Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[jm1212]

nope. thats the problem, I don't trust pir at all at this point. JM ruined any form of role claim for the rest of my life. My life has been so dramatically altered by his amazingness last game.... It makes me think that someone would try that.

good, i saved the best for last.

Wowsies. I don't understand why everyone would listen to pir when he says I'm 100% scum with no prove, explanation or evidence...well at least I know he will be gone tomorrow night. And can someone tell me what PR stands for? Is it like the major roles? Like doctor and that? Thanks.

his 'investigation' was supposed to be the proof.

yes, PR stands for player role. I'm surprised that you didn't pick that up yet, its pretty obvious. In my mind it bears more truth to pir's claims.

PR is for power role...though since Haydn didnt know what it was, it kinda throws the whole 'coached' thing out the window for me.

Pir, please show us some posts as to where Haydn looks like they are being coached. when i looked back, i really couldnt find any. in fact, there weren't many of any substance, except a few that just went and said what everyone else had said about you and UN. i think it would be very convenient to claim they are scum since 1. they are a noob and 2. noone had even thought about questioning Haydn. it's a parallel to the werewolf game in that two of the three werewolves were complete noobs that were being coached by labby the entire game. noone saw it coming from them. you picking a random noob to investigate and claim is a mafia would fit along these lines pretty well.

I just did the "No Votes thing so here is the updated version.

Vote Count
3- Pir- Zaffy (634), Haydn (731), Dawg (753), Razz (762), Kash (817), DD (817), Rich (897)
5- Haydn- Pir (637), Pir (843), Razz (844), Zaffy (846), Dawg (890), DD (909)
1- S4S- User (673), Pir (824), Bally (845)
1- Zaffy- Rich (797), User (869)
1-Rich- JB (800)
　
No votes:
Chill, TwoHobbies, Jm, Mav, Lady G, Salt, Wizard

thanks, Razz!

 

[Kashta]

Just got on and there's a crap load of reading to do. Back soon.

 

[Kashta]

I just did the "No Votes thing so here is the updated version.

Vote Count
3- Pir- Zaffy (634), Haydn (731), Dawg (753), Razz (762), Kash (817), DD (817), Rich (897)
5- Haydn- Pir (637), Pir (843), Razz (844), Zaffy (846), Dawg (890), DD (909)
1- S4S- User (673), Pir (824), Bally (845)
1- Zaffy- Rich (797), User (869)
1-Rich- JB (800)
　
No votes:
Chill, TwoHobbies, Jm, Mav, Lady G, Salt, Wizard

Razzle... how did I end up in your vote tally? I have not placed my vote.

 

[Lady G]

Wow, is each Day going to be full of so much craziness!!!

Since nobody's going to listen to me that I am 100% sure that Haydn is scum, I retract my vote and vote to lynch Salt4Sam, so we have a close runner up in the election.

Ok, this made no sense to me...if you know 100% why would you take your vote off him?

That means that Hay is scum. Pir is scum and Zaf is scum. Only two ways that Pir could know Hay's status and I am not buying one of them.

Trust me and I gift you 3 scum - Pir, Zaf and Hay.

I am under no real suspicion, nothing to save so you all decide.

So, how can you know all 3 are scum? I never knew not being under real suspicion clears you and makes what you say is true.

Best part is if you want this to work you cant hit me or it is proven. I get at least one more look see.

You seem to leave off the fact the mafia could think the same thing and hit you even if he is not mafia just to make it seem that way.

I felt like I had the best chance of catching scum from noobs. There were 3 first times, Mav, Haydn, Salt. Mav hardly plays, I X'ed him out, so I had to decide b/t Haydn and Salt. If I would have had more time, I probably would have decided on Salt, but I had 5 minutes to choose and after some quick skimming, I decided on Haydn. Haydn really sounds like he's being coached.

Yeah, I guess. Haydn sounds like he's being coached.

Shhhhh I don't want the scum to figure it out! But, yeah I am.

Ok, so you are throwing a RC out there, so if you ARE telling the truth the town will loose another PR..you do realize that right?

I can assure you he will not get that fate.

