Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[Jspigs]

Lady G has been viewing a lot but hasn't posted much.

 

[IceH2O]

I think we should focus on making a list of a few people who we think could be mafia and then go from there.

Anyone else think rich might be mafia? I just think there is something about the way he is posting but I just can't put my finger on it. But I could be completely wrong.

From 6 posts you already have a scum vibe from Rich?

I agree up to the new player part. I don't think they would pick a new player because odds of a miss are close to 100% anyway and they would want a good player to take themself out with a miss. Eliminating a new player is less benefical to the scum then eliminating a vet.

It adds a bit of confusion to the mix to choose a new player and there is a really good chance they would take out another newer player or one that always looks scummy and put the gun into another player with a high risk of taking out an innocent.
It doesn't really matter how many vets are left. We only get 5 misses.
FF
Haydn
Salt
Pir
Jspigs

They each shoot each other its game over.

 

[Chill]

G could be signed in and away from her computer - who's viewing is not a particularly useful tell. G has been invisible many times in the past and if she wanted to read unobserved it would be quite easy to go invisible again.

 

[IceH2O]

Jsprigs, a lot of us leave the browser open so even though the name is there it doesn't mean they are reading.

Your list idea is good but its to early, not everyone has even posted. If you said it tomorrow night the idea becomes more valid.

 

[Chill]

Still dicey Ice, Haydn demonstrated good instincts in the ghost chat and any plan that depends on FF going a certain way is doomed from the get go. I'd still go vet and since we know they went vet I'm not seeing a lot of point to this line of thought.

 

[IceH2O]

I'm not saying its a line of thought. I was only explaining why I would possibly choose a new player as slinger.

We already know they didn't so yes its a moot discussion.

 

[jbradt]

It wasn't so much that he said I, it was that he said I would....

If the question was who do you think then..... I would..... would have been ok to use but since I said who do we think.... players should have said, I think they would.....

I know it sounds confusing but I can't explain it any better.

I would hope that as many games as you guys had played that if innocent you'd know it could be a trap and see what becomes of it and only blow it up if evil but I guess we won't know which it is till later in the game.

Again, I see what you're saying, Ice. I'm not trying to blow anything up, but I am trying to point out what I see as odd.

 

[Jspigs]

From 6 posts you already have a scum vibe from Rich?




It adds a bit of confusion to the mix to choose a new player and there is a really good chance they would take out another newer player or one that always looks scummy and put the gun into another player with a high risk of taking out an innocent.
It doesn't really matter how many vets are left. We only get 5 misses.
FF
Haydn
Salt
Pir
Jspigs

They each shoot each other its game over.

Like I said I could be completely wrong about rich. This is also my first game so everything I say is only based on what I have learned from reading the previous mafia game thread and the few hours I have been playing so far today.

 

[the wizard]

wahoo GAME ON!!! first post I rule

Are you serious?!!!? arguing??? none of us have ever argued about anything it seem solid advice though so best of luck with your shots Wiz make them count.

OK, I have been going back and forth from the begining of the game to the last post.

Not all players have posted yet which makes my job tougher. Next question for the town is,

This is Dag's total input to the game so far. Click the box by each quote and observe the time stamp of his posts. Thoughts?

I need to stretch my legs but will be back to recheck the thread for any input from the town.

 

[Jspigs]

OK, I have been going back and forth from the begining of the game to the last post.

Not all players have posted yet which makes my job tougher. Next question for the town is,

This is Dag's total input to the game so far. Click the box by each quote and observe the time stamp of his posts. Thoughts?

I need to stretch my legs but will be back to recheck the thread for any input from the town.

My only thoughts on those posts are they are very far apart in terms of time and they did not contribute much in terms of finding the mafia.