Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

I'm about to go to bed but I wanted to stop by here real quick first.

This FF thing, as most have noted, is whack. I feel like we've scared him into junk post overload now that we brought up how quiet he was. And the fact that he was on the site when he said he wouldn't be and avoided this thread sends a huge red flag. I'm not falling for any crap anymore. (thinking back to Bally's "i didn't realize I was invisible" a couple games back.)

This thing with JM is tiresome to me. It's like this in every game I have played. JM slips up in some way, gets himself and the town confused, gets flustered and ends up innocent anyways. I'm not saying he's innocent, because I don't know, but I have to think to myself that maybe he's just bad at proofreading? lol

Bally still makes me nervous but I'm getting pretty sleepy in my typing so that's all I'm going to say about her right now.

Lastly, LG, where are ya? I usually expect to see her by evening. I agree with what Pappy has mentioned about her as well as my own observations made earlier. As of right now, she is my strongest suspect in my gut.

I vote to lynch Lady G
 
That may sound like im skimming over the question. I have not seen anything scummy, but my judgments off right now, IDK why, it just is. Im getting my brainpower back now though. The small activity in mafia is bringing back my "skill" and normal posting procedures now.


How have you not seen anything scummy??? JM is making incorrect statements in several places. PP has said more than a few things to peak my interest, and seems to have retreated. Bally has said a couple of things that make her suspicious. LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice for some reason, not sure why.

Right now, I could vote for either FF, JM, or LG. I want to see more from PP and Bally before voting for either of them. Maybe FF was really at grandma's that whole time, and I know JM made many flubs as an innocent, but I still can't figure why in the world LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice and on to her.

I think I'll give LG what she wants...I retract my vote on Ice and vote to lynch LG. If LG shows jock then I will be voting and keeping my vote on Ice next.
 
Geez Tay, ya ninja'ed me there with that vote while I was typing.

Wanted to let y'all know my time will be very limited tomorrow, but I will try to check in when on pit stops and hopefully I'll be around for nightfall.
 
Vote count:

0 Ice - Lab_rat(361) Chill(401)
2 JM - DD(397) Ice(439)
2 FF - Dawg(433) Noods(495)
2 LG - Tay(511) Lab(512)


No votes:
Jpappy, Ballyhoo, Razzlefish, Patrick.paul, Fishfriend, Maverickbr77, RBishop, Rich, Lady G, JM1212, Chill

Just thought I would update this...I think it's correct but let me know if you hve something different...

3/5 suspects are tied at two a piece but obviously there's a lot of time left and people left who haven't voted.

I honestly don't have a top suspect at this point. Too much has gone on. I'm going to have to wait and see what happens tomorrow before voting I think.
 
Time to make some waves. FTW, idc what you think about the following comments, contradiction, and/or insanity.

I have a moment to post, no idea what time night fall is but i will vote now I vote to lynch JB

I will give my reasons why when I get another chance to sit down. Sorry everyone.

No offense to you, but this is the same game you played before when evil. Finding time to throw in a jab or a vote but never actually contributing much information or help.

You played with Ballyhoo b4?

Typical day one - lots of fluff. I do have a feeling that Pat slipped and apparently so do many others....My vote may go there but I want to wait a little while longer, see waht else happnes and read again. Starting late leaves me at a bit of a disadvantage but :huh:

Stalling...

I have to agree with pappy. Your case against chill was weak, but at least you had a case against him. But instead of that, you go with Bally? I vote to lynch DD just in case I don't get back.

UN, don't tempt me.

? What case against Chill?

And how would UN have tempted you?

Ice - what's your secret?

maybe that should have been posted elsewhere...? AKA: Scumden.

Well, I need to place a vote. I usually do not like to vote noob on day 1 but the slip from Pat bothers me the most at this point. I vote to lynch Pat. I have only played a game or two with UN so not seeing what a few others are altho I am not willing to clear him; the other two in the running (dawg & bally) I am not seeing a case for them yet either......Rich is certainly posting more but I dont think this reflects his role - it never has before.
I am sorry i am lagging a bit but i hope to be more up to speed by tomorrow.

