Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[Chill]

pirana, answer my question!! and give some evidence that I'm scum... I would like to hear it myself. And i highly doubt your a detective.

Haydn that last part gives me pause, if you're innocent you would be saying you know he is not the detective. His claim is he is the detective and he is strongly impling that he investigated you and you are scum. If you know you're not scum wouldn't you also know he is not the detective. Why do you merely doubt?

 

[Lady G]

He did come out to save himself or at least to go down as a mafia champion. I don't care how new your are at this, hay had 5 posts maybe day one, he was a big threat to who? his lunch.

If Hay is mafia, he is a threat period. I have know idea why Pir does what he does, but just because he didn't investigate who you would of, doesn't make his reason any less valid.

Thanks rich, at least someone has some brains around here if everyone votes to lynch pirana and finds he is scum then you will all know I'm telling the truth... I know I haven't been investigated, especially by pirana so therefore he is lying to get another innocent lynched... I hope everyone understands this.

IF he is lynched and found mafia, it will not clear you in anyway.

 

[Haydn24]

If pir is lying, how does that make me scum LG?

 

[the wizard]

Thanks rich, at least someone has some brains around here if everyone votes to lynch pirana and finds he is scum then you will all know I'm telling the truth... I know I haven't been investigated, especially by pirana so therefore he is lying to get another innocent lynched... I hope everyone understands this.

This post adds credibility to pir claim, IMO. If you were not scum you would not want to risk loosing the det D2 after loosing doc D1.

If everyone votes pir and he shows det we are screwed. None of the townies can communicate and the scum can so as to scheme and decide the best way to control lynches.

 

[Haydn24]

If Hay is mafia, he is a threat period. I have know idea why Pir does what he does, but just because he didn't investigate who you would of, doesn't make his reason any less valid.


IF he is lynched and found mafia, it will not clear you in anyway.

Umm yes it does because everyone is basing their vote on me because they think pir investigated me... If pirana is found to be scum then he couldn't of possibly investigated me...

 

[Haydn24]

This post adds credibility to pir claim, IMO. If you were not scum you would not want to risk loosing the det D2 after loosing doc D1.

If everyone votes pir and he shows det we are screwed. None of the townies can communicate and the scum can so as to scheme and decide the best way to control lynches.

Well that is up to who you believe the most. I know he is lying but that's up to you to decide...right now most of you are making the wrong decision.

 

[Haydn24]

Haydn that last part gives me pause, if you're innocent you would be saying you know he is not the detective. His claim is he is the detective and he is strongly impling that he investigated you and you are scum. If you know you're not scum wouldn't you also know he is not the detective. Why do you merely doubt?

By saying highly doubt I am implying I am sure. I have also stated numerous times I know he isn't the Det.

 

[Lady G]

If pir is lying, how does that make me scum LG?

Well, that is easy. Why would he name a "innocent" if he were claiming detective. The only way he would come out with a name, if mafia would be to name another mafia member, otherwise his claim would be discredited as soon as you were lynched.

 

[Chill]

I cant believe all this. Pir was going to be voted off or at least he thought he was.

I was in no danger of anything.

Cant believe you all are going to buy his story or the crud his buddies are feeding you.

I said I thought the kids were innocent, but one made a false claim and picked another youngster as his know scum. Only way you pick some like that is if he is scum too. Other wise you take some one bigger down with you.

I am pretty sure I have not been investigated.

Now you do the same thing Haydn just did. If you are the detective you know you were not investigated. I was leaning believing you more than Pir but ever since you asked that question about why would two mafia come out I been a whole lot less certain.

 

[the wizard]

Well that is up to who you believe the most. I know he is lying but that's up to you to decide...right now most of you are making the wrong decision.

We see scum make posts like this all the time when their number is up. The "I'm innocent" posts rarely pull any convincing weight.

If we are wrong Pir is next. He knows this so coming out like he did if lying doesn't make sense.

But, going after him first when he might be the det. makes even less sense.

It has been hard enough to find anything worth pulling to root out scum this, is finally something we can work with.