely done RB, and way to go doc. As far as protecting people the next night, I would say the detective or mayor would take priority over the vig...sorry KOTD, but even if you get whacked, if you make a hit it will at least go through before the mafia one. Just a thought.

My top picks right now are mee-mee, bkw and jpappy. Lot of switching around. Ice is now pushing me toward the innocent side, I would call him a 6 or so right now for me. DD, who knows with her. It seems the only time she posts is when there's a direct accusation, not really any analysis. Quiet mafia or just detached from the game. Although throwing all that "you only suspect me because my name is on the screen in big red letters" crap around...come on, gimme a break. Mee-mee's vote attempt last night, and earlier in the game, don't make too much sense to me but I'll have to go back and review. Thats all for now, I'm going to bed.

 

[IceH2O]

I hate that OgreMvK used me in his plea to stay alive. It was in him using my name that I knew he was not the detective. He had already twice before threw my name out there as a possible target.

I think its good he used you, helped push you towards innocent IMO.

 

[johnlarson66]

Here is a day one quote from OgreMkV -

Coler, have you given reasoning for those four and I just missed it?

A few thoughts from my side of the board.

1) Mee-mee hasn't said much. She had one post and then nothing. I would expect a little more from her.

2) Where did Cory Lover get off to? another hit and run poster.

3) I guess I could say the same for the other three or four hit-n-run posters.

4) Clown-Lover - what the heck, with all the stats man? Let it go. Very distracting.

Hooked liking it.

I guess the ones that I'm most suspicious of are the very low posters. I mean, it is a Sunday, what better day to get involved. I know I have family, but work starts tomorrow.

Anyway, my randomness is going again... have at it.

Here is a day two quote -

I'm guessing that no one remembers my posts because they were some 20-15 pages ago. I said the same thing mee-mee.

I'd also like to point out that mee-mee is doing the exact same thing she did night one, to vote to lynch someone that has no real chance of being lynched... thereby keeping herself off the radar.

I agree that JLarnson is one to watch... but is he vote worthy now?

I'm almost tempted to vote for mee-mee and do the same thing she did

Malbri still hasn't voted nor has bkw. Talk about lying low.

I'm telling you, I really think the mafia is in stealth mode and laughing there tails off at all of us pointing fingers at each other.

I think mee-mee at this point had voted for me.

The more I think about this, the more I think mee-mee is mafia.

 

[mee-mee]

My list as it stands.

MAFIA = 1

Dangerdoll – 2
jpappy789 – 2
bkw1982 – 3
IceH2O – 5
johnlarson66 - 5
joander123 – 5 (He is either Innocent or a Mafia fall man)
Jensons – 6
Mee-mee – 6
Cory Lover – 7
Malbri - 7
sploke – 8
ZSandmann 10 – Detective
KingOfTheDeep – 10 Vigilante
Coler – 10 Innocent
INNOCENT = 10

I should definitely be a 10, for I am a Townie just like the ones that arent the Mafia...and The Mafia know I am not a Mafia member...I stated my reasons for who I voted for...night one Malbri- acting like GGF did in game 2, JohnLarson-for going for CL2 and Joander on the very first vote for both...I am still keeping my eyes on him...and I had to work a long day yesterday, worked 15 and a half hours, and when I got home I went right to be...

Heres my list and reasons why. Once we get a top 3 or so we cam all agree on we can start pulling quotes and discuss.

Bkw - needs looking into, did a lot of protecting of JM

Jensons a lot of bandwagon jumping. Sit back see which way the vote is going and join as to not look conspicuous

Mee-mee last 10 minutes of day and throws a nonsense vote in a close match Then 2nd night she throws another worthless vote. Then after night falls and she looks at the posts and wants to vote Ogre even though he lost in a landslide. To late for the train?

Jpappys is after Jo with a vengance almost as fixated on him as I was Coler but so was KOTD

DD, I've always had trouble picking out her roles even when just watching. I think either innocent or bad at being mafia.

Mal not voting bears watching

CL pretty much just following others, thrown a few lists in here and there not much explanation to the reasons why.

Jl vacation slows his vote understandably, Ogre fingering him leans him to innocent

Jo I believe innocent, so must at least half of us or he'd be gone. Becomes a Mets fan and I'll throw my body in front of a car to save him from a hit lol.


Sploke Had no real opinion, I was to stuck on Coler, when he buddied up with Coler I started to suspect. Back to a 5.

Coler I'm convinced he is innocent, after all the accusations I threw he didn't answer any of them defensively

Zman Detective,obviously innocent

KOTD vig, innocent

We're getting far enough into the game where EVERYONE should have some idea. I could understand confusion in the early going with so much going on but by now you should know why you think what you think.

The first day or second day votes were after 6pm central standard time...I had to go to work and take care of stuff and got home too late to even get a vote in, and I had to catch up on all the posts that were made...

This is about the order I'm thinking though a couple near the top can be flipped around.

I moved Jpappy down just because I was on KOTD for the same reason and he turned out to be innocent.

I just don't like mee-mees voting record.

Jensons waits till the last moments before throwing a vote. Almost like she is waiting to see if she can tip the vote to take out who she thinks is more dangerous to her.

And I voted for people who I thought were good enough to vote for, until I got more conclusive info from the one who gave the best info on the Mafia...

I hate that OgreMvK used me in his plea to stay alive. It was in him using my name that I knew he was not the detective. He had already twice before threw my name out there as a possible target.

I think mee-mee, dangerdoll, and malbri all need some sort of attention paid to them.

Looking at this game from the outside, my name would be on the list of possible mafia. I just hope we are able to lynch the rest of them before I am a prime target.

As far as mee-mee goes, the night time vote (which rbishop did not delete) after the votes were in makes me wonder. There has been a few other things.

I know a lot of you want to talk about it, but I am going to throw my vote out there (I can always change it). I like voting early.

I vote to lynch mee-mee

I think the mafia are on the run, big time. Good job everyone.

I have already explained about the reasons why I voted the way I did, and now I can say I will be voting for the ones that everyone else votes for, from the key players because now I can see and I did also suspect the ones a few have listed so far, I just wanted to hear what everyone else had to say...but go ahead and vote for me if you want, Detective or Mayor or Vigilante investigate me and you WILL SEE THAT I AM AN INNOCENT ALSO...but do what you want...I am not going to do the same thing that JM did and try to defend what I did outside of others votes...even though she was a Mafia,

My top 3 are...
1..DD-she is saying and acting just like she did in Game 3...
2..Ice-casting doubt on me and saying I am sporadic, yet I may be, but he is screaming Mafia at me the whole time...
3..Jpappy-read post 1000..2 wrong lynches no there was only one successful lynch and that was the lynching of Ogre...and and King wasnt even lynched...there was only Z and Ogre...not unless I missed something in Kings post or something between posts 998 and 1000...