Mafia #6.....The Play

[KingOfTheDeep]

i've already stated why i will be less vocal this game...if i have time..i post..if i have no time..i dont post.

question..how was CL lynched?..have we not figured that out yet?..4 innocents in one night...crazy

and the snitch list..i'd say mad was my top suspect after that..

 

[Madcrawdad]

Here is what I was able to dig up on Mee-mee. These aren't all of her posts, and are only my interpretation. I highly recommend others continue to investigate as well..... Mee-mee, don't get freaked. I'm going to be doing the same for others on the list as well. This post may sound a little accusatory, but that's just how I write when I pull this stuff together.

Here I'm listing only part of a multi-quote post by Mee-mee. In it she mostly sounds off about folks wanting to lynch JudgeMax, and how she didn't think that's a good idea. At the end of her post, she inserts this quote from MikenDanielle, and responds that she kind of agrees w/ Mike that I appear to be mafia, but gives no real reason why. No biggie.

Or Mad felt worried we were on to him and decided tot ry and restart the Mike train.

That is what I am kind of seeing in his posts, maybe he knows more than he is letting on...

A little later she votes for MND, and gives a decent reason. She also posts her list of top mafia...

With the inconsistant voting of Mike (that is the exact same way I voted in Game 4, when I was Mafia, got me figured out right away and lynched)

I vote for Mike....

My list is...
Mike
Mad
HN

This next post is where it gets a little interesting IMO. Coler has kicked me in front of the train, and Mee-mee claims to be unsure of what Coler is up to. Is Coler mafia just protecting MND, or is he onto something with Mad? 'Oh what the heck, I'll vote for Mad. But Coler, I'm not taking responsibility....you'll need to eat my stuffed bear if you're wrong...'

I really dont know what to think at this moment...is Coler trying to protect Mike or just throwing us a curve ball...darntarnation....


I retract my vote for Mike and vote for Mad...I am trusting you on this Coler...if you are wrong then you will have to eat my Winnie the Pooh stuffed animal...

In this post to MND, once again, Coler is responsible for Mee-mee's vote for Madcrawdad. Also mentions to MikenDanielle that since we're both on her mafia list, she's willing to lynch me first and take a look at him tomorrow. Here's the thing, though, and I hope I'm not tooting my own horn. On Day 1, where everything is sketchy at best, if you thought that I could be mafia and that MikenDanielle could be mafia, who would you would you be more willing to chuck from the game? I think that I've outed a fair enough number of mafia in past games to warrant a little more consideration from mee-mee over MikenDanielle (a newer player whose gameplay has already irritated a fair number of other players by this point). Assuming that Madcrawdad and MND were both innocents, though, who do you think the mafia would prefer seeing gone? Mee-mee tells MND that she's willing to give him another day or 2 to see what comes of his posts.....why not give me the same consideration? I think I'd be more help to the townies in the long run. Maybe that's just me, though.

Yes, that is in regards to you be innocent or mafia...if you are innocent I will eat my WtP stuffed animal...but I did change my vote for Mad...and if Coler was wrong then he has to eat my WtP stuffed animal...I will ship it to ya Coler...Mad was my second choice anywho...but I will try and give ya the benifit of the doubt and hold off one more day or two....and then we will see what transpires out of your posts...:lipssealedsmilie:

Here is a response to Hooked Newbie regarding his appearance on her list of mafia. Hooked Newbie saw his name on her list of mafia, and called her on it, as he was also voting for me (actually first one to cast a vote). Maybe mee-mee got caught here, and thought yeah, it might not make sense to list HN since he was also coming after ol Mad, and I don't believe that she mentioned him until this point (she also never gave a reason for placing him on her list). Funny thing is that she responds to HN that his name was just a typo....she really has no suspicions of HN. Strange. This may be a very telling post.

Sorry HN, that was a typo...I was trying to edit it but everyone else popped up...my mind was thinking of someone who I could closely watch and I inadvertantly typed your name...I have no suspicions of you as far as I can tell...

In this post, Coler has been whacked, and Mee-mee vows to go back and review who was against Coler, and who Coler liked for mafia...Once again, doing it all for Coler.

And we seriously need to go back and reread all of the posts that seemed to be against Coler...

I, myself, will surely pay closer attention to the very last list he posted...
God be with you Coler, we will avenge your meaningless death, and get those Mafia, before they can get our town a 3rd time...

And since I have tomorrow night off, even though it will be night 3, I am going to go over every post as thoroughly as I possibly can...

And then this one, she parks her vote on me again. Keep in mind she has NEVER given a reason in both days as to why. Only that Coler would have to eat her bear if I were innocent.

My vote is still for Mad

Since then, the previous Madcrawdad lynch train has lost some steam, and Mee-mee really doesn't see my gameplay as suspicious anymore.

That's my rundown on Mee-mee. She was one of the two that I already had suspicions about. The whole 'I'll lynch him for Coler' was what clued me in there. Like I said, I'll do the same for the others on the list, but it may not be until tomorrow sometime.

 

[mee-mee]

Why is it we always forget why people can't post as much as they did in the other games....I forgot you said that in the beginning....

 

[mee-mee]

Okay, Mad, you made your point...

I retract my vote for Mad...and vote for no one right now.....

and I will say, if everyone lynches me, you will be down another Townie...

 

[Madcrawdad]

Well since my instincts were right about Mike being an innocent and just a flustered newbie..I am sticking with my instincts and going to continue to pursue Madcrawdad as my #1 suspect. He is still the same person who was on Coler's #1 suspect list too. Mad was also at the top of Hooked Newbie's Mafia list and Mike suspected him enough to vote for him.

I vote to lynch Madcrawdad

Townies, don't let me die in vain here for sticking my neck out!

