Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

the more I think about it, the more it makes sense for me to vote S4S right now. He hasn't been helpful to the town, and has proven to be extremely scummy. I like my vote on Ice, but I feel more confident with a vote on S4S.

I retract my previous vote, and vote to lynch S4S
(salt4sam)
 
Picked up on the votes after Pappy posted the count last. Please let me know if I've missed something... I was in a hurry. Thanks.

3 Salt - UN 6 Wizard 370 Bally 411 Razzle 486
1 Dawg - Lab 204
5 Lab - Ice 231 JM 236 LadyG 381 Hayden 382 Kashta 387 Piranha 390
4 Ice - User 286 Rich 396 Piranha 471 Mav 483
1 Pir - Haydn 301 Dawg 418

1 Chill - JB 373
2 User - Salt 383 Chill 459
0 Lady G - Piranha 397 (probably won't count/previous vote not retracted 1st)

No vote (???): Dangerdoll, Patrickpaul, TwoHobbies, Zaffy.

That's not the landslide I was thinking it was, so what I'll do is wait to post my thoughts as to how I came up with my theory and why I struggled with whether to come out with it until right before nightfall. That way, if I'm gone either way (lynch or hit), I'll have put it out there and hopefully it will help the town after my death.
 
Well there is a lot that could warrant a day 1 vote, but nothing bothers me more than Ice calling for protection, and the invest on a first game player. I just can not find a way in my mind to spin that pro town.

I vote to lynch Ice
 
the more I think about it, the more it makes sense for me to vote S4S right now. He hasn't been helpful to the town, and has proven to be extremely scummy. I like my vote on Ice, but I feel more confident with a vote on S4S.

I retract my previous vote, and vote to lynch S4S
(salt4sam)

Does that count? Cant remember who you had voted for?
 
Does that count? Cant remember who you had voted for?
sorry I didn't realize I still had to say ices name in my retraction. if you read my whole post you would've been able to see that rich.

I retract my previous vote to lynch Ice, and vote to lynch Salt4Sam.
 
Wow, this does not look like a favorable outcome for tonight. Let me start by apologizing to the town. I was torn about whether I should come out with my theory or keep it to myself until later in the game. After going back and forth about it in my head, I decided to take the risk and put it out there. I will expand on my thought process and why I decided to come out with the wack theory if it looks like I'm going to be lynched for this nightfall. I'll compose it and post it at 7:30 EST if things haven't changed drastically. I don't expect any of you to trust me, but it really would be better for the town if I do not need to post my thoughts in such a manner.

<< Snipped the middle part >>

As I've already stated, I'm not voting you for your wack vote/theory about Dawg, Lab Rat. So I'm not sure what you may or may not post before nightfall that'll make any difference in my mind.

That's usually the case Kash, I should have slept on it before answering.

Not playing fast and loose. What you're picking up on was my indecision about whether to say anything about my suspicions or not. Obviously in hindsight the correct answer was "or not". But I couldn't risk not putting things out there in case I was prematurely silenced. If I am correct, then we are faced with a very dangerous scum team (at least two of the players) and I'm sure they would have come to similar conclusions that I have. I will explain this further when we get closer to nightfall if I'm still on the chopping block.

<< snipped this part too >>

Labby, I'm not picking up an indecision vibe from you. You got my vote for evasion and being untruthful.

When I saw you'd skip over a reasonable question asked of you directly... that made me wonder why. I still didn't go after you or give you hard time over that.... I simply asked you to explain it. You didn't, so I asked again.... and I believe the answer you gave me was not truthful. I reserved judgement about this and gave you full opportunity to address it.... but you didn't, so you got my vote. That, plus the fact that you're acting like scum (already covered by the posts of others)... I don't see much else to say about this.

Now, you tell us you're sorry for messing this up. You maintain your innocence and are hoping we won't lynch you. You also state that you have good reasons voting Dawg which you'd rather not tell us.

At best, Labby, if you really are innocent... all I can figure is you have some other theory in mind which you may or may not reveal. This being Day 1 still, no one on either side have an investigation result, so I expect anything else you could possibly have to say would not be actual evidence. And, frankly, I'm not real keen to hear much more unsubstantiated speculation from you.
 
If you were an innocent townie wouldn't you know that innocents didn't get a PM

That's a slip-and-a-half. Only PR's and mafia got PM's.

Why are you protecting Ice? His game play has seemed off to me and now he posts something that could have been a slip and you push it off as Ice being strategic?

After that slip from Ice,I retract my vote on LG and vote to lynch Ice.


I think that's probably the best reason to vote him.

I highly doubt that he meant that to put me in a trap or whatever.

Ice, I don't know if that was meant so that I would screw up and say that I received a PM saying I was innocent, or if you received a PM and didn't read the 2nd post. Either way, it was a screw up. Care to elaborate?


You don't know me very well do you.

Glad to see Mav had your back there Pir. Weren't around in the scum den for him to tell you to not say it said innocent townie?

I PMSL when you guys called that a slip. I was hoping to trip Pir up because innocents didn't get PMs.


I'm glad to be in the running for lynch. Saves me from being hit and if the votes do fall my way it helps lead the innocents to the scum.

To all those voting me for the "slip" watch them. For those voting me for thinking Salt is Vig or snitch watch them too but honestly it won't help till he is lynched or hit and shows either one. If he doesn't show then I was way off.

I'm thinking about moving my vote off Lab, I know it puts me closer to being lynched but Lab if innocent is just as good if not better for the town then me. Maybe we can get a tie coin flip out of it.
I think Pir and Mav stand out more.

I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Pir


Think that puts us both at 5, Lab. Also gives you the chance to take me out with your lone vote on Dawg.
 
I retract my vote on Lab and vote to lynch Pir

Think that puts us both at 5, Lab. Also gives you the chance to take me out with your lone vote on Dawg.

I think it doesn't, Ice, if my count is right. Looks like a 3-way coin toss with 4 votes each at the moment.

4 Salt - User 6 Wizard 370 Bally 411 Razzle 486 User 491/495
1 Dawg - Lab 204
4 Lab - Ice 231 JM 236 LadyG 381 Hayden 382 Kashta 387 Piranha 390
4 Ice - User 286 Rich 396 Piranha 471 Mav 483 TwoH 493
2 Pir - Haydn 301 Dawg 418 Ice 498

1 Chill - JB 373
2 User - Salt 383 Chill 459
0 Lady G - Piranha 397 (probably won't count/previous vote not retracted 1st)

No vote (???): Dangerdoll, Patrickpaul, Zaffy.
 
AquariaCentral.com