Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

well Ice you already said my reason for voting Jb.


Zaffy said:
Vote count:

0 Ice - Lab_rat(361) Chill(401)
5 JM - DD(397) Ice(439) Lab_Rat(562) Jpapp(578) Chill(584)
4 FF - Dawg(433) Noodles(495) Taysius(593) Maverick(600)
1 Lady G – Taysius(511) Lab_Rat(512)
1 Noods – FF(515)
0 Bally – Lady G(529)
0 Lab_rat – Lady G(549) JM(595)


No votes:
Lady G, Ballyhoo, Razzlefish, Patrick.paul, RBishop, Rich
Click to expand...

by the time I got around to looking at FF he already had 4 votes, so of course mine was going to be a later vote. then in post #618 you voted for FF, as did Rich in post #622 before I even got an answer from FF. So there is 6 votes before I had my question answered. FF answered part of my question in #626, PP voted for him in #629. There is 7 votes before I had even gotten my question answered.

Like I said before....you give me crap because I didn't have a good enough reason and didn't say much for my first vote. Then you accuse me of repeating what others say for my second vote....I believe I found the white messages therefore that isn't really copying anyone.

Like I said, my comment about Razz's vote was a misread. I had to run out the door to go get weighed in, I wanted to finish my thought before I left and I shouldn't have done that, that's what I get for skimming
 
IceH2O said:
Bally can we get a suspect and why list from you?
Click to expand...

Jm- he is erratic, inconsistent and generally vague and confusing
PP- seems as if he slipped up at some point in the beginning and was told to hush, or he was just going along with day 1 banter and joking around and enjoying role playing. I can't rule him one way or another.
RB and DD- very quite but from playing the last game with them they seem to be more active at night. I'd like to see more from them
Razz- I don't feel as uneasy with razz as I did before, I realized my mistake and then how little sense my post made. ( Razz I'm sorry for calling you a girl )

I'm having a hard time getting a read on
Tay
Chill
Ice
Noods and Mav
 
Ballyhoo said:
Jm- he is erratic, inconsistent and generally vague and confusing
PP- seems as if he slipped up at some point in the beginning and was told to hush, or he was just going along with day 1 banter and joking around and enjoying role playing. I can't rule him one way or another.
RB and DD- very quite but from playing the last game with them they seem to be more active at night. I'd like to see more from them
Razz- I don't feel as uneasy with razz as I did before, I realized my mistake and then how little sense my post made. ( Razz I'm sorry for calling you a girl )

I'm having a hard time getting a read on
Tay
Chill
Ice
Noods and Mav
Click to expand...

PP is still one of your suspects? i guessed you skimmed over the posts where he stated he was going to UD.
 
jm1212 said:
PP is still one of your suspects? i guessed you skimmed over the posts where he stated he was going to UD.
Click to expand...

no I saw it. I was just stating...he hasn't come out as geek or jock yet so I still suspect him of being jock, I never said I was going to vote him.
 
neither did i...just seems odd that you would still list him as a suspect since he is you of the game without a doubt. having someone as a suspect implies that you are still willing to vote for him. you sure you saw that he was a definite UD? im not so sure that you did.
 
yes I am sure that Zaffy confirmed the pm that he was a UD.

I was making sure everyone had all of my thoughts on everyone since I don't post quality material.
 
Ballyhoo said:
Jm- he is erratic, inconsistent and generally vague and confusing
PP- seems as if he slipped up at some point in the beginning and was told to hush, or he was just going along with day 1 banter and joking around and enjoying role playing. I can't rule him one way or another.
RB and DD- very quite but from playing the last game with them they seem to be more active at night. I'd like to see more from them
Razz- I don't feel as uneasy with razz as I did before, I realized my mistake and then how little sense my post made. ( Razz I'm sorry for calling you a girl )

I'm having a hard time getting a read on
Tay
Chill
Ice
Noods and Mav
Click to expand...

Thanks, what about Dawg, Lab, Rich? Any reason you left them off the list?
 
Ballyhoo said:
well Ice you already said my reason for voting Jb.




by the time I got around to looking at FF he already had 4 votes, so of course mine was going to be a later vote. then in post #618 you voted for FF, as did Rich in post #622 before I even got an answer from FF. So there is 6 votes before I had my question answered. FF answered part of my question in #626, PP voted for him in #629. There is 7 votes before I had even gotten my question answered.

Like I said before....you give me crap because I didn't have a good enough reason and didn't say much for my first vote. Then you accuse me of repeating what others say for my second vote....I believe I found the white messages therefore that isn't really copying anyone.

Like I said, my comment about Razz's vote was a misread. I had to run out the door to go get weighed in, I wanted to finish my thought before I left and I shouldn't have done that, that's what I get for skimming
Click to expand...

It is not that hard to check a fact. Seems to me you were ready to start a case and guessed. That does not sit well. i would have gone back to check the voting before I started the case.

Ice JM said he was sure. I asked a leading question with different wording, meaning the same thing. I never said that is what he said.
 
I can't make up my mind about Dawg
I don't consider Lab a threat to the town
And rich is on the fence I am back and forth reading the thread still.
 
rich311k said:
It is not that hard to check a fact. Seems to me you were ready to start a case and guessed. That does not sit well. i would have gone back to check the voting before I started the case.

Ice JM said he was sure. I asked a leading question with different wording, meaning the same thing. I never said that is what he said.
Click to expand...


I knew what you meant lol..Just stirring the pot a little..Reactions are better then words sometimes.

I'm glad you see what I see in Bally though.

What about her leaving you dawg and lab off her list? Protecting or setting up?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom