I really have to go but it would definitely help me anyway if you would explain more the strategy on voting DD and also are you basically calling out ZS as mucs/likely mucs/you know, much as you can be sure of anything etc. ?
Mafia #51 - Mafia Citizens - The Play
- Thread starter johnlarson66
- Start date
I really have to go but it would definitely help me anyway if you would explain more the strategy on voting DD and also are you basically calling out ZS as mucs/likely mucs/you know, much as you can be sure of anything etc. ?
The above bolded and red part is very odd.
1) You supposedly knew nothing about a protection on Zig, therefore not a rebel
2) Therefore you could be a citizen or a mafia member w/o protection powers
3) However you then guess that is was bala
4) If you don't know ANYTHING about the protection, why think bala? Why not the rebels or mafia?
A part of me is thinking that plant was trying to push Zig into the clear. But I am not sure, I could just be misreading this post...
im not saying they should be connected as in working together or something of that nature. But, why did the rebels pick them out of everyone available figuring out the mucs strategy if it isn't just pulling numbers could help us figure something out about them.
My guess is that they were either fishing for PR's or trying to get the good players out of the game or both. In playing mafia I have found that the scum players rarely try to overthink the hits by targeting players that will lead to other players getting looked at, if you catch my drift. Usually it is to get rid of players who are just good at the game...but again, I could easily be wrong, which is why I don't like thinking about it too much. :grinyes:
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
protection isn't for only one night, who's to say you are not offering the info form tomorrow??
mostlycichlids
Cichlid Specialist
Actually I have read the rules several times, I now understand, had my take on them twisted a bit. I still feel you Zsand and plant are in some way scummy....maybe you put the protection on Mad, we wont know till tomorrows nightfall (or today), in a sense. Zsand has asked people to post a list and asked more than once who who's top suspects were...including you. Seems to me like you and him definately have some kind of team thing going on along with plant.
This needs to be looked at more, but where do you come in here? I think zsand is definately scum though, still not sure what your role is in it though plant.
If you put a protection on TRS and voted to lynch him then it wouldnt matter because he would come back the next night, rebel scum hold that power. Now did you do that, I don't know but it does need to be addressed.
Very true..but it don't mean protection doesnt need to figured out before the next night?
MC you definitely have not read the rules well enough. Mad was HIT, protections only work for LYNCHES.
You are acting far too suspicious right now but again, I don't think JL would add you as a rebel. Not yet anyways...
And why would me and ZS, who are supposedly in cahoots with plant, name her as a top suspect? Why would we try to have any connection at all? We're better players than that, aren't we?
You are acting far too suspicious right now but again, I don't think JL would add you as a rebel. Not yet anyways...
And why would me and ZS, who are supposedly in cahoots with plant, name her as a top suspect? Why would we try to have any connection at all? We're better players than that, aren't we?
And I wouldn't be surprised if the Rebels have protected the person who they suspect would be the popular lynch candidate, probably Kashta. Especially when they hit Mad who was all over her. It appears you are trying to push Kashta now after two days of hesitation on her. Seems to me you are trying to lead the town by the nose.
We have been trying to get Rebels all along, right? Well it would be nice to nail one but at least don't get led by the nose as we did last nite into voting off someone who they most likely protected.
You should read that part b4 the part you bolded in red as it explained that the protections had to be submitted b4 nitefall for the following night's protection. SO any protection should have been submitted even b4 I voted for Zigman. JL should not have accepted any protections an hour b4 nitefall. Unless the Rebels or the Wiseguys had the foresight to protect Zigman which is not indicated by early voting, it must have been a Bala protection. Therefore If Zig was a citizen b4 he was lynched, he should still be a citizen. But I have no way of knowing. Only an educated guess.
And I did not quote you Coler, but yes I seriously think ZSand is a Rebel Mucs and he is trying to lead the town by it's nose. If you go back and read his posts or any of Mad's cases on Zsand you will see that he ever so slightly warned votes against Kashta. And he denied it but he ever so slightly indicated that Ice, who was on the Kashta train, might presumably not be a citizen b/c of the blue mist. And Rebels must be sharing notes because Kasha's post earlier tried to say that the four ppl we lost might not be citizens either. Whether she was serious or trying to get ppl to vote her is questionable. But for some odd reason Z is all for giving Kashta up today, right after nitefall in fact. Does that not sound suspicious to anyone?
As for voting DD, IMO she is a likely Rebel candidate. As I have said her low posting and not having much to say and her iffy stance on Kashta is very suspect. I think I have seen her much more active as an innocent townie and kinda hiding until her name is brought up when she is evil. And there is not a likely chance that the Rebels would have protected her as her name has not been tossed around much.
Me and Plant on the same team :drool: that's rich. Why do you say me and Plant are working together to me, then say you don't know what Plant is to her? And you'll have to trust me here but if I was planning to turn someone with a protection, Red would NOT be at the top of my list...
