Dawg.. this is sloppy work on your part. You are misrepresenting the names I listed. Is that deliberate? Or just an error on your part?
You need to go back and read the original posts one more time.
1. Ice posted a list of players he felt were "dangerous" to the mafia. He left off 4 people... Agassizii, Annie, Lab_Rat, and RazzleFish.
2. We've agreed that Ice was chosen as GS first BECAUSE he's dangerous to the mafia. When I saw his list of names I thought any one of those people were likely the mafia's second choice if they hadn't picked Ice. So if Ice shot one of those people.. he would be doing exactly what the mafia was hoping he would do. I didn't like that notion... so I looked at an alternative suggestion.
3. All 4 of those names were not my suspect list... as you are trying to claim now. I said ONE of the people on that list was probably mafia. I was hoping Ice (and the rest of us) might be able to identify at least one scummy player from among those 4 people. Then if Ice shot one of them and killed a mafia player... we'd still be left with all the others who are potentially dangerous to the mafia side (excluding those who turned out to be mafia themselves, of course).
Here are both of these the posts to restore the accurate context of that list... Ice's post first, followed by my response to Ice.
In this post, Ice is naming the people he considered most dangerous to the mafia side.
Here.. I posted the 4 names Ice left out.
As it turned out, I was right. There was at least one person on the list who was mafia..... Annie. Ice didn't shoot one of the people he considered most dangerous to the mafia.. and he didn't die by hitting an innocent.
The advice I came up with to offer may not have had anything to do with his decision to shoot Annie at all.. but it was still sound advice and turned out to be correct as well.
So I'm the sloppy one? I know quite well what your post said. Here...let me quote it again for you...
This is a good point, Ice. And since we figure the mafia picked you as the first gunslinger because they feel you're dangerous to them.... you'd likely make the mafia very happy if you target somebody else YOU consider dangerous when taking your shot. For that reason, I'd rather see you shoot someone not on the list you just gave us... that leaves these names then as promising suspects for at least one mafia position on their team.
Agassizii
Annie
Lab_Rat
RazzleFish
Even if it's a miss and we lose you in the game as a result, at least you're not putting another good mafia hunter into the next risky gunslinger position so soon.
These are people you wanted Ice to shoot...in your own words, Kash. I don't care how you came to that conclusion the bottom line is you asked Ice to shoot them.