Mafia 94: When Gingers Attack; the play

[Kashta]

Really, Lab? Plant quite playing mafia before David/Wizard's first game. He doesn't know who she is; I figured she wouldn't know who he was either.

Everyone else knows we're together IRL, why shouldn't I let her know? Our names are not secrets.

 

[Chill]

I vote to geneticaly test Pir this could change very quickly I have to read some stuff

 

[Lab_Rat]

I'm going back and forth between voting for Kash or Plant. Actually, I suspect they're both scum so I guess it doesn't matter which goes first if I am correct.

I vote to genetically test Plant.

 

[plantling]

I saw you asked her if she was on the west coast, but no where do I see you refer to Wiz as David, prompting Kash to use his name instead of his screen name.

Don't expect you to believe me, but if you can accept for one moment that we don't communicate outside the thread, Kash is just filling me in on her life. Last I played with Kash was years ago and I remember we had personal discussions on an outside "afterdeath" thread after she was killed as a townie pr and i was hit as a townie.

 

[RazzleFish]

Dawg, do you not think his play this game is typical Pir, no matter what his role? It strikes me as odd that you're the kill vote on him when 2 of my current top suspects were tied with him until your vote.

Lab, I agree that most of Pir's play is consitant with his play from previous games but I have never heard of anyone (not even Pir) not look at the player list. Honestly, the only way I could ever imagine not looking at the list is if he is scum. Townies and townie PRs are looking for gingers so they are going to go into the game expecting certain people to lead the charge and others to lay back. In addition townies are going to know how players act when scum or innocent. The mafia team, however, would not need to worry so much. They simply avoid getting too close to those in the scum den and play it by ear. While I am not saying scum shouldn't look at the player list, it may not be so important as it is for townies. Does that make any sense?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Really, Lab? Plant quite playing mafia before David/Wizard's first game. He doesn't know who she is; I figured she wouldn't know who he was either.

Everyone else knows we're together IRL, why shouldn't I let her know? Our names are not secrets.

Nothing wrong with letting her know. It just really sticks out to me that you used his real name when you've never done that before in a game. Like it was part of a conversation you'd been having somewhere else. I could be totally wrong.

 

[jbradt]

vote count:

Pir (4): Wiz, AAF, Dawg, Chill
Chill (1): Kash
Dawg (1): Plant
AAF (1): Rich
Plant (3): Pappy, 2H, Labby
Kash (2): Zaffy, Pir
2H (1): LG
Labby (1): DD

no vote from Razz... did I miss it?

 

[Lab_Rat]

Lab, I agree that most of Pir's play is consitant with his play from previous games but I have never heard of anyone (not even Pir) not look at the player list. Honestly, the only way I could ever imagine not looking at the list is if he is scum. Townies and townie PRs are looking for gingers so they are going to go into the game expecting certain people to lead the charge and others to lay back. In addition townies are going to know how players act when scum or innocent. The mafia team, however, would not need to worry so much. They simply avoid getting too close to those in the scum den and play it by ear. While I am not saying scum shouldn't look at the player list, it may not be so important as it is for townies. Does that make any sense?

Have you ever heard of an innocent making a false role claim? Pir has done so. After that stunt, nothing from him should surprise me.

 

[plantling]

Nothing wrong with letting her know. It just really sticks out to me that you used his real name when you've never done that before in a game. Like it was part of a conversation you'd been having somewhere else. I could be totally wrong.

you are...

 

[Chill]

I retract my vote vote to geneticaly test Pir

and I vote to genetically test Kash