You don't like to vote newbs but you vote one? Huh?

Seriously? I might just have to now, I have a hell of a hard time turning down a dare.

Jocks usually do ;)

so do a certain kind of geek

Defending Lab?

I just love how humble you are! :lipssealedsmilie:

:iagree:

And you complain about my BS posts that waste time...

Another lesson in humility! :bowing:


It will be interesting to see where this goes over the next day or two....

More stalling and putting off helping...

Good Lord! Can we stop with the testosterone poisoning and the jock strap size comparison boys? "I dare you"; "I double dog dare you".....come on! We lost 3 geeks in one night!

Hey look, some BS.

This goes for you too, Labby!

And labby should care why? I call BS.

well, I must retire to my boudoir for the night.......more tommorow.....

Night. (BS)

Wow that did not go well. In fat it sucked.

I a thinking Bally, she is scared of JB and a vote is great cover for a hit.

JM for posting thoughts of others right after they posted them and then a lame and untrue reason for his vote.

(Fact?)

Yes, Ballys vote would be great cover for a hit, but i tend to think it was a cowinkidink. Don't trust my judgment though!

LMAO..yes Lab that is what I am doing...I DARE you to vote me:perv:

Distracting her from Ice with a challenge? Hmm...

Actually LG, I'm waiting to see who you lean innocent because that's who I'm going to really look into. As an innocent, you have an uncanny knack for protecting scum. Now if you're scum, that plan gets thrown out the window.

Sad thing is labs right... in the werewolf game you were more a danger to the town then a help. I have never trusted you since, even with what little i had b4 that game...

No.



No.

The only time Chill was mentioned involving me and DD is when I had quoted Chill and asked a question to Razz but didn't clarify that until the next post. DD skimmed that apparently and tried to call me out on what I said about Chill (really Razz). Not sure how Jm came up with this case on Chill though and I would like him to explain that.

Pretty fast to get away from JM, eh pappy?

I am in agreement with this as well; where did JM come up with that "weak case againt Chill"? I think it's time to wash those gym clothes boys. The smell in the locker room must be making your little pea brains all woozy!

Getting ready for a meeting but will definitely look into it on my lunch break.

Some Bs and repeating of what others have said... again.

You know what's really weird? Rich and Razz both have more posts than jpap, LG, and FF. :nilly:

first brings up my lack of posting.

JM's "slip" about DD's case on Chill is certainly odd, but I am tempted to let it slide for now...The last game I played with him, he also flubbed up pretty bad and caught crap for it for days & got lynched. He wound up being innocent. I don't want to see that happen again if this is a typical thought process with him.

Be back in a bit...need to do some digging............

Again with repeating what others have said without adding anything new...

Thought I would take a look at a few players - first Mav: (deleted the beginning fluff/non game related posts)


I agree with what someone else said - that first you start out pointing a finger at Pat for learning how to multi quote (which I do find suspicious since he did not ask anyone in the game thread) and then you turn around and defend him. the bolded part of your quote is a bit confusing but it sounds like you are pointing a finger at anyone who mentions Pat being suspicious. Are the two of you jock pals, perhaps?


Not really much there with the exception of that one post. Noob trying to get the feel of the game? or Scum defending a team mate? I will hold my verdict until I see more posts from him......

Now, onto PP. :lipssealedsmilie:

Holds verdict, not helping.

Sorry if this is a bit long.....

Ok - now for PP: (again, I deleted the early game fluff/non game related posts) with the exception of the controversial posts to JB

had to leave this one in - it is too funny! :rofl:

First of all, only a jock would say "hit them first and hard" and second of all - I really do not need a mental picture of geeks "turning on" themselves! *shudder*

Here is where you begin to point a finger at LG....

hhhhmmmm

Questions were asked and you skirted around them - repeatedly.



ok, so she is not on your radar but you continue to call her out and point your finger at her for "instigating"....trying to deflect the attention away from you onto someone else?


