Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

"Rich is a grumpy guy this game, and that last bit with kashta where she tried to get him shot was probably last minute distancing." Thats what it was supposed to read. And thats how i see it, if you think its a scummy way to see things, then shoot me, i can handle the gun (i hope)



Well no, but 5 reasons it was wrong seems a little overkill to me.


see how much differnce the "probably" makes FF? No I'm not thinking about shooting you - not yet anyway. Just wanted to clarify what you were really trying to say.
 
This was JB's big post of the day...

This whole case against pappy and tay seems weak at first, but when you think about it and pappys response to it (below) it makes you think, or at least it made me think. Pappys reason for think JB is scummy is weak, based on JB not being commental. Sad. I wasn't ready to call either of them scum at this point, but then i read pappys defensive posts.



That was pappys super defensive post. 5 different reasons it was wrong, wow, someones scared.



Then more defense, against Rich this time.



Well it looked to me like she was going for the win, but this is kashta, so she was probably trying to go for the win AND set up her team for victory. Lets see who she didn't accuse: I don't think pappy was in her lists of scum. Also, as far as i know, neither was JB. Could be that she didn't care, but i find that hard to believe, so i would have to say that both may be on her team. Then i have to say that if pappys on her team then Ice may be as well.

Now, my thoughts so far are that:

Rich is a grumpy guy this game, but also that the last bit with kashta where she tried to get him shot was last minute distancing.

Pappy is too defensive of late. When JB's big post came in, he came up with 5 reasons it was wrong, after saying it was BS. Since when does BS = superdefense?

JB: That big post, when i first saw it i though "Bs with some possible facts" but when Pappy got defesive i went back and re-read it. He makes a valid point about Tay and Pappys reason for calling him scum. Pretty weak on their part.

Tay, you need to get a better reason for calling JB scum then "Well, his opinion about kashta was non-commental". Thats a very weak argument. Funny how pappy agreed with you and you came back and said "Im glad i brought that up".

FF: just a tiny bit upsett that no one think he can control himself...

Ice: If Pappy is evil, he is much more likely to be evil., but pappy could have still told the truth to get someone to think he was inocnet. I bet Ice is thinking "What mafia guy would say im innocent?" Well, Pappy would if it ment getting you to think hes innocent too.

Hay: Pretty quiet, quietest one left... Thinks that LG is evil dispite being against Kashta. I sorta aggree, LG did sorta jump on the bandwagon when Tay brought up Kashta's mistake. Seems like she was distancing, and was told to keep with it.

Dag: Agrees with ive that kashta put at least one teammate on her list, either me of JS. Since i know my role, i would say JS. Also, he thinks thank Kashta was setting up her team. Nothing really scummy from him.

LG: Seems to me that she just rode along the Kash bandwagon when Tay noticed Kashta's slip. Not cool, probably distancing.

JS : Seems to me that JS was slipping early in the game, but now hes gotten much better. Been choached or learnt as he went?

Chill: Good Aim!

All in all, my list consists of

LG:Seems to have been a follower in the whole kash thing. Distancing.
Pappy: Superdefensive, came up with 5 reasons a "BS" post was wrong.
JS:Seems to be coached.
Tay:Granted, tay did bring up the Kashta thing, but tay also brought up how "non-commental" JB was on it. And then ran away with it.
Rich: Kashta may have been distancing with her last couple posts where she included him.

Ok, I'm really sure that FF is scum along with JB and Dag. Defending JB and starting to jab at Pap rand me right along with him. I bolded the things said that I find interesting in his post.

Note the part where he adds that JB and Pap could both be scum with Kash. Was that distancing from JB without actually calling him scum, FF?

In this game it's starting to sound like Pap is "super defensive" and I have an "attitude." Starting to see a bit of a pattern here in the scum styles. (Especially since Kash started jumping in on the attitude thing that JB started.)

FF, if you read my post I had more to say about JB than just his answer to my question about Kash. He seemed to cozy up to me on some things I saw about Rich, then later "forgot" about it and had me and Rich both on his list. You add that into the fact that him and Kash were both using the same reason to paint me scummy.

Lastly, note the bits I've bolded in his "list." Just a few things I found interesting.
 
Not sure what I want to ask today but let's start with this:

I know some of you had commented on this all ready but for those who didn't Do you think Kash was going all out for the win or was she trying to ensure the team win by building some cred for her team?

I also don't have a read on Dag. If memory serves I only played with him twice and both times I read him wrong, so if anyone has any thoughts on Dag so far this game can you post them? Sorry Dag not picking on you just trying to be thorough.

I feel Kash was going for the win, everyone was on me. she was hoping a final push would persuade you to hit me. Thus sealing the win for the mafia.

Yesterday the town was almost unanimous in their suspect list: Kash, Rich, and FF made almost every list. Some scum had to list them so how likely is it that scum would put more than one of their own on a list?

I have not seen enough to get a feel for him. He posts little so I do not know what to think of him at this point.
 
I feel Kash was going for the win, everyone was on me. she was hoping a final push would persuade you to hit me. Thus sealing the win for the mafia.



I have not seen enough to get a feel for him. He posts little so I do not know what to think of him at this point.

You feel kash was going for the win? Not leaving you and your scummies something to build upon to win the game? Hmm...
 
I feel Kash was going for the win, everyone was on me. she was hoping a final push would persuade you to hit me. Thus sealing the win for the mafia.



I have not seen enough to get a feel for him. He posts little so I do not know what to think of him at this point.

How does that second part answer Chills question?

Yesterday the town was almost unanimous in their suspect list: Kash, Rich, and FF made almost every list. Some scum had to list them so how likely is it that scum would put more than one of their own on a list?

Chill was asking how likely do you think scum would put MORE THEN ONE on their list. Not what you thought of them.
 
You know what I think... I think kash purposly put in "vote for rich" before she died because that would make people think that he is innocent. Whereas it could of been a very very sneaky underlying scum tactic. Think about it...
 
The more I read, the more I come to a conclusion to finish out my list.

JB
Dag
FF
Haydn

I absolutely think that Kash was going for the win when she wrote up her post on Rich when Chill asked what she thought about him. The fact that she had to be asked first is a little odd too. She blamed it on LG and me but that was just a cop out.

The fact that now FF and Hay are pushing the same idea about Rich seals the deal for me.
 
You know what I think... I think kash purposly put in "vote for rich" before she died because that would make people think that he is innocent. Whereas it could of been a very very sneaky underlying scum tactic. Think about it...

It is a good theory and entirely possible. The problem is it was not needed she just needed one more innocent killed.
 
AquariaCentral.com