Mafia #7 -- The Play

[johnlarson66]

I'm confused....If KOTD comes up empty handed, woudn't you vote KOTD next?

As far as finding a mafia member. If he does not find a mafia member, then I will vote for wata.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I am all for being investigated. Anyone that KOTD can clear would be good for the town.

I have also posted one person who I think is mafia. I just do not want to put out a long list at this time.

agreed. maybe we should all post one-two players they are suspicious of. I would look at Sploke because of the thread thing last night. I wouldn't want to train the guy for such a reason, but an investigation might be good.

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

I had to come back and post this because you people are blind to everything.

I'm sorry wata if I'm outing you but they can't seem to see it.

Has anyone seen that Wata is the only one besides me calling out KOTD and deflecting guilt from me? Could she be the real detective? Is she trying to let you know without actually revealing it?

The mafia is laughing at you guys so hard they can't post. KOTD and his team have you in the palm of their hands. Jl are you the Don? Just asking you don't have to answer..

Again sorry wata but it had to be said. These guys need someone to hold their hand through the thread and actually shove their faces into the pool of fact.

you realize now..with this post..that when you are lynched and found to be mafia(and the snitch :duh: ) you have now created even MORE suspicion for wata, i'm sure she'll thank you..or will it be us thanking you if she is found to be mafia..we'll see

i think ice just outed a buddy, UH OH!

 

[Madcrawdad]

I had to come back and post this because you people are blind to everything.

I'm sorry wata if I'm outing you but they can't seem to see it.

Has anyone seen that Wata is the only one besides me calling out KOTD and deflecting guilt from me? Could she be the real detective? Is she trying to let you know without actually revealing it?

The mafia is laughing at you guys so hard they can't post. KOTD and his team have you in the palm of their hands. Jl are you the Don? Just asking you don't have to answer..

Again sorry wata but it had to be said. These guys need someone to hold their hand through the thread and actually shove their faces into the pool of fact.

Sorry, Ice...if you were townie, even you would see that 'outing' Wata as detective to save yourself is a totally anti-town move. Earlier you said that if lynched, you would go out while being helpful to the town. Now you're 'outing' who you claim might be detective. That wouldn't be very helpful to anyone but you. Kind of puts a target on the detective's back, wouldn't you say?

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

agreed. maybe we should all post one-two players they are suspicious of. I would look at Sploke because of the thread thing last night. I wouldn't want to train the guy for such a reason, but an investigation might be good.

i have my eye on Z and wata now..

 

[mee-mee]

This caught me by surprise...where do you see RB revealing that Ice is the Snitch in the rules of the Snitch..or am I missing something...

I am surprised that rbishop revealed that IceH2O was the Snitch. I thought it was only in death. If they were on the same mafia team, the Don would not know who the snitch was.

I do not think KOTD is mafia. Well unless Ice is proven innocent. If he comes up mafia and the snitch, then it is different.

I also like the idea that the Detective and Doctor can talk to each other, I hope they find each other soon.

And if it does come up Mafia and Snitch, we know King is telling the truth..which I believe he is..

I meant to say "mafia and not the snitch, then it is different"

 

[johnlarson66]

I had to come back and post this because you people are blind to everything.

I'm sorry wata if I'm outing you but they can't seem to see it.

Has anyone seen that Wata is the only one besides me calling out KOTD and deflecting guilt from me? Could she be the real detective? Is she trying to let you know without actually revealing it?

The mafia is laughing at you guys so hard they can't post. KOTD and his team have you in the palm of their hands. Jl are you the Don? Just asking you don't have to answer..

Again sorry wata but it had to be said. These guys need someone to hold their hand through the thread and actually shove their faces into the pool of fact.

Too much.

If I was the Don or even on your team, I would have told you to calm down and not post so much. I would have also told you to stay away from the trains and try to act more innocent. I would have highly suggested that you stopped freaking out. Too late for all that. I look forward to see you in the next game.

 

[johnlarson66]

This caught me by surprise...where do you see RB revealing that Ice is the Snitch in the rules of the Snitch..or am I missing something....

I quoted the rules. Here is what was said:

"The Snitch does not reveal his identity to anybody, not even the Don, except by me upon their death. "

It can be read as that rbishob only reveals it "upon their death".

 

[plantling]

Thats why you discuss things and not just react to them. Which is what people want to do this game. Its all reaction no discussion.

You voted for Sway, why? Why couldn't she have been a power role? She posted she wasn't going to post much, don't most power roles try to stay hidden? But you had no problem voting for her based on something as trivial as a post stating she wouldn't be around much.

If we had discussed Sway instead of just piling on her maybe we could have found something out or she could have had a chance to explain better rather then having to talk her way out of a 9 vote deficit. Maybe she'd still be here and we would have taken out a mafia player and had 2 of them instead of just the one.

Ice, I listed my reasons when I voted Sway as I usually do when I vote. And I voted early enough so that if she was the doc or detective she could have somehow convinced us. None of her later posts indicated she was a power role and regrettably they didn't convince me of her innocence either. I believed her to be Mafia until RB stated she was an innocent. But I believe you suspected she was innocent when you made that backpeddle post. And instead of withdrawing your vote and stating reasons why you thought she was innocent, you tried to set Mad and Chaz up for the fall. Very Mafiaish, to me.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I had to come back and post this because you people are blind to everything.

I'm sorry wata if I'm outing you but they can't seem to see it.
If you turn out to be innocent this very well may be true. Or maybe wata is going to post that she is the detective any minute now because she is mafia just like you.
Has anyone seen that Wata is the only one besides me calling out KOTD and deflecting guilt from me? Could she be the real detective? Is she trying to let you know without actually revealing it?
Hmmmm possible. It's equally possible Dangerdoll might move to Canada and become Mrs Charlie Stubbs. It's unlikely, but not entirely impossible.
The mafia is laughing at you guys so hard they can't post. KOTD and his team have you in the palm of their hands. Jl are you the Don? Just asking you don't have to answer..
This play only works once, so it would seem a fruitless strategy. Besides, he could have said your just mafia, hoping to get lucky, but he said your the snitch.
Again sorry wata but it had to be said. These guys need someone to hold their hand through the thread and actually shove their faces into the pool of fact.

To quote a once trusted colleague, "If Ice is not mafia, then there is no mafia".