That vote tally is a huge red flag for me.
I've been back and forth on this myself ever since Annie counter-claimed the role. No matter which one we think is telling the truth or lying, one fact remains:
7 out of 14 players in this game are on the mafia side. And all 7 of those people wants us to kill the policeman tonight by lynching him (Annie or John) before the mayor can investigate either claim.
The scum side can't talk to each other as a team. They can't coordinate anything they do behind the scenes. The Don can't even kill any of us without the hitman. But each one of them can still dig up one excuse after another or yammer on and on about having this "hunch" about someone or how that person's argument "feels" wrong to them. Then they'll use whatever they can come up with to justify voting for one or the other person claiming to be the policeman.
I don't believe anyone who is innocent will vote to lynch either Annie or John for the Day 2 lynch.