We all know that geeks are used to being picked on thus they have skins of armor; jocks on the other hand, cannot handle their little egos trampled upon...:silly:


Well, you were on the thread earlier, presumably reading - it is now afternoon and not a peep from you.....anything to add?

Not sure where I place PP right now. Did he know JB was a geek and cozy up to appear innocent or was that really just day one goofing off?
I do not like the way he points his finger at LG but yet says she is not on his radar. Seems pretty scummy to me.
I would really like to hear more from him before I put my vote back on him......


Gald we have one more day to vote....will have to look into a few others... :uhoh:

Already stated.
Again, already states (as far as i read)

Already stated... again.

I know that from experience. Bullys hate to be bullied. But still, that may not hold true in a game. Trying to distract or just adding a little bit of truth to spice it up?

Kinda obvious, and i think it was stated b4.

Good points, but again you just make a hint of a choice, not an actual choice3.And again you stall and say "later, ill decide later".

So, where did you look into others?

So to get back into this, my motive for my next vote will be based on the "who would wedgie jbradt". I am deciding whether or not the people who voted for his lynching will be safe from my vote tomorrow night. An easy way to make yourself look non-scummy is to vote for the person you're going to wedgie to try and pass the blame. Seeing as Bally has been coached before, I'm wondering if she was told by her fellow jocks to lay low by doing this? More to come when I get a chance to read through..

Took you a long time to come up with such a simple idea. Find out who would want Jb dead... anyone evil.

Very true Ice. I may not let it slide for long, but I certainly will not let it narrow my focus yet....

Aw, shucks! Thanks. It's not something I get to do often but I had a little free time at work. Hopefully I will have time to look closer at a few others; and I agree with your thoughts on both Mav and PP.

Again, BS and stalling. When will you choose?

How is someone telling their teammate what to do NOT coaching?

What was I supposed to say? Jm is all over the place and keeps referencing things that never happened.

He's on my list along with DD and maybe Pat. I'm still a little weary of thinking that what he said is scummy rather than newby but he too is all over the place, throwing out names left and right. I also suspect LG for some of the things she has said since right before nightfall regarding Jb, Bally, etc.

Someone also mentioned that FF said he wouldn't be back until Wednesday (today). Funny, because if you look at his profile you see this...

View attachment 133394

Hmmm, and you had nothing to say FF? Seems rather unlike you...

And my lack of posting re-surfaces.

^He also posted once in GCC.

Yep, to OMOTS. He's leaving the hobby, and i wanted to say my peace b4 my grammy showed up.

:silly: Very true but I was taking into consideration that the day is not over yet....until i saw this post from JP!!

Whoa!!! Very un-FF-like!!! To be on the forum and not grace us with his infinite wisdom and spectacular spelling!?!?!?

Darn kids!

all interesting points.

Again, no real info, just a ton of hints and BS. And sarcasm is not necessary, it not the lowest form of intelligence, its not intelligence at all.

I feel like we're at the same point this game as last...so many odd things going on that could be considered scummy.

Yep, oddities all round.

Oh greatest one, should not JM have 2 votes?

Still, this is funny :D

well, FF that was a really long post with really no content to it what-so-ever...do you have anything useful to say?

And you've said more? At least im trying...

Looks to me like he grabbed posts he could comment on without really saying a thing. That whole think was just about pointless.

*Sigh* When i post alot of this, no one says it crap, but when itys all put in one big *** post, boom, its all crap.

well, I need to call it a day and based on FF's recent post - or lack there-of; I vote to lynch FF. just posting a bunch of crap just for the sake of posting is a waste of my time.

Let's see what tomorrow brings....

Once again, you leave it for tommorrow, but this time you acted, voting me because of the content of my first non-joke post this game. And i know im a geek.

FF, how many times has it been that you've tried to change so far? I'm sorry but a huge break like that when you visited the site is not very innocent looking. Has nothing to do with posting for the sake of posting but you couldn't pop in and say anything? It looks like you just plain ignored the game but still found time to get on AC anyways. You're usually the most talkative person in the game and I don't believe you wouldn't post unless you planned not to for some ulterior reason.

I find this hard to believe. You honestly think that out of everything said there isn't one thing that could be seen as scummy?

I did ignore the game. i didn't want to get caught up and then suddently drop off the map, and i wanted to send my condolances to OMOTS, for obviuse reasons. I was also short on time and needed to eat.

Not anymore. Noods seems scummy to me. But at the time, yes, nothing was scummy, and my mafia self was sleeping. The insane beast has awoken...

In an effort to consolidate my suspect list, here goes...no particular order...

Jm- been posting nonsense all game. Misreading? Maybe, but IMO it's too blatant to ignore the misquoting going on. A protown player is going to double check the facts before trying to put a case out there on someone. A scum player could care less if it is true just so the person goes down...unless they get caught. I think that is why he flubbed again.

DD- I still stand by my D1 vote for the same reason. That post was a bunch of fluff and it's weird she has never said anything about skimming my posts. Instead she gets defensive and turns around on me saying there was other things I should have picked up on...yet she didn't either...she has also taken off on the Jm thing. I'm not saying that is scummy in of itself but possibly some distancing going on here.

FF- just read the last page and you'll see why. I do not buy the excuses he is throwing out about why he isn't posting.

Pat- he too has been all over the place but I still am not sure if its due to a jittery, scummy newb or an overly-excited, innocent newb. He's thrown a lot of names out there but it could just be getting a handle on the game for all I know. Warrants further watching.

LG- the whole thing with JB and Bally seemed illogical to me when you really think about it. Would an evil Bally really try to go after JB based on nothing but something from a past game? Jb didn't think so and I see his point. That doesn't mean I find her innocent, but the way LG jumped on him and then right away put it out there that the hit was from Bally really caught my eye. And then the whole sarcastic bickering with Lab over her joke vote on Ice. She seems a little more agitated than the normal LG.


Wasn't

I agree, LG has behaved like someone hiding somthing, someone guilty.

But my case is against Noods. I will now seal that case. I vote to lynch noods. for just following and agreeing and not helping the town in any meaningfull way. Vote is prone to change.
 
<snip a whole bunch>
But my case is against Noods. I will now seal that case. I vote to lynch noods. for just following and agreeing and not helping the town in any meaningfull way. Vote is prone to change.

Was that just a total OMGUS vote?
 
I honestly tried to post stuff that made sense to me.



Well maybe i've started to change. And maybe i thought that there were more important things to do at the time.


Trust me (ha, as if!) i do not have anyone "pulling the reigns"



Some people seem to think its what i always do... just post to post. Then, when i do post, everyone says its crap and starts to accuse me of stuff. If i always post crap, why is this any different.

I don't trust my judgment, my time away from mafia hasn't been good to me...

That happens in every person's life, usually around age 13...
 
How have you not seen anything scummy??? JM is making incorrect statements in several places. PP has said more than a few things to peak my interest, and seems to have retreated. Bally has said a couple of things that make her suspicious. LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice for some reason, not sure why.

Right now, I could vote for either FF, JM, or LG. I want to see more from PP and Bally before voting for either of them. Maybe FF was really at grandma's that whole time, and I know JM made many flubs as an innocent, but I still can't figure why in the world LG tried to draw my vote off of Ice and on to her.

I think I'll give LG what she wants...I retract my vote on Ice and vote to lynch LG. If LG shows jock then I will be voting and keeping my vote on Ice next.

Wait... So you are going to go against your conscience because someone else is 'trying' to draw your vote? Didn't you spend two days grilling me about that in a previous game when I was 'doing' the same thing?
 
AquariaCentral.com