A couple thoughts about this post. Jpap, I would like to know what the difference is between the bolded phrase above and anyone else saying "I'm leaning soandso innocent". You stated that she said she trusted me. This is not what she said at all. For someone who's been so hung up on semantics, you seem to have twisted what Labby said and ran with your own version. This seems to be the same thing you did with Ag, and we know how that turned out. Again, this could be just a misguided pittbull of a townie, but it seems odd.
The reason that it's so disconcerting is because you're a top suspect with a lot of townies. And because I can see the reasons why. To me though, the trigger hasn't been pulled yet.
Let me get this straight Papster... the fact that I've been helpful means nothing to you? Is that right? I thought I had something crazy in my eye. Can you explain -like I was a 5 year old- WTF you mean by this?
I've got to go back and look at Labby's posts again. It's not easy for me to say this after being chumped last time, but I really don't see the case against her, and several people seem to be making it. I'm going to have to go back and look at this.
Again, Jpap; this isn't what was said. It's interesting to me that you have been so concerned with the way people are phrasing things, but you seem to interpreting this one your own way. At least from how I read what she said.
Oh, and for all of you who are going to say I'm defending Labby: :headshake2: and shame on you for thinking I'd be so simple.
JB, please read the post below:
I'm agreeing with you because I trust you more than most of the others. Why is that disconcerting? I gave you the list of my top innocent choices.
She trusts you (Zaffy and Z also) most out of the people playing. What other way is there to interpret what she has said?
I have already said that IMO it is far too early to be pushing people to the innocent side. Its day 2 for goodness sakes! There are definitely people not on my scum list but I cannot say that I have anyone "leaning innocent". And yes, that includes you. Being helpful and posting a lot does not have a bearing on which way people go because obviously not just innocents are going to appear to be helping. Unless your posts nail a mafia or two I'm not going to see you as potentially innocent.
There she is!! finally something with a bit of substance.:
C'mon Rich. You aint no dummy. Let's see something a little more definitive. You have skated thru many a game as mafia by flying under the radar and you always have me a bit nervous. Let's say you change up your play style and give us some meat to go with the mush?
Rgiht now I would have to say my top 4 suspects are:
Labby - While the huge train makes me a bit nervous she is still my top suspect. The recent finger pointing, pleas and grabbing onto others she notes as innocent remind me of a drowning person grabbing onto and dragging down as many others with her as she can. I am ok with her finding me suspect, but I just dont get the how she insists that Dawg and I have been distancing when the only post I can think of were the initial joke post. Reminds me of Luvbugz a bit....hhhmmmm- that did not always work out in the towns favor. (poor Bugz, where did she go anyway?)
Rich/DD - they are tied for second place. DD is always on my scum radar and altho she did finally post something with a bit of meat to it, I would like to see more that looks like she is helping. Rich, well, I outlined that above. He is not producing much either.
Jpap - while I said I would give you the benefit of the doubt on the Ag banter, I tend to agree that you seemed to be single minded there and that does not seem typical for you at all. What else you got dude?
Not sure of number 4 yet, but off the top of my head I would say Ice. Need to do a bit more research first................The Noob has me a bit worried. We either scared him off or he has been told to lay low by his team mates. This tactic seems to be used often and appears to work with noobs. not sure I wanna give him a pass just cuz he is new............
more in a bit.
I have listed all my suspects already but apparently that still makes me narrow minded. Didn't know I had to have so many strong suspects this early in the game...
I will be back hopefully with some posts not directed at me.