Mafia Game #4 The Play

Ok I finally finished going over Day 3 in detail.

Charlie_Stubbs votes for KOTD
johnlarson votes for KOTD
Hooked Newbie ... MM
judgemax ... MM
Plantling ... MM
MadCrawdad ... MM
johnlarson switches to MM
SHK-ATK ... MM
sovran ... MM
FishLady ... MM
Charlie Stubbs changes to MM
ZSandmann ... MM
Ogre ... MM
DangerDoll ... MM
Coler ... MM
MadCrawdad changes to Coler
sovran votes for MM again (lol)
Jensons ... MM
MadCrawdad changes to MM again
NeonJulie votes for DangerDoll

---NIGHT--

No votes from GuppyGuppyFish (Innocent), Mee-Mee (Mafia), KOTD, BKW, or jpappy
 
KingOfTheDeep said:
im not even going to make a case for myself as you guys are too hellbent on jmax's list that its blinding you.
Click to expand...

I disagree. Right now we're still just testing it, as I don't consider Mee-mee a valid test (she was all wrapped up before Judge named her). You can rest assured that if Judge's list 'misses' on just one, folks will stop following so closely.

Thing is, whether you believe Judge's list or not, it's placed a handful of folks under closer scrutiny, which is probably a good thing for the town. Also, the mayor would have had 2 investigations since Judge's list came to light. I suspect that they might have tested the list themself on at least one candidate (hopefully other than Mee-mee), and if it were a bust would be screaming "Run away, run away...", but can't be sure of that.
 
ZSandmann said:
True but I'd like to get the Don tonight in hopes they haven't used all three investigations.
Click to expand...

I'd be willing to bet that they have used all 3....no real sense in waiting, as IMO watching is unlikely to reveal any townie power roles. There's no real need for townies w/ power roles to behave any differently than any other townie.

I think the Don realized at the onset, w/ 2 investigators (cop & mayor) that there was a good chance of being discovered and whacked. They would have started investigating on Night 1. Just my opinion, though.
 
it would have been smart to try and find the detective and the mayor in the first couple nights...otherwise the mafia is just plain stupid. I will agreee with you mad and say that the don has used up all of his investigations....or at least i hope so!.
 
Coler said:
yeah, I'm about as dangerous as they get in this game...can't stop with the posting and the allegations.

*sigh* lynch me if you want...my vote is for Hooked Newbie...my next preference is jpappy.
Click to expand...

Ok, care to explain why since I haven't been named in ANY of your postings untill it's in bold? This looks pretty odd to me. I wasn't really sure about you until now. I'm holding my vote for a few hoours, but I promise if it comes out for you it's not retalatory.
 
I don't trust what you're saying and think you're spreading confusion...hey in this town you don't need evidence :D
 
judgemax said:
I may be going out on a limb, but I have to say that I think pete is acting strange...I also think, that since the banter between him and julie, is nonsense, and seems, a lil early for the two of them to be squabbling so...maybe its a script?..if we call one one it, the other would then be "clear"..are they actually offering their sacrificial lamb so early?...

(I also want to say, that since every one felt so guilty about lynching julie in the last game, it would make perfect sense to give her a mafia role this game...)
Click to expand...

This is still a mystery to me. How can someone who was so off with the gameplay concept and random selection of roles, with reading people, and wrong have gotten it supposedly so right a matter of hours after this? It almost looks like two people switched out their chairs. And the post after this? Were you baiting us? Were you acting like you didn't get it, but you knew better?

How did you get Nola wrong, Judgemax? If you're so certain about 7-8 other people, how did Nola get pegged by you? Or were you just pushing him out because you didn't like his unsporting attitude?
 
OgreMkV said:
As far as I'm concerned, this makes you VERY mafia. I have run through Hooked Newbie and I think a lot of others have as well and consider him pretty innocent.


Hooked, I liked your post, but a little context would be good. You quoted Zsandmann talking about someone, but who was he talking too?
Click to expand...


Sorry about that. It was in response to SHK (928).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom