Mafia 62- The Play

[jbradt]

I thought I'd take a look at DD... turns out it didn't take so long.

12th

Kash, you're supposed to call 11th!

ok.... officially, 12th

good point, LR

Hehe, okay, early game banter and bs.

ok..... what I am unsure of is how anyione could be saying "Alex usually plays like this or is normally like that and he is quiet no matter what role he has".... when I am thinking Alex has played in one game before... or am I wrong with that? Looks like someone might be protecting Alex....

...

My thoughts on JL is that he is tied up with work or something.

...

I have nothing either.... I will say the whole Ag/Pap conversation is pretty interesting and as much as my knee jerk reaction is to vote paps... I can't help but think he's got good points... I am especially leaning off him a little because he was the first one to indicate that Ag was possibly playing in other games, which is why he would suggest Alex had been quite in "other" games.

Thanks for that.

sorry guys.... I have had a heck of a day.... I haven't read through the posts really well but I can see there is some concern over Lab, however, I am still not feeling good about Ag.... the most because of the reference to games off the board. Not much to go on but it's what I have to get my vote out.... I vote to lynch Ag

Not much to go on indeed. But it was day 1...

man, that sucks... I don't know if anyone other that Paps was digging on Ag as much....

Another stunning insight! :lipssealedsmilie:

It seems to me like DD is a bit off. I would have expected more input by this point. You're a vet DD... you've really got nothing to offer?

 

[IceH2O]

Actually I just looked back...while I think you baited him, you weren't the first to vote for him (in fact you were fourth) and he did react weird to all your probing. Ice was the first to actually vote for Ag.

Were you so focused on trying to get rid of someone you deem dangerous to your survival that you honestly missed that I was the 1st vote on Ag and that it wasn't Jpap?

Just a fun little tidbit...the chance that I would be mafia in 3 consecutive games is approximately 0.020625. Not very good odds there...I bet the mafia scum are loving how this game is going. :shakehead: I'm worried for the town.

Heh you used odds last game and were mafia. I think its more telling to claim you can't be mafia then it is to claim innocence.

 

[jbradt]

So far nothing but a bunch of fluff from JB. Made a couple of posts, makes a vote, then nothing. What's up with that JB?

Feeling any better about my posting now, Labby? :silly:

Just a fun little tidbit...the chance that I would be mafia in 3 consecutive games is approximately 0.020625. Not very good odds there...I bet the mafia scum are loving how this game is going. :shakehead: I'm worried for the town.

The beautiful part of this game is while this is an excellent point if you're a townie, it's also an excellent defense if you're scum. :wall:

 

[jbradt]

I've gone throught the lists posted so far, and here's what I've got. Keep in mind, this is suspects, not lynching...

So, out of 6 lists we have:

Mich: 4 (Ice, Jpap, Zsand, Zaffy)
Labby: 4 (Ice, Jpap, Rich, JL)
Noods: 4 (Ice, Rich, Zsand, JL)
Ice: 4 (Jpap, Rich, Zsand, JL)
DD: 3 (Jpap, JL, Zaffy)
Jpap: 3 (Rich, Zaffy, JB)
Zaffy: 1 (Ice)
JL: 1 (Zsand)

Here's the list of remaining players:
Jpap
Lab Key: Players not listed yet
DD Players with 4 votes
Michwol42795 Players with 3 votes
Rich Players with 1 vote
Ice
Zaffy
JL
Noodles
Dawg
ZSandman
JB
Razz

Labby and Mich: I can see the cases on them and will look more into it.
Ice: as stated earlier... I'm still on the fence here.
Noods: I also feel like her posting has been off. Going to look into this too.
Jpap: I already have my suspicions of him, but waiting for responses.
DD: I'll have to look more into her too. I haven't paid attention her way.
Zaffy and JL: I have both of them leaning innocent thus far. Though I always have an eye on Zaffy...

As for my list, in no particular order:
Jpap
Mich
Noods

The fourth would be a total guess, so I'm not going to bother.

