mafia 63- Who is Who

[Lab_Rat]

Interesting scenario LR and it makes some sense...I just don't know if that route is a good idea.

Maybe Annie is the cop, maybe JL is the cop. Lynching either one is a risky move since all it takes is lynching the wrong one (if it even is one of them) to put us square with the mafia again. Then the game is down to who can survive the longest...which is a total crapshoot and rather boring.

I almost would rather wait it out and see what the mayor does then watch for the hit to see who was telling the truth. Problem is that I don't think Annie sees eye to eye with this plan and wants to lynch JL right away...makes sense why the real cop would want it, but honestly the collective town doesn't know either role so it's stupid for us to just play along.

See, when I was going back and forth with maybe JL is cop, maybe Annie is cop, :nilly: it bugged me that JL was so insistent Annie was scum but flat out refused to vote for him. Makes absolutely no sense unless the scenario I described is what is going on. If JL is scum and Annie is really the cop then JL would be pushing very hard to lynch him. That would even things out for the mafia. But that is not happening. Instead, FF is a poor pawn in the game JL is playing. I felt manipulated by JL, especially his post right after my vote for FF.

Now Annie is acting like one would expect from the cop, but the incongruities from JL make me think they're on the same team. And what I mentioned before, where Annie gets JL lynched and then Annie looks awesome to the town when JL shows mafia further feeds into their evil plan. The mayors investigation on Annie would do nothing, except waste an investigation and a day. The mayor can't even come out and say Annie is scum.

Please re-read their interactions and tell me if you think it sounds scripted. Yes, it is a huge gamble, but what do they have to lose? They have no hits. They have no power except for the power to confuse the town. Neither JL nor Annie strike me as a conservative player, I can see them pulling a ballsy stunt like this. Desperate times call for desperate measures in scumland...

 

[jbradt]

This is making a lot of sense to me Labby. I'm going to have to put more thought into this when I get back home...

See, when I was going back and forth with maybe JL is cop, maybe Annie is cop, :nilly: it bugged me that JL was so insistent Annie was scum but flat out refused to vote for him. Makes absolutely no sense unless the scenario I described is what is going on. If JL is scum and Annie is really the cop then JL would be pushing very hard to lynch him. That would even things out for the mafia. But that is not happening. Instead, FF is a poor pawn in the game JL is playing. I felt manipulated by JL, especially his post right after my vote for FF.

Now Annie is acting like one would expect from the cop, but the incongruities from JL make me think they're on the same team. And what I mentioned before, where Annie gets JL lynched and then Annie looks awesome to the town when JL shows mafia further feeds into their evil plan. The mayors investigation on Annie would do nothing, except waste an investigation and a day. The mayor can't even come out and say Annie is scum.

Please re-read their interactions and tell me if you think it sounds scripted. Yes, it is a huge gamble, but what do they have to lose? They have no hits. They have no power except for the power to confuse the town. Neither JL nor Annie strike me as a conservative player, I can see them pulling a ballsy stunt like this. Desperate times call for desperate measures in scumland...

 

[jbradt]

FF, for the sake of clarity, who do you mean by LB?

 

[Fishfriend1]

FF, for the sake of clarity, who do you mean by LB?

woops thats LR Lab Rat lol.:duh: and im taking him off my list that was more a "i dislike u" thing not logical to keep him there.

 

[Fishfriend1]

so no one cares about my notes?

 

[Fishfriend1]

where is everyone, this is getting boring...

 

[Fishfriend1]

zzz zzz zzz snort zzz zzz snore zzz zzz zzz zzz snort zzz zzz zzz .............

 

[RazzleFish]

so no one cares about my notes?

Nope, their worthless! JK I am sure we all read them but there just isn't much to say about them. I encourage you to continue sharing them but don't expect people to coment that much on them. You have said what you think is going to happen but because of the format of this game there isn't much to talk about with your notes. There is no way of linking anyone yet.

This is just a thought and I would like some input but what do you guys think about making it a tie between Annie and JL? I am thinking not but I just wanted to hear your thoughts. I don't think FF is mafia. I know that when I was mafia and knew I was getting lynched I shut up. I would expect a noob to do the same but I may be off. My top 3 are as follows in no particular order:

JL- Claming to be the cop.
Annie- Also claiming to be the cop.
FF- I know I said I don't think he's mafia but with what everyone else has said I feel I should put him up here. Also I don't have anything for the other players so........

 

[RazzleFish]

where is everyone, this is getting boring...

You know you can go do something else and check back in later. You don't have to wait and reply after every post.

 

[Fishfriend1]

At this point, I just don't want to see the mayor get lynched.

All I can do at this point is hope that the town does not lynch me and that the mayor looks into me.

If people think that I am mafia and made this claim as a way to get rid of FF1 or out anyone, I guess they have the right to think what they want. I think it would be an odd move, I was also the one that had the bright idea to have the snitch name all 4 mafia members last game. I can completely understand why people would not want to trust me.

My vote stays on FF1 as I believe there is no way they are the mayor. I think I have said everything that I can on this subject. I have put it out there. I will be back after nightfall and go from there.

Your right im not the mayor... OR AM I? You can never be sure. The best way for the don to win would be to distract everybody and slowly have them vote innocents off. If the Leaders are out there you may want to look into me i could be anyone, mafia OR townie. Im gonna stay as unpredictable as possible. Right now the only thing you can KNOW is that i will probably crack a joke out soon... [and the crowd :cry:]