Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

[Lab_Rat]

So you wouldn't vote to lynch Ice even if it meant you'd be saving yourself?

 

[Lab_Rat]

DD, I see you viewing the thread...how do you feel about voting out Ice or RB instead of Bally?

 

[Ballyhoo]

I fail to see how voting Ice would save me.

 

[Lab_Rat]

There is a small risk you're telling the truth and that JM is a liar. Small. So my proposal would be to vote out Ice or DD as I think they're both scummy. That way, the real network guru would not be voted out accidentally. Your hesitation and sidestepping is making me more comfortable with my vote on you, but tbh, Ice and DD are greater threats to the town than you are.

I fail to see why you would not vote out Ice if it meant saving yourself if you truly are innocent.

 

[dirtydawg10]

LG being innocent has cleared lab in my mind. Lab and LG have played together often and Lab says LG has a tendency to protect scum and she didn't try to protect lab and LG came up innocent, and the tone was too light between lab and LG.

Dawg is getting more suspicious to me in the fact that he jumped on PP for learning how to multiquote so quickly and then flipped and protected him at one point.

Rich isn't that suspicious to me, last game when I played scum with him he was much quieter and this game he has been much more vocal.

Can you show me the posts where I jumped on PP for learning to multi-quote and then protected them?

Okay DD knows we lost 3 geeks but now doesn't know one of them was Pap? I'm having trouble with that.

DOH!! all I paid attention to was the geeks.

However, still does not explain Bally's reason for placing me in her list.... now it's because she coulda sworn I played with her? Come on.... I have felt pretty strongly about JM being a jock and I still do but Bally is quickly beginning to climb the ladder aboce him. If I do switch my vote, it willdefinitely go to Bally.


they aren't huh....


I guess I didn't pay so much attention to WHO it was, just what they were...

This after 2 people pointed out to her that JPap was dead. Me and Chill I believe.

Well Jm it will be your word against mine.....

I am the Detective.
On night one Dawg was investigated and proven innocent
Day 2 I investigated Lab who also turned out to be innocent.

In the end it is the decision of the ACU.

If lynching me means revealing Jm for the scum he is I will gladly be lynched.

Wow! I agree it looks strange that you question if I'm innocent then come out and say you investigated me. Doesn't make much sense. Are you trying to set me up if you turn out to be the true scum?

Bally, I thought that you were just talking about how dawg could be scum? Now you just said you found him to be innocent on day 1. If you knew he was innocent, how could you still hold him a suspect? And why would you invest dawg if you were so convinced JB was up to no good?

And if you really got the PM, or at least read the rules, you would know that Network Guru is really the term.

I thought that was strange too.

This may sound crazy, but I don't like how freaking quickly Ice and DD voted to lynch Bally. I'm pretty darn sure both of them are scum, and that Bally is, but part of me thinks we should lynch Ice or DD instead of Bally. Any one else think that is a good idea?

I was wondering about why so many people jumped on Bally for coming out. I would like to hear from those who voted Bally...what made you choose to vote Bally over JM?

 

[Lab_Rat]

I was wondering about why so many people jumped on Bally for coming out. I would like to hear from those who voted Bally...what made you choose to vote Bally over JM?

I am believing JM over Bally for a few reasons.

1. I didn't see why scum would need to false role claim at that time when JM came out. It was a smart time for the network guru to come out as the scum team about has our town over a barrel if there are indeed 5 scum.

2. JM's reasoning for investigating LG on night 1 made sense. He also adamantly backed her being innocent all throughout day 2. It all holds.

3. JM said he investigated me on night 2. His reasoning as to why he investigated me makes sense as well.

4. If Bally had truly investigated you, she would not continue saying you were suspicious or scummy. That makes no sense, nor do her reasons for why she investigated you or I.

Dawg, who is on your scum list? Do you see the merit in voting out Ice or DD tonight instead of Bally or JM?

 

[dirtydawg10]

Bally is this where I voted PP for multi-quoting??

I disagree...cool kids don't have to continually try and convince geeks that they are cool. Only a geek who longs to be cool does that. Just embrace your geekdom Ice :silly:

For now I vote to lynch PP (Patrick Paul - I just wanted to say PP)

I think a Jock would more likely try to convince us they are a geek than the other way around. We need more mafia strategy talk and a little less fluffy geek talk.

I don't think so.

Is this where I protected PP??

JM's post does seem strange to me too. Not 100% sure what to think right now.

Right now though I'd say my top 2 suspects are still PP and Maverick also makes my list. Not so much because of the vote on me but more because of the reasoning for the vote on me. I'll have to keep a close eye on him.

I know I stated my top 2 suspects and this is currently not one of them but...

I vote to lynch FF

I don't have a problem voting for PP right now either but FF just doesn't seem like himself. Only 6 posts thus far tells me something is up with him too. I figur I'll put my vote on FF and see if that gets him to participate more in this game.

Again I don't think so. You say you investigated me D1 for this but my 2 quotes where I voted FF instead of PP was on D2 not D1.

I vote to lynch Bally

I think it is pretty obvious that Bally is lying. I think she came out to try and confuse the Doc so they would have to make a 50/50 decision on who to protect.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I am believing JM over Bally for a few reasons.

1. I didn't see why scum would need to false role claim at that time when JM came out. It was a smart time for the network guru to come out as the scum team about has our town over a barrel if there are indeed 5 scum.

2. JM's reasoning for investigating LG on night 1 made sense. He also adamantly backed her being innocent all throughout day 2. It all holds.

3. JM said he investigated me on night 2. His reasoning as to why he investigated me makes sense as well.

4. If Bally had truly investigated you, she would not continue saying you were suspicious or scummy. That makes no sense, nor do her reasons for why she investigated you or I.

Dawg, who is on your scum list? Do you see the merit in voting out Ice or DD tonight instead of Bally or JM?

Bally is on my scum list tonight. I am innocent but I think she was setting me up as her invest so people would come after me next thinking she was protecting me.

As far as voting Ice and DD. I'd be more willing to vote DD than Ice but I'm pretty comfortable with a vote on Bally.

 

[Zaffy]

Vote count:

1 JM - Ice(704) Lab_Rat(711) DD(714) RB(867)
0 PP - Dawg(721)
0 Lab_rat - Noods(729)
0 DD - Mav(836)
10 Bally - DD(845) Noods(853) Mav(854) Rich(855) Razzle(857) Ice(858) Tay(859) Lab_rat(860) JM(861) Dawg(907)


No votes by:

Ballyhoo, Patrick.paul, Chill




Nightfall in 3 hours 47 minutes.

 

[Rbishop]

JM hasn't done anything to prove he is the detective.....that and the earlier position of folks calling him evil or voting for him is enough for me.