Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[Dangerdoll]

You had time to make this post but still have yet to kick a bush. I don't understand how people can think that just by posting they will appear to be playing and appear helpful.

actually, I had time to read a biut and made a decision to read further into it and posted that though, then explained my absence this game. I am surprised you missed that. As I stated, I am bringing the dog back today and will post after that after reading more. At 1:30 in the morning, it was hard to think of anything, much less make that post. Or did you miss that too.

 

[allaboutfish]

ok so before i go back and pull posts im going to explain the dun thing, which i thought i already had. anyway, i have no idea why i put pro town. what i meant was not enough to go on bc he hadnt posted much.

 

[allaboutfish]

actually ill have to do the post pulling later on i have to go with my aunt to see an ex coworker of hers.

 

[dirtydawg10]

lots of catching up to do. (sorry for my absence) I will try to answer questions/posts without pulling quotes.

Voting innocents both nights - My vote on Rich was a joke vote and he was not in any danger of getting lynched. My vote for FF on night two - he was at the top of my meager list at the time and I completely expected him to pop in at the last minute and make a vote. If I did move my vote my only other options, besides a singleton vote, would have been for Ice, which i did/do not see him as scum or Kash which would have forced a tie between her and Ice. I felt better about leaving my vote on FF. Obviously I was wrong.

My thoughts on players:

Labby - not sure - possibly innocent
AAF- seems easily flustered but could lean him either way
DD - not sure, not enough posting to determine
Ice - duh!
Zaffy - leaning scum. the exchanges between he and Kash are interesting
Wiz - leaning innocent
Kash - not sure but could easily lean her scum. she is a tricky one.
Dawg - leaning innocent
Dun - not sure. have not played with him before.
JB - leaning innocent
Noods - adorable and thoroughly enjoying the playoffs with the boys and too much beer. ;-) (my liver is grateful there are no games today!)

I will definitely take the time today to go back over everything and see what sticks out the most to me and post my thoughts.

I am interested to know why you are leaning Wiz, JB and myself innocent.

Wow. There seems to be something really OMGUSy going on with the whole Dawg/Kash thing. At first I was thinking this exchange was too much like townie vs. townie. Now it's getting more interesting.

:iagree:

 

[Zaffy]

Kash - Dawg(264) Dawg(438)
AAF - Zaffy(315)
Dun - Dawg(328) JB(386) Ice(402)
Dawg - Kash(426)

No votes from: Lab, AAF, DD, Dun, Wiz, Noods


I think this is accurate.

 

[Lab_Rat]

then you and a couple others might be peeved when i go for JP as well. what can i say?

Yeah, if you're voting based on some grudge from a previous game, without regard to the current game, that's poor strategy.

My thoughts on players:

Labby - not sure - possibly innocent
AAF- seems easily flustered but could lean him either way
DD - not sure, not enough posting to determine
Ice - duh!
Zaffy - leaning scum. the exchanges between he and Kash are interesting
Wiz - leaning innocent
Kash - not sure but could easily lean her scum. she is a tricky one.
Dawg - leaning innocent
Dun - not sure. have not played with him before.
JB - leaning innocent
Noods - adorable and thoroughly enjoying the playoffs with the boys and too much beer. ;-) (my liver is grateful there are no games today!)

I will definitely take the time today to go back over everything and see what sticks out the most to me and post my thoughts.

Thanks for the list Noods. You've only named two as possible scum, and many more as possible innocents. You do realize there are 4 scum roles this game, right?

I never said Kash went from Scum to Innocent. I said my impression of her after she didn't bite was leaning innocent. Remember my original reason for voting Kash was her low posting then she jumped on and started posting like mad after I called her out. Sounded to me like something a scum would do. So I went after her to see if she would bite. I have done this in the past and it does seem to work depending on the player. If you don't buy it I don't know what to tell you.


Nice! So you finally did it. I was wondering if you would jump to vote me when I went after you the first time around...but I see from this that you were waiting to see what others thoughts on me were. Many have said they are leaning me scummy and it seems like you wanted that back-up before you placed your vote. Guess my impression from you yesterday was wrong.

I retract my vote on Dun and vote to send Kash to the looney bin

It seems to me like Dun is at least trying to be helpful as of late. That still remains to be seen though.

So was this your master plan? Badger Kash, then flip your view of her, to have her come out and vote for you for your odd 180 just so you can turn around and go "'Ah Ha!' Kash is scum, she voted for me just like I thought she would."

At this point, I'm torn between voting for Noods or voting for Dawg.

 

[dirtydawg10]

Yeah, if you're voting based on some grudge from a previous game, without regard to the current game, that's poor strategy.

Thanks for the list Noods. You've only named two as possible scum, and many more as possible innocents. You do realize there are 4 scum roles this game, right?


So was this your master plan? Badger Kash, then flip your view of her, to have her come out and vote for you for your odd 180 just so you can turn around and go "'Ah Ha!' Kash is scum, she voted for me just like I thought she would."

At this point, I'm torn between voting for Noods or voting for Dawg.

Unfortunately, no. It didn't go as planned. I thought if Kash was scum that she would vote for me the first time around. I do find it odd that she waited to see what other's thoughts were on me before she voted. At least that's the way I see it. Not to mention that would be a stupid plan if I was scum. I would have just left my vote where it was in the first place.

 

[jpappy789]

I apologize but something came up tonight so I will be pushing back nightfall. I can either move the time completely or just freeze votes and other actions and post when I get back. It would be very late tonight...

 

[jbradt]

Whatever works best for you, Pappy.

 

[Zaffy]

I apologize but something came up tonight so I will be pushing back nightfall. I can either move the time completely or just freeze votes and other actions and post when I get back. It would be very late tonight...

Alright, but she better be cute.