Um, Ms. Swayde....you're not really sticking your neck out, as you've pretty much parked on me since day 1. It's fine that you want to vote for me, but how about kicking down some other doors? After all, there's a total of 7 mafia you know...

 

[plantling]

After reviewing my posts I can see how DP would not be too happy with me for scrutinizing how he reacted to Mike's PM post. When it seemed pple had forgotten and were busy gunning for Mike, I kept bringing DP's name up. I was also the first to post Coler's list after his death and insisted that he couldn't be the Don when it was suggested that he may have been the Don. Perhaps at least one of these things displeased the Mafia. For sure though, at least one of the names on the snitch's list is Mafia. At first I had my suspicions about Mad but lately he seems to be more helpful to the town and this post to Mike after he quit just doesn't ring of Mafiaism:

On a sidenote, MND, just stop and take a breath, man. If you're an innocent, I know it can seem disappointing when it looks like nobody appreciates your game. I've been sitting there for the last 2 days also. Here's the thing though, it's just a game. You really need to keep telling yourself that sometimes. While you think that everyone is against you, you need to realize that the mafia are there too, helping make that happen.

As you mention, you don't want to be lynched while mafia scumbags look on smiling. Keep in mind, it's their right to do so....something has gone 'right' with their game when that happens. When we find mafia, and corner them, it's just as much fun to watch them squirm while the townies look on smiling.

Don't take it personally, and don't quit the game. I'm really not saying that to save myself, either. If you quit now, it'll just make it harder for you to return for the next mafia game. Next time will be a completely different game.
Seriously, it's just a game.

So either Mad is not Mafia or he's a very good actor.

And Mee-Mee doesn't post a whole lot, but I believe she's busy outside this game and has defended herself in a recent post.

That leaves KOTD who has also said he's gonna be busy, but I noticed him on the thread while I was trying to decide who to vote for on night 1. It took me a little while as I wasn't gonna vote for Mike and DP didn't seem to have anyone else voting for him besides Mike so I was second-guessing myself about DP. And I realize sometimes it's hard to vote, but not voting isn't gonna help the town. And KOTD didn't vote. So out of the 4, I would have to pick him. But I think I'll vote DP tomorrow if he's the best lynch candidate.

 

[nickmcmechan]

ok guys, my theory was obviously not accurate, but i must have something

after i signed off last night ice and hn went for me big style in the posts

hn, however, turned out to be innocent,

i cant work out if the mafia have turned us against each other

4 townise down, surely even random odds would have meant we would have got one mafia

mad was lynched for no good reason i can find

posts need to be revised to see who was going for mad....that way some mafia will be revealed

 

[Madcrawdad]

I think the snitch is on our side. But, I am not 100% sure.

Does anyone else read it that way?

I think it makes a difference.

I would like to see the 4 people on the list post their thoughts if they think the snitch is for the town or against the town. I would like others to post if possible.

If the list is on the side of the town, well it looks bad for Madcrawdad. If the list is on the side of the mafia, well it looks like has confused us all - three quiet ones and one vocal one.

The whole snitch thing is new to all of us. Nice twist rbishop.

Part of me thinks rbishop wants the mafia to win or atleast have a chance.

I think we will lynch one tonight. The town seems to do good on day 3.

The snitch is mafia, therefore AGAINST the town. If the snitch were for the town, I wouldn't be the only one in trouble as the snitch could name up to 4 mafia players if they desired...we'd all be sunk. The snitch doesn't win the game if the mafia doesn't win the game.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

After reviewing my posts I can see how DP would not be too happy with me for scrutinizing how he reacted to Mike's PM post. When it seemed pple had forgotten and were busy gunning for Mike, I kept bringing DP's name up. I was also the first to post Coler's list after his death and insisted that he couldn't be the Don when it was suggested that he may have been the Don. Perhaps at least one of these things displeased the Mafia. For sure though, at least one of the names on the snitch's list is Mafia. At first I had my suspicions about Mad but lately he seems to be more helpful to the town and this post to Mike after he quit just doesn't ring of Mafiaism:


So either Mad is not Mafia or he's a very good actor.

And Mee-Mee doesn't post a whole lot, but I believe she's busy outside this game and has defended herself in a recent post.

That leaves KOTD who has also said he's gonna be busy, but I noticed him on the thread while I was trying to decide who to vote for on night 1. It took me a little while as I wasn't gonna vote for Mike and DP didn't seem to have anyone else voting for him besides Mike so I was second-guessing myself about DP. And I realize sometimes it's hard to vote, but not voting isn't gonna help the town. And KOTD didn't vote. So out of the 4, I would have to pick him. But I think I'll vote DP tomorrow if he's the best lynch candidate.

lynch me if you want...wont really help the town much..unless my death somehow shows you guys who the mafia is on the list..

i have also explained why i did not vote on night one..it's a random vote..but i like to be at least a little accurate..and no one was screaming mafia at me..i voted for mike on night 2 due to the fact that he was acting like mafia..then he wanted to take himself out of the game..i saw that as a cowardly mafia tactic..so..lynch me if you want..all i can say is good luck my fellow townies.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Going to bed.

I think the people who voted for Mike should be looked at as I think there will definetly be Mafia in that list.

I think DP should be lynched for saying they were going to quit.

I think we should not put too much weight on the Snitch list as it doesn't really help increase our odds of finding a Mafia. A random vote in fact is a much better pick than the list.

Just some thoughts. Good Night Townies.

I somewhat disagree with the part of mafia being parked on Mike. There may be one or two, but as an innocent, I would think more would have been parked on Madcrawdad, or even elsewhere (not on either Mike or Mad). If you believe that I'm innocent, you've got to believe that the mafia would prefer me gone over Mike. Like I said earlier, I have a little more experience than Mike, and Mike was really a distraction for the town that the mafia would like to have kept.