Wow, this does not look like a favorable outcome for tonight. Let me start by apologizing to the town. I was torn about whether I should come out with my theory or keep it to myself until later in the game. After going back and forth about it in my head, I decided to take the risk and put it out there. I will expand on my thought process and why I decided to come out with the wack theory if it looks like I'm going to be lynched for this nightfall. I'll compose it and post it at 7:30 EST if things haven't changed drastically. I don't expect any of you to trust me, but it really would be better for the town if I do not need to post my thoughts in such a manner.
I've changed my mind. Labby is very sus to me now. Especially after making so many cases and jumping on peoples comments/ theories. And the answer for not seeing any scum was not adequate enough for me...
I retract my vote on pirana and vote to lynch labby
Another coincidence that you follow LG's vote?
Because i see hand-picking as something that would cause controversy since it wild be easy to make a super team or a noob team. With only a few of the past games actualy being finished, I don't know why he would want to add something that could end the game prematurely. Also like I have said before, I would rather not get caught up in pappy's mind so this is only a theory as to why he may have not hand-picked them
JM, I've pulled this post by jpap from the Christmas game he modded, Mafia #60:
And all the PRs were hand chosen this time around...
The RED severum (santa). Noodles avatar had a dog with reindeer antlers (rudolph). ZsandMANn (frosty the snowman). FIREdancer (Jack frost). And Ice is just a Grinch lol.
I was just pulling your leg...I know you're joking because I 'know' you if you know what I'm saying
Good, I wasn't sure if you knew I was joking.
The piece so far that I am most interested in right now though is the comments made about JPap hand picking roles. From my experience this is not what JPap does and I do believe he has even stated that he prefers the randomly picked games. I could be thinking of someone else but I'm pretty sure it was JPap. This theory seems to be something thrown out there to confuse what's really going on here...almost something a mafia member would bring up especially if the mafia team is a group who may not seem to be hand picked similar to last game. I need to go back and look into this a bit more.
See the quote I pulled from jpap's Christmas game, posted above.
Perhaps Lab Rat should have gone to bed last night when she told us she was going to. Maybe she would have thought up more believable answers had she slept on it.
<snip>
She seems to be playing fast and loose with the truth this game. This, along with many other suspicions already raised and talked about by other players, leads me to believe Labby is scum.
That's usually the case Kash, I should have slept on it before answering.
Not playing fast and loose. What you're picking up on was my indecision about whether to say anything about my suspicions or not. Obviously in hindsight the correct answer was "or not". But I couldn't risk not putting things out there in case I was prematurely silenced. If I am correct, then we are faced with a very dangerous scum team (at least two of the players) and I'm sure they would have come to similar conclusions that I have. I will explain this further when we get closer to nightfall if I'm still on the chopping block.
Wait, what if Lab Rat was blackmailed? Her vote was completely random and didn't make sense, it seems like something a don would do to get her voted off. I'm going to go with that theory and retract my vote on LR.
As much as I would like to pretend I was blackmailed, I cannot because I was not. The decision to lay my vote on Dawg was mine and mine alone. As I said previously, putting my wack theory out there was a hard decision for me to make. I did not expect this badly of an outcome.
That's a slip-and-a-half. Only PR's and mafia got PM's.
No Pir, that is one of Ice's famous Icetraps (R).
I do have to say (and you don't have to believe this now, but after nightfall please come back to this) that I believe Pir is likely innocent. No scum would have come up with an excuse like blackmail to try and get me off the hook. I'm an easy lynch for them this time, they're not going to try to mess that up.
So, to all the townies, I'm sorry, I screwed up royally. To the scum team: :silly: I made this all to easy for you.