Mafia #57: The Great Mafia War- The Game

[IceH2O]

I'll post right out in the open I have Annie way down my list.

Due to his actions and the actions of others against him.

Can you think of a reason why if mafia he would risk dying day 1 by coin flip?

He could have voted for a number of other ppl to add another name into the coin flip and lower his risk even more if he was.

 

[OgreMkV]

Maybe we should make this a two horse race between John and Annie. Everyone else is really set on Annie and I really think we need someone to counter the that train. Just as a way to tell the sheep from the wolves.

My top two right now are John and RB.

RB: The problem with him is that he knows how this game is played and still makes only one or two posts per day. He could be anything and there's no evidence one way or another.

John: Yeah, it's kinda OMGUS, but it's also that I agree with Ice about a lot of things concerning Annie right now.

Now, the biggest thing in my mind at this point is where in the heck are Wycco, ZSand, and Zaffy? I know they've posted, but they are all generally more active that this.

 

[judgemax]

I'll post right out in the open I have Annie way down my list.

Due to his actions and the actions of others against him.

Can you think of a reason why if mafia he would risk dying day 1 by coin flip?

He could have voted for a number of other ppl to add another name into the coin flip and lower his risk even more if he was.

there was no coin flip?.. why do you feel annie is less suspect?

 

[Dangerdoll]

:swear: 2 innocents in one night. :swear:

i vote to lynch ogre

he has to be mafia, and if he isnt, RB is next.

ok, so why does Ogre "have to be" mafia... and if not, why does RB?

I vote to lynch ICE

bravo for blending in the game and not even being noticed..... now where's your reasoning?

Everyones on my list including Ogre. I just listed the ones I'm more apt to think are mafia due to actions.

Its the reason you used to vote Annie. Maybe not yours as much as LG and DDs so maybe you shouldn't be on the list as high but it bothers me that you are ,even if you think you weren't, pushing for Annie votes.

ok, so why is my reasoning so suspicious? * hasppened to think he slipped up big time and then the crazy stunt he pulled before nightcall "just to mess with the mod" is even more ridiculous and a sloppy stunt to pull....

 

[IceH2O]

there was no coin flip?.. why do you feel annie is less suspect?

There was a coin flip between

Annie
Dawg
Rb
Kash
LG


he could have added into the mix

you (jm)
me(ice)
Luv
Wycco
Zaffy
DD

or just been a kill vote on any of the 4 already in the coin flip.

 

[johnlarson66]

Everyones on my list including Ogre. I just listed the ones I'm more apt to think are mafia due to actions.

Its the reason you used to vote Annie. Maybe not yours as much as LG and DDs so maybe you shouldn't be on the list as high but it bothers me that you are ,even if you think you weren't, pushing for Annie votes.

I think my reasons for my vote on Annie were solid, as solid as day 2 votes are. I don't get the attempt to pin Kash's death on anyone. She had two votes. No one placed a third vote that stuck (Annie did with his messing around votes). Rb even posted that he was watching the #3 votes or something.

Kash was killed by a coin toss.

So lets say I am "pushing for Annie votes." Would I take the lead on something like that if I were mafia? On day 2? Maybe if I was trying to lynch a teamate to gain the towns trust. So if that is case, you might as well lynch Annie. I can see me as a suspect and I prefer to play as a suspect, but I think you can do better than blaming my vote on Annie. It was Ogre's comment about me "leaping" on Annie that got my attention from him.

I have switched to Ogre. I could see myself switching to Luv. I think they have been told to settle down and are not posting much.

 

[johnlarson66]

I'll post right out in the open I have Annie way down my list.

Due to his actions and the actions of others against him.

Can you think of a reason why if mafia he would risk dying day 1 by coin flip?

He could have voted for a number of other ppl to add another name into the coin flip and lower his risk even more if he was.

I agree 100% with this.

 

[johnlarson66]

Maybe we should make this a two horse race between John and Annie. Everyone else is really set on Annie and I really think we need someone to counter the that train. Just as a way to tell the sheep from the wolves.

My top two right now are John and RB.

RB: The problem with him is that he knows how this game is played and still makes only one or two posts per day. He could be anything and there's no evidence one way or another.

John: Yeah, it's kinda OMGUS, but it's also that I agree with Ice about a lot of things concerning Annie right now.

Now, the biggest thing in my mind at this point is where in the heck are Wycco, ZSand, and Zaffy? I know they've posted, but they are all generally more active that this.

Why not make it a two horse race between me and Rb? And what train are you talking about?

Just when I think about taking my vote off of Ogre, he posts this gem. This has to drive your teamates crazy. Your vote on Rb is because he is playing EXACTLY like he does every game.

You are better off placing your OMGUS vote on me.

 

[johnlarson66]

Here are some interesting day one events -

Ogre retracts his day one vote on Rb (who is his best suspect today) and votes to lynch Annie. Dawg has already voted Annie.

I retract my vote for Rb and vote to lynch Annie.

Going to a party today will be back late. I do this only because of the supposed issue with really wanting to play and waiting 24 hours. Presumably because Annie needed to communicate with team mates.

Best there is for day 1.

Ice agrees.

I can see that logic...

What do you have to say to that Annie?

dangerdoll hops on there.

I am on my way out the door and don't think I will be back before nightcall.... so because I still see nothing better, I am going for the vote on Annie. I vote to lynch Annie

Here Annie gives his excuse. Pretty much after he gets some votes. I think the timing is a little suspect, but I have had times where I really wanted to play, but just had to wait to log onto the site.

Well, my RL is a horror show right now. I'm in the middle of a messy divorce and work is very busy at the moment.

Are you telling me you think the fact that I posted 24 hours after the thread started, but that i posted I had mafia withdrawls is a good enough reason to hang someone, then by all means join growing the mob.

Darn, citizen again.

The more I read and the more I have Annie leaning less mafia.

 

[johnlarson66]

Nah Annie, I don't agree with Ogre at all. I just wanted to see who would jump on next using that reason as an excuse. Its a weak reason even on Day 1 IMO.

I don't think any of us if put on a mafia team would wait to post anything until we communicated with our team. Day 1 is just mostly babble, not anything you really need to talk over with a team.

I do have to say though that weirder things have happened.

I won't be jumping on that train. I like my Luv vote for mentioning RB peeked her interest then votes Wycco for no apparent reason. It seems more scummy to me.

Ice clears up his thoughts, he did not agree with Ogre at all.