Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[Piranha86]

If he turns up scum he would not have the gun.

I meant doesn't. Corrected below. Or now, above...

 

[the wizard]

alrighty then. even though not everyone has given me an answer about who you would shoot right now, the consensus seems to be Ice and for basically the same reason.

Let me set up a hypothetical (that means pretend) situation. You are the gunslinger. You just shot Ice down in the street, and still have the gun. So Ice then has turned up scum. The deadline approaches, YOU have to take your next shot now.

Who will it be?

Why?

 

[Piranha86]

alrighty then. even though not everyone has given me an answer about who you would shoot right now, the consensus seems to be Ice and for basically the same reason.

Let me set up a hypothetical (that means pretend) situation. You are the gunslinger. You just shot Ice down in the street, and still have the gun. So Ice then has turned up scum. The deadline approaches, YOU have to take your next shot now.

Who will it be?

Why?

Whoever defended Ice, guess we should see who clinged to him.

 

[Chill]

Piranha86 and Salt4Sam have both been prodded.

read that as probed the first time:22_yikes:

 

[Taysius]

Maybe Rich based his on recent posts.

 

[Taysius]

Maybe Rich based his on recent posts.

Oops, forgot to quote Wiz.

 

[jbradt]

alrighty then. even though not everyone has given me an answer about who you would shoot right now, the consensus seems to be Ice and for basically the same reason.

Let me set up a hypothetical (that means pretend) situation. You are the gunslinger. You just shot Ice down in the street, and still have the gun. So Ice then has turned up scum. The deadline approaches, YOU have to take your next shot now.

Who will it be?

Why?

I would go either Rich or Jspigs. I've posted reasons for suspecting each. Out of the two, I would probably choose Rich since if he really is innocent, I'd rather he have the gun than a newb.

 

[Kashta]

If it makes you feel any better, if I have something worth saying, I say it. I don't feel the need to post a bunch of "I agree" posts unless you'd prefer that I do. I'm more of a reader than anything and the only time I'm really worried about looking scummy is when I'm scum.

In this format an "I agree" post can say a lot more than a post with original ideas.

The point being, Taysius, is that posting whether you agree (or disagree) gives us an indication who you agree with and who you say nothing about. You know this game well enough to know that much... we need to look for (good or bad) associations between players where they exist.

Saying nothing in the thread while just nodding at your monitor screen still equates to hiding out.

 

[the wizard]

Great minds think alike... even the sick ones.

That's all we need, someone else that thinks like we do. :crazy:

 

[Piranha86]

I posted my thoughts think what you like. Makes no never mind to me.

Yes Ice having the gun would not be a bad thing. I would rather he have the gun much later on.

I would hesitate to shoot pigs because he is new and he may not have a feel about everyone yet.

Wiz, here's the best one I've found of someone actually defending scummy posts and ice...