Just noticed my list didn't format right earlier... tried to fix it.

 

[jbradt]

... meh...

 

[jbradt]

No, jpap's frequent posting has absolutely nothing to do with why I chose him. And I'm actually rethinking that choice right now...the only reason you're liking that vote more and more is because you are indeed mafia. You know I will show innocent. This will be a problem for you, since you've led the charge against me which is why you put in this nice disclaimer:



There is something off with Noods too, and Dawg has raised my suspicions as well. I'd bet my fish that at least 2 of the following 3 are mafia: Noods, JL, Dawg. It could possibly be all 3, though they seem to experienced to pile on a vote like that. I'm gonna go pull some posts from Noods, she's the one primarily setting off my mafia radar at the moment.

Labby... this post caught my attention. It may be because I'm tired and skimming, but can you give the readers digest version of why you suspect the 3 you mentioned? You must be awefully confident to bet your fish... I'd like to see your perspective.

 

[noodles62]

I find it amusing that I am suspect to a few of you because I referenced SK. I was not making excuses for my play style, merely my sense of humor. (I guess this is lost on non SK fans)
I do not feel it necessary to quote the posts in fact it would be a waste of my time.

I was preoccupied last night as things were a bit hectic around the house and the earlier nightfall is altho, welcomed, it is out of the norm and right in the middle of my busy evening. needless to say, work has been hectic so I have not had the luxury of being able to play much "on the clock". regardless, I will do my best to step it up today and make sure my head is in the game........but whatever. i dont feel i have to justify my play style of sense of humor but i guess i just did LOL! there you have it. be back a little later with my thoughts on things/players as it stands now. Losing 3 innocents (& the detective) really sucks..........

 

[noodles62]

I find it amusing that I am suspect to a few of you because I referenced SK. I was not making excuses for my play style, merely my sense of humor. (I guess this is lost on non SK fans)
I do not feel it necessary to quote the posts in fact it would be a waste of my time.

I was preoccupied last night as things were a bit hectic around the house and the earlier nightfall is altho, welcomed, it is out of the norm and right in the middle of my busy evening. needless to say, work has been hectic so I have not had the luxury of being able to play much "on the clock". regardless, I will do my best to step it up today and make sure my head is in the game........but whatever. i dont feel i have to justify my play style of sense of humor but i guess i just did LOL! there you have it. be back a little later with my thoughts on things/players as it stands now. Losing 3 innocents (& the detective) really sucks..........

oops. bolded/red word should be "or".

 

[jbradt]

I'm less concerned about semantics and more concerned about the odd logic he used to jump around on votes.

I get what you're saying here Paps. And I'm still trying to give the benefit of the doubt, but you don't seem to have any consistency here. I'm just about brain dead, so I can't pull the posts, but if I've got anything wrong, I'm sure you'll correct me.

You said that it worries you when someone prefaces their vote with a claim of randomness. And you stuck to this. You called Zaffy out on it when he made a random vote. Which, btw; sparked a pretty long plot line. I was thinking it was a joke, but maybe there's more to it... I digress. And you totally called Ag on it when he used it. Then when he gave into your pressure you called him on that.

Here's what's weird... you have no problem with Rich suggesting that we vote randomly, but when Ag and Zaffy say their voting randomly that's suspicious? And then to cap it, you say you're not concerned about semantics...

 

[dirtydawg10]

I'm not looking one way and voting another. I'm looking both ways, if I had two votes I'd give one to both jpap and Noods. And I'm not attempting to blame jpap for lynching the detective, I am blaming jpap for the results of this nights lynch. (Also blame Ag some as he should have defended himself or even revealed he was detective).

I have to agree with this. If AG revealed himself the Doc could have protected from the hit. The Town lost a big PR last night. Hopefully we can recover from it.

I need to do some rereading before I put a list of suspects out there and I'm not around much today so I'll try to post something thia afternoon or evening if I can.