Why is that?

Go ahead and lynch me at least 3 mafia will be know then.

Pir was the lead for the lynch, he gets another day and an innocent or two out of this.

I was under no suspicion, nothing to gain if a mafia, if I am who you think I am saying I am I got you 3 scums.

Now you also are RCing...also taking the chance for the town to loose another PR...this is just so wrong.

it got real quiet.....


any thoughs LG?

Yep..I got thoughts, had to get through all the stuff posted first. Sorry I'm not a speed reader and it takes me a bit to get through so many posts.

 

[Lady G]

So what this day has boiled down to is 2 ppl pretty much RCing again. Now it is up to us to decide who to believe.

I can't get over the fact that after loosing the DR last night, the supposed detective is willing to come out..this takes our last remaining PR from us, IF neither of you are mafia you have completely screwed the town. There is no way I can see you are both innocent, and am having an even harder time believing EITHER of you are.

So now I have to decide, do I vote one of you...do I vote one that you have "claimed" to be mafia I just don't know.

It looks to me I have to vote either Rich, Pir or Hay. I think we as a town need to come together somehow and decide....are we going to make a three way, a two way or go for one of them only. That is the only way we have to "prove" who is telling the truth. I hate this, one way or another if EITHER are telling the truth will will be loosing our last PR...yes I know we still have the Vig and hope they make the right choice when they take their hit, but we no longer have any form of "protection" and after tomorrow night there is a HUGE chance we will loose our investigations.

 

[rich311k]

Now you also are RCing...also taking the chance for the town to loose another PR...this is just so wrong.

Why? multiple scum for just me. I may not pick right again. I think it is a fine trade.

 

[rich311k]

So what this day has boiled down to is 2 ppl pretty much RCing again. Now it is up to us to decide who to believe.

I can't get over the fact that after loosing the DR last night, the supposed detective is willing to come out..this takes our last remaining PR from us, IF neither of you are mafia you have completely screwed the town. There is no way I can see you are both innocent, and am having an even harder time believing EITHER of you are.

So now I have to decide, do I vote one of you...do I vote one that you have "claimed" to be mafia I just don't know.

It looks to me I have to vote either Rich, Pir or Hay. I think we as a town need to come together somehow and decide....are we going to make a three way, a two way or go for one of them only. That is the only way we have to "prove" who is telling the truth. I hate this, one way or another if EITHER are telling the truth will will be loosing our last PR...yes I know we still have the Vig and hope they make the right choice when they take their hit, but we no longer have any form of "protection" and after tomorrow night there is a HUGE chance we will loose our investigations.

There is no protection there is single player maybe knowing something that he has to get people to believe. Not much power there.

Why would two mafia do it at the same time?

 

[Lady G]

There is no protection there is single player maybe knowing something that he has to get people to believe. Not much power there.

Why would two mafia do it at the same time?

I don't know Rich....I really don't think they would, but the way everything is going this round, I have know idea anymore.

 

[jm1212]

So what this day has boiled down to is 2 ppl pretty much RCing again. Now it is up to us to decide who to believe.

I can't get over the fact that after loosing the DR last night, the supposed detective is willing to come out..this takes our last remaining PR from us, IF neither of you are mafia you have completely screwed the town. There is no way I can see you are both innocent, and am having an even harder time believing EITHER of you are.

So now I have to decide, do I vote one of you...do I vote one that you have "claimed" to be mafia I just don't know.

It looks to me I have to vote either Rich, Pir or Hay. I think we as a town need to come together somehow and decide....are we going to make a three way, a two way or go for one of them only. That is the only way we have to "prove" who is telling the truth. I hate this, one way or another if EITHER are telling the truth will will be loosing our last PR...yes I know we still have the Vig and hope they make the right choice when they take their hit, but we no longer have any form of "protection" and after tomorrow night there is a HUGE chance we will loose our investigations.

there is still the vigilante.

 

[Lady G]

Why? multiple scum for just me. I may not pick right again. I think it is a fine trade.

Ok, but how do we know it would be multiple scum? Rich, I want to believe you I really do..but you can't blame me for my doubts