Mafia #69: Ghost Hunters Game Thread

[the wizard]

O.k. let me make it easy for you Bio, you said that nothing LR said jumped out at you as scummy, you do remember that she said Kashta was leaning her innocent right?

I retract my vote on Ice.

My top suspects right now are JL, Annie, Rich, and Bio.

I'm leaning Lab Rat and ILM more to the scum side than townie.

I'm still undecided or neutral about everyone else (including Ice which explains my retraction above).

Does the above post indicate that in any way?

 

[noodles62]

To me this still may be an issue since no one ever mentioned puke. I'm surprised anyone would just assume that regardless of the reasoning that followed.



I understood it to mean that they were the bottom 3 people on your list of 8 scum suspects...not that they were the bottom 3 overall out of everyone.

It was a bit confusing but that is how I interpreted it as well.

 

[IceH2O]

Then why not have a list of the top 5 and then the next 3. The list was almost like that anyway, except for Bio and Wiz.

The reason Wiz is knocked down is becuase he was voting Bio, but why not knock Bio down because Wiz was voting for Bio.

Because Bios voting at the time looked more scummy.

I voted on you based on this...


I felt that, at the time (that is, many many posts ago), you were the scummiest looking person. What do I think of you now? I'm not sure, but I am leaning towards non-scum. I still don't know if you were playing at some reverse psychology to claim innocence, or just stating an opinion.

As for ILM, they are not posting, and the posts they have made have been useless. As mentioned earlier, not all my posts have been relevant either, but most of them have. ILM decided to vote off FF, and still has not explained their reasoning (unless I missed it). And that seems to be the only thing he has done so far.
If he is scum, he is probably being coached to stay quiet.
If he is innocent, he is hardly contributing, and will not be missed.

 

[BioHazard]

Bio would you care to give us some comprehensive thoughts you might have on Lab?

How comprehensive are we talking here?

My thoughts are that they made a mistake, and made it look worse by panicking when people attacked them. I just am not sure I can judge them as scum or innocent based on that.
I guess I just empathize.

 

[noodles62]

I dont think this has been brought up yet but I find it particularly interesting...



If lab indeed slipped before the first nightfall she may have very well slipped again...she certainly seemed flustered enough too drop a teammates name.

i think that if/when lab flips scum I will be voting bio. the fact that she has no firm stance on what lab said makes me think they are teammates.

Good catch Mael! let's hope we are right.

There are 4 players not voting on Labby. I find it highly unlikely that they are all scum so that means scum is of course hiding in the train......i hate that is so easy for them...

 

[the wizard]

I dont think this has been brought up yet but I find it particularly interesting...



If lab indeed slipped before the first nightfall she may have very well slipped again...she certainly seemed flustered enough too drop a teammates name.

i think that if/when lab flips scum I will be voting bio. the fact that she has no firm stance on what lab said makes me think they are teammates.

I can't argue there. I voted Bio D1 and was beginning to think I should have today as well.

Since it is unlikely LR will survive the night it doesn't seem like a vote change to Bio now would make a difference.

 

[[AC] maelstrom]

looks like ILM is going to UD...fingers crossed they are scum

 

[johnlarson66]

Ice, if Lab comes up innocent - what will you say?

 

[noodles62]

Good catch Mael! let's hope we are right.

There are 4 players not voting on Labby. I find it highly unlikely that they are all scum so that means scum is of course hiding in the train......i hate that is so easy for them...

Should say "easy for them to hide"....

 

[johnlarson66]

If Lab comes up evil, will all of us not voting for her be on Ice's newer list?