Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[jbradt]

It looks like at 932pm Salt will UD. Salt, at least post somthing... UDing in this format is even worse for the town than normal.

 

[jbradt]

sure who gets the Martin Short role - FF for typecasting?

LOL... but I think we need to load his gun with blanks... just to be on the safe side.

 

[jbradt]

It looks like at 932pm Salt will UD. Salt, at least post somthing... UDing in this format is even worse for the town than normal.

Unless you're scum... then, by all means feel free to UD. :thumbsup:

 

[Chill]

It looks like at 932pm Salt will UD. Salt, at least post somthing... UDing in this format is even worse for the town than normal.

and Salt I'm a patient man but fair warning posting simply the word "something" will probably buy you a bullet, so don't go for the laugh, try to make a helpful post

 

[Fishfriend1]

That is a cop out. Answer the question as given.

As for all of you and the great evidence you found with my quote about shooting the low posters at the time we were talking about the lack of posting and it was a sarcastic statement about it.

Now I know someone will say I don't beleive that, or some other great conspiracy plan about the statement, please know this it is my last word on that matter. I will not respond to any questions about it. it was a sarcastic joke and cranky half idea.

Ask away about my choices for shooting, I call them as I see them.

What evedince? I was meerly noting that it was a bad idea to shoot low posters. Why the big usett?

I missed this...


Why me first?

I agree with Rich that focusing on shooting vets over noobs is simply a cop out way to answer the question.

I honestly think that it would be smarter to hit the vets b4 the noobs, unless they do something really scummy. The vets will know how to use the gun if they get it, the noobs not so much. If you don't like it, oh well.

It's pretty dang disconcerting to me to have to agree with two of my suspects, but I just can't leave you alone any more, FF. You've been pretty evasive the whole game. Care to give any specifics? Or are you gonna disappear with a :bs: excuse again?

Oh no, my comp is lagging. I better go... No im not gonna leave, i'm probably gonna make some head explode trying to reason out my words and reasoning. Good Luck, here comes FF.

Yikes...sorry to see you go Wiz. I need to reread the posts since I left. Be back in a jiffy...

Reread posts... be back soon...

I just received my investigation result and Ice is innocent.

I was totally off on him but at least now I can trust what he says and remove him from my list.

I have some posts to respond to still...got distracted by Lab's PM.

Invest results from pappy.

Which is why I said it still would have made sense for LG and Ice to hypothetically be distancing. Obviously since Ice is innocent it doesn't make sense in that situation but again there's nothing too far when it comes to distancing. They just need to trick one person into believing that...don't put the blinders on Dag...

I read your explanation for this and I still have no idea what you were trying to say...

So now that we know Ice is innocent...what do you think of LG?

Guess again.

You've posted since this one...any revelations?

How eggzactly does a mafia distance from an innocent? If thats what your saying.

Since Ice was part of who I thought was scum, I have to tweak my suspect list a bit...this is who I am most weary of at the moment:

Js
Rich
FF
Kash

There are some people who really need to step it up and post. If it weren't for the fact that we need a somewhat active slinger (and that we cannot afford to just shoot innocents) I'd say we take them out now. Its not doing any good for a townie to hide in the shadows.

No reasons why... and he makes note that he would shoot them if the town didn't need a somewhat active slinger.

It always worries me when people say "I'll post soon" and then never do...

This was almost 24 hours ago. This is your only post. Welcome to my suspect list.

Comments on S4S, about low posting. As if hes gonna read it, never being here an all.

I understand. The two hypotheticals that would make sense to me in the town's views would be...

1) I am mafia and named Ice hoping to gain his and also the town's trust myself. Problem is I could have come up with a better innocent to have "investigated" because Ice as a known innocent is very dangerous to me now. I would have picked another player who is less dangerous but still plausible as a choice.

2) Both Ice and I are scum. Risky but if no one questioned it we could get away with it. Based on what I have said today regarding Ice I don't think it would make very much sense although it could have all been distancing from the start. Again, it is risky, mainly because we would not have known that we would be getting the investigation to make it full circle.

Purely coincidental. I had already PMed Lab with my choice before I even responded in the thread. When Ice typed that up I had just received her response.

I don't expect everyone to believe me 100% but no matter what came up I was going to reveal it. The only way to know for sure is for me to be shot. I obviously don't want that to happen for the sole purpose of clearing me and Ice. Shoot for scum.

Why no "Im innocent and so is Ice" part?

Ok, maybe... or maybe teamwork.

I agree, at the time shooting you would have been risky. Now, well, im more to shooting you.

Uh Jb I didn't list that hypothetical because I was responding to Tay who said that she couldn't fully believe me. Plus its pretty obvious, don't ya think?

And congrats Tay!

Its not obvious, but after about 5 min of reading that and seeing whats b4 it, i think you mean thatt you didn't put it in because you figured it would be obvious. Never assume that, cause not everone will see things the way you do. It could also be covering for a slip.

The scenarios were presented in response to Tay saying she could not trust me. I said I understood but wanted to give why it wouldn't necessarily make sense for me, as mafia, to come out with Ice of all people as my "investigation" result. And I'm not saying it is obvious as reality but it why say I'm innocent when every person in the game plays as if they are innocent? That is the point, so why even mention it? Maybe I should have prefaced the scenarios better by adding "...if I am mafia." but really, would a "3) We are both innocent and I am telling the truth" done anything to convince anyone? No.

I don't care that you doubt me because either way it was going to happen but at the same time I don't see why people are not understanding where I'm coming from here...oh well...

As for who I would shoot next I'm torn between Kash and Rich. At this point I've suspected Rich longer so I would probably shoot him first. If I was correct I would then consider Kash, Js, and LG. If I was incorrect I would hope that the next slinger would still consider those people. I can't say for sure who I would shoot but if I had to choose on the spot I would say Rich then Kash or Js. Those are my three names I suppose.

Well, when reading this i had a FF revalation (there pretty rare). A mafia member would say "Ice is innocent" because that would keep the gun out of his hands. Thats if its true of course.

That confuses me a little. Why would you NOT say the "Im innocnet" one?

... I would have no matter what my role. It makes no snese to leave out that you are innocent (if you are) and if ur not it would be a slip.

You should spell it out next time. That would keep the misunderstandings to a minimum.

You think you could give reasons? Like "I would shoot so-and-so because they (insert incrimating stuff here)". just making a list is easy, backing it is harder.(duh)

Chill steps out if the haberdashery all decked out in black with shiny silver buttons. The sun glints off the gleaming silver making him clearly visible to everone in town.

Show off...

I hope this post helped in some way at least.. probably made some people very confused...

 

[Chill]

Sorry FF was it the "haberdashery" word that confused you? I'm just having a little fun to pass the time and letting the town know I came out of my invisible status so I will show up in the thread when I'm watching. For now I'm doing more watching and wouldn't want people to think I'm not around just cause I might choose not to post.

 

[Fishfriend1]

sure who gets the Martin Short role - FF for typecasting?

...

LOL... but I think we need to load his gun with blanks... just to be on the safe side.

Oh come on! Really?!

 

[Fishfriend1]

Sorry FF was it the "haberdashery" word that confused you? I'm just having a little fun to pass the time and letting the town know I came out of my invisible status so I will show up in the thread when I'm watching. For now I'm doing more watching and wouldn't want people to think I'm not around just cause I might choose not to post.

yes, as a matter of fact, it was the haberdashery that confused me

 

[Chill]

sorry
haberdashery - a store where men's clothes are sold

 

[jpappy789]

This post was kind of a mess...I'm going to try to break it up and respond to the stuff directed at me...

I honestly think that it would be smarter to hit the vets b4 the noobs, unless they do something really scummy. The vets will know how to use the gun if they get it, the noobs not so much. If you don't like it, oh well.

It worries me that you would shoot me over any suspects you may have...do you even have suspects?

How eggzactly does a mafia distance from an innocent? If thats what your saying.

That is not what I was saying. Earlier I said that I thought Ice and LG may be distancing and Dag disagreed with that stating it was too far for distancing. My point was that there isn't anything that cannot be thought of as distancing in a game where you only need to convince one person, the slinger.

In that post I was trying to say that even though Ice and LG weren't actually distancing since Ice is an innocent that in the future we shouldn't discount anything that may be distancing.

No reasons why... and he makes note that he would shoot them if the town didn't need a somewhat active slinger.

FF, I'm pretty had explained why I had all those suspects at some point or another. Most were still from a previous list.

And if you're going to go after me based on my list then maybe you should post one of your own. You've mentioned one suspect as of late in Jspigs and everything else is based off of someone being a vet and that's it...

Comments on S4S, about low posting. As if hes gonna read it, never being here an all.

Are you really trying to tell me that I should ignore Salt because he may not see it? Really? No, seriously, really?

Why no "Im innocent and so is Ice" part?

Ok, maybe... or maybe teamwork.

I agree, at the time shooting you would have been risky. Now, well, im more to shooting you.

Blah, blah, blah...I've already explained this...

Its not obvious, but after about 5 min of reading that and seeing whats b4 it, i think you mean thatt you didn't put it in because you figured it would be obvious. Never assume that, cause not everone will see things the way you do. It could also be covering for a slip.

Yep, that's what I said...

Well, when reading this i had a FF revalation (there pretty rare). A mafia member would say "Ice is innocent" because that would keep the gun out of his hands. Thats if its true of course.

That confuses me a little. Why would you NOT say the "Im innocnet" one?

... I would have no matter what my role. It makes no snese to leave out that you are innocent (if you are) and if ur not it would be a slip.

You should spell it out next time. That would keep the misunderstandings to a minimum.

You think you could give reasons? Like "I would shoot so-and-so because they (insert incrimating stuff here)". just making a list is easy, backing it is harder.(duh)

Sure, except that Ice was like 90% of the town's choice to shoot until Kash came up with her case against Chill. Why would I want to change that? Why not keep the suspicion there?

BECAUSE THAT WASN'T THE POINT OF THE RESPONSE. Please get that in your head. I was responding to the fact that people couldn't trust me and laid out the scenarios for that. It made no sense to me to just say "I'm innocent" since that wasn't going to convince anyone of anything.

And I honestly don't care what you would have done. You are NOT the one in the position to have done anything regarding an investigation so saying that you would have done whatever really means squat.

Also, it makes a whole lot of sense for you to be questioning my list when yours basically boils down to just shooting whoever has played the game a lot

I'm thinking about substituting you in for Js. Maybe I misread him to begin with but then again you're just FF, right?