Mafia #67 - 50/50 -- The Play

[Lab_Rat]

I'm glad you pulled that Lab post and bolded that line about you not kicking bushes. The ending really raise flags.

Lab you've put JB into a spot by saying I bet he starts now that I've pointed it out.

If he does you can say see scum trying to save himself by looking innocent, that isn't protown. Why would you dare anyone to start kicking bushes is just trying to blend?

I was saying I'm not going to let him play me for a fool like he did last time with the same scenario. It was no dare. You're reading way too much into things...dare I say, like I did with FF...

 

[IceH2O]

I was saying I'm not going to let him play me for a fool like he did last time with the same scenario. It was no dare. You're reading way too much into things...dare I say, like I did with FF...

Its possible but I'll keep my vote on you for now. I will at least keep an open mind. As you can see I'm not just questioning you.

 

[the wizard]

So just to understand you correctly you are saying that Lab started attacking FF when she said that if he mass posts it will confuse the town. Since you insist on posts here they are. This is what made me think FF was scum:






I cannot think of a single reason that an innocent person would want to be investigated by the mafia. still. i have said that about 5 times now. and you keep asking. again. and again.

How you can see that as an attack by lab rat to start a battle of wits is beyond me. I can however see how that could of been a serious slip up by FF asking for a mafia to investigate him. Yes his game play was different from last, I was convinced that he didn't have a scum team reeling him in this time and tell him to shut up like last time.

I can't believe this has to be pointed out again. :wall: Remember the context, FF is talking to LR. He said IF YOU think I'm scum then invest me. The YOU being LR. Not the scum team.

I don't, I can take care of myself. In fact I have no idea why he's defending me. Still doesn't mean I think he's scum, maybe I just know how he is so his actions haven't struck me as scummy like some of you guys think they are.

Since you know how he is soooo well, care to enlighten us as to why he ignored the question I asked him about liking the train on FF?

 

[jpappy789]

Thanks Dag, I mean Jpap. Why the defense?

Not innocent still doesn't mean should be voted out, SB is still a possible help to the innocent team.


What is your take on the SB? What is everyones take on the SB?

Because it caught my eye and I thought it needed to be corrected, or at least reinterpreted. Lab, I believe, called the role evil flat out. Dag didn't.

I agree that not being innocent doesn't mean they should be voted out but I was under the impression that Dag was saying he ruled out the innocent role entirely and was between SB and scum. Thus, he wouldn't be voting an innocent out at least and even if he was SB he wouldn't be killed. I'll stop putting words into his mouth and just stop typing about it.

My take on the SB is that it's a wild card role and unpredictable. I don't want to assume they are playing with the best interest of the town. More often than not the vigilante type roles have been but this role has the chance to create a heck of a lot more destruction if they feel like it.

 

[jpappy789]

Wiz, if that is the case (the "you" being lab) then why did he later say it wasn't just to lab?

post #238 if you need to read what you obviously missed.

 

[Dangerdoll]

Ice, Dag never said the SB was evil...he said the role isn't INNOCENT.

Pap, if the role isn't innocent... what is it? I guess I just don't get this...

 

[IceH2O]

Because it caught my eye and I thought it needed to be corrected, or at least reinterpreted. Lab, I believe, called the role evil flat out. Dag didn't.

I agree that not being innocent doesn't mean they should be voted out but I was under the impression that Dag was saying he ruled out the innocent role entirely and was between SB and scum. Thus, he wouldn't be voting an innocent out at least and even if he was SB he wouldn't be killed. I'll stop putting words into his mouth and just stop typing about it.

My take on the SB is that it's a wild card role and unpredictable. I don't want to assume they are playing with the best interest of the town. More often than not the vigilante type roles have been but this role has the chance to create a heck of a lot more destruction if they feel like it.

I would have trusted this a lot more if he had said it instead of you. Now he can just say the same thing in his own words.

I've been trying to give you the benefit of the doubt because of your questioning and points made today but if Dag dies and shows mafia I will have to pull this post as a defense of him.

 

[jpappy789]

OMG! You guys thought i was referring only to lab?! And that at the time i thought LAB was mafia?! I was just stating that if the mafia team invests me they will vote for me and you can use that as a way to find the mafia. This is just a big misunderstanding. And at the time i didnt think lab was mafia, that has since changed.

For dramatic effect...

 

[the wizard]

I was saying I'm not going to let him play me for a fool like he did last time with the same scenario. It was no dare. You're reading way too much into things...dare I say, like I did with FF...

You didn't read too much into anything with FF. Are you trying to sugarcoat your day1 behavior? You twisted his posts and steamrolled right on over him.

 

[jpappy789]

Pap, if the role isn't innocent... what is it? I guess I just don't get this...

DD, how many games have you played? I'm just guessing but I think you've played the most of anyone on AC. You don't need to be told that there have been roles in the past that have been neither innocent nor evil either in how they did not count to numbers and/or their abilities.

Come on...

I would have trusted this a lot more if he had said it instead of you. Now he can just say the same thing in his own words.

I've been trying to give you the benefit of the doubt because of your questioning and points made today but if Dag dies and shows mafia I will have to pull this post as a defense of him.

I understand, and I wish I just would have kept my mouth shut and let Dag respond himself.