mafia 63- Who is Who

Although if one hits the other, I guess we'd know...
 
jbradt said:
Kick ***! We got the hitman night 1.


I don't know what to think about the JL/Annie debaucle. I've had suspicions about JL from the beginning, but I'm going to have to put some thought (and more time reading back) into it before voting. I will most likely be voting either Annie or JL tonight. I don't see FF being as important as either of these two. Also, after nightfall, either can claim whatever they want, I don't see how we would prove or disprove it without outing the mayor which we can't do per Ice.

Should be an interesting day...
Click to expand...

Because once the mayor and I can communicate, I have two hits that I can use. Even during the day time. Until the mayor finds me, I can't hit anyone.

I am 100% against lynching annie. Once I am confirmed by my actions as to who I am, the rest of the town will know what annie is. Of course I am 100% against lynching me also.

What is your reason for not wanting to lynch FF1? As long as they are not the mayor, me coming out can only help the town. Even if I am lying, there will be only one player dead, there are no mafia hits. So if I am lying then lynch me then. I will be able to prove my innocents with a quick hit. I will state who I am going to hit and then place the hit. If the mayor has no names to give me, then I will hit annie, but I will announce that also.

What suspicions have you had about me? I missed that part.
 
johnlarson66 said:
Because once the mayor and I can communicate, I have two hits that I can use. Even during the day time. Until the mayor finds me, I can't hit anyone.

I am 100% against lynching annie. Once I am confirmed by my actions as to who I am, the rest of the town will know what annie is. Of course I am 100% against lynching me also.

What is your reason for not wanting to lynch FF1? As long as they are not the mayor, me coming out can only help the town. Even if I am lying, there will be only one player dead, there are no mafia hits. So if I am lying then lynch me then. I will be able to prove my innocents with a quick hit. I will state who I am going to hit and then place the hit. If the mayor has no names to give me, then I will hit annie, but I will announce that also.

What suspicions have you had about me? I missed that part.
Click to expand...

I think the Pandas in your Avatar are cool.

Is it too late for me to brown nose?
 
johnlarson66 said:
Because once the mayor and I can communicate, I have two hits that I can use. Even during the day time. Until the mayor finds me, I can't hit anyone.

I am 100% against lynching annie. Once I am confirmed by my actions as to who I am, the rest of the town will know what annie is. Of course I am 100% against lynching me also.

What is your reason for not wanting to lynch FF1? As long as they are not the mayor, me coming out can only help the town. Even if I am lying, there will be only one player dead, there are no mafia hits. So if I am lying then lynch me then. I will be able to prove my innocents with a quick hit. I will state who I am going to hit and then place the hit. If the mayor has no names to give me, then I will hit annie, but I will announce that also.

What suspicions have you had about me? I missed that part.
Click to expand...

To be honest, my suspicions have been fleeting and sketchy. But it was day 1; that's the case with everyone. I have to go back and look through to find specifics.

My problem with voting FF1 is that it feels wrong to me. Yes, he's spastic and noobish, but I see that in his posts outside this thread too. See my puffer tank update thread where he asked if it was the puffer tank...

I would have much less of a problem with it if you had said something like "don't lynch me tonight", instead of suggesting another target seemingly because they annoy you. Something doesn't sit townieish about that with me. Does that make sense? I'm still trying to sort a lot of this out while I'm typing...

Why are you so against lynching Annie? It seems if you were the cop, you would know he were mafia and lynching him would not only get rid of a mafia, but also pretty much prove you as the cop. I don't get that. You only get 2 hits all game... why would you want to voluntarily use one on someone that should be such an easy lynch target?

Like I say, I'm just trying to make sense of it.
 
I guess the short of what I'm trying to say is that the job (of a townie anyway) is still to find scum. It seems like you're trying to change that goal to lynching FF1.
 
jbradt said:
To be honest, my suspicions have been fleeting and sketchy. But it was day 1; that's the case with everyone. I have to go back and look through to find specifics.

My problem with voting FF1 is that it feels wrong to me. Yes, he's spastic and noobish, but I see that in his posts outside this thread too. See my puffer tank update thread where he asked if it was the puffer tank...

I would have much less of a problem with it if you had said something like "don't lynch me tonight", instead of suggesting another target seemingly because they annoy you. Something doesn't sit townieish about that with me. Does that make sense? I'm still trying to sort a lot of this out while I'm typing...

Why are you so against lynching Annie? It seems if you were the cop, you would know he were mafia and lynching him would not only get rid of a mafia, but also pretty much prove you as the cop. I don't get that. You only get 2 hits all game... why would you want to voluntarily use one on someone that should be such an easy lynch target?

Like I say, I'm just trying to make sense of it.
Click to expand...

Exactly. When JL RC'ed, I couldnt wait to hang him for it. If I didnt step up, he rules the town. Last thing we need is JL ruling the town right now, trust me.

I dont think JL is necessarily in comm with his boss, just he did what he meant to do....find me....

and he did...

i vote to lynch JL.......if I havent already......
 
jbradt said:
I guess the short of what I'm trying to say is that the job (of a townie anyway) is still to find scum. It seems like you're trying to change that goal to lynching FF1.
Click to expand...

I am not trying to lynch FF1, I am trying not to lynch the mayor. The only reason I am okay with lynching FF1 is because I am sure they are not the mayor.

I also don't think the mayor would have looked into FF1 as a possible policemen.

I think lynching FF1 is the safest way to avoid lynching the mayor and/or a communicating innocent.

I am looking forward to annies death...
 
AnniesNotOK said:
Yeah, its a weird day. Im interested in your thoughts.

I agree, the only real choice for a lynch right now is myself and JL.
Click to expand...

Nope. Nobody should lynch either of you. The mayor can investigate one of you, and if the cop claim checks out that person can kill the other.


johnlarson66 said:
I am 100% against lynching annie. Once I am confirmed by my actions as to who I am, the rest of the town will know what annie is. Of course I am 100% against lynching me also.
Click to expand...

Yes. No reason to lynch either of you at this point.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom