Mafia 9: The Bloody Coup

[Hooked Newbie]

Great Caesers Ghost!!! i have posted my suspicions of mee mee and deputy. havent you been reading, or have no need to read all the posts??? i could post a list for you. here it is:
innocent- charlie stubbs
suspects-everyone else
its day one for crying out loud. had you been reading you would have noted i suspected plantling was guilty for trying to stretch a little suspicion of JL into a full blown case, and that joander wasnt a great suspect in my opinion. dont worry, my hairy friend, i will make a case when there is one to be made, for now i watch for suspicious posts. Like yours, for example. Welcome to my suspect list.

Sorry Bud, but the non-vote concerns me. You quite possibly could have had computer issues, but this game isn't really about the giving the benefit of the doubt is it? You suspected 2 people (which I have suspected from the start), but didn't vote and as far as I can tell your list is mee-mee, DC, everyone else. You could have easily voted at some point throughout the day, but didn't. As far as if I'm reading all posts... please go back and review. You seem to be the one popping in for a few minutes here and there.

 

[OgreMkV]

Whatever Mad, I get jumped on from rb for casting a singleton vote and jumped on by you for following a train.

Now take a look at my list on #334 and the votes on #359. My suspects voted for one of the train people.

Fine, from now on, I'm doing my thing and the rest of you can take a flying leap.

I vote to lynch hooked newbie just to keep things kind of even so we have a chance to talk about.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Sorry Bud, but the non-vote concerns me. You quite possibly could have had computer issues, but this game isn't really about the giving the benefit of the doubt is it? You suspected 2 people (which I have suspected from the start), but didn't vote and as far as I can tell your list is mee-mee, DC, everyone else. You could have easily voted at some point throughout the day, but didn't. As far as if I'm reading all posts... please go back and review. You seem to be the one popping in for a few minutes here and there.

I have reviewed all your posts, my discontented friend, and i find alot of finger pointing and word twisting. Considering the position we are in, doesnt seem responsible behavior for a "concerned citizen" to run around blowing smoke at all he sees. Hell, even i have toned it down a shade as i dont want to cause any duststorms the rebels can use as camoflage. Sounds more like the actions of an angry rebel hellbent on anarchy and trying to take down the man. You and all your scummy rebel co-conspirators have barked up the wrong tree this time. I think Braveheart said it best. You can take my life, but you cannot take my Freedom

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Whatever Mad, I get jumped on from rb for casting a singleton vote and jumped on by you for following a train.

Now take a look at my list on #334 and the votes on #359. My suspects voted for one of the train people.

Fine, from now on, I'm doing my thing and the rest of you can take a flying leap. Geez, are all rebels this "rebellious".

I vote to lynch hooked newbie just to keep things kind of even so we have a chance to talk about. Finally, something we can agree on. Except i'm voting for him because i believe he is a rebel, not because i want to keep things even. I think you are also a rebel, but at least i know your not on the same team as him. Thanks for clearing that up.

i vote to lynch HN

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I have reviewed all your posts, my discontented friend, and i find alot of finger pointing and word twisting. Considering the position we are in, doesnt seem responsible behavior for a "concerned citizen" to run around blowing smoke at all he sees. Hell, even i have toned it down a shade as i dont want to cause any duststorms the rebels can use as camoflage. Sounds more like the actions of an angry rebel hellbent on anarchy and trying to take down the man. You and all your scummy rebel co-conspirators have barked up the wrong tree this time. I think Braveheart said it best. You can take my life, but you cannot take my Freedom

I voted consistently for someone that I believe to be a rebel and that makes me look like a rebel. Ummm... ok. Questioning everything one sees is exactly what CCs should be doing. Hopefully people will question you too. At least you voted this time though.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Charlie knows he is different. Has always known. Awkward as a child, he often had difficulty making friends. Even the dog wouldnt play with him. When his parents divorced, neither of them showed up at the custody hearing. Charlie almost died once. He fell asleep with a cigarette in his mouth. His ex-wife lit it.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

I voted consistently for someone that I believe to be a rebel and that makes me look like a rebel. Ummm... ok. Questioning everything one sees is exactly what CCs should be doing. Hopefully people will question you too. At least you voted this time though.

Trying to get as much life out of my no vote as you can are you. By all means. Im the first to admit i let the town down, and i am sorry. i have never missed a vote before, nor will i again. Not voting has certainly painted me in an unflattering light, im even suspicious of sploke because he didnt vote so i can relate to why people would view this as rebel activity.

 

[OgreMkV]

Charlie

this is exactly what mike said before switching to invisible to communicate with his pack.

Accusing

now who's beatin up the newb. i

Accusing

Now why in the world do you need to switch back and forth??? I used to do that. When i was mafia. After our meetings. Hmmmmmmmmm. Gonna have to watch you methinks...

Suspect because of the way charlie played as mafia

well lets hope you find a better suspect, i dont have a rebellious bone in my body. **** the rebels. i am a patriot who loves his country and his president <cue patriotic music>. Ask not what your country can do for you...yada yada yada...Four score and seven year ago...yada yada yada...I have a dream...yada yada yada...the Braveheart speech...yada yada yada...<insert fillibuster here>

Defending himself

i agree we must vote each night, or nothing is solved. we have to fire with both barrels. controlled chaos. mee mee you seem pretty defensive whenever someone raises any suspicion of you...evidence of rebel activity???

then accusing mee-mee of defending herself

once again i think my vote will come down to who is helping the town and who isnt night one. it worked for DP last game so who knows. people that do not post will be the most suspicious, and arent helping one way or another IMHO. if your not posting its because you have something to hide, or maybe they are having trouble hooking up with their teams.

Curious, I realize there were computer problems, but you still didn't vote so we have none of that info on you.

i think its reasonable to believe a newb is not the president. i say this because ice mentioned how, although roles are random, sometimes a mod will tweak things for the good of BOTH teams. i believe if emma for example was president, ice might change this.

i was also suspicious of this. when i was mafia i switched to invisible and back. once you have switched to invisible, there is no need to switch back, unless your trying not to look suspicious

Again with the invisible non-invisible thing. Let it go.

i disagree. a rebel might want to use mutiquote when trying to cast doubt upon the innocent.

Sovran you have been accused of rebel activity. How do you plea???

Why is this necessary?

Are you trying to blow smoke my way??? I'm trying to be a little more reserved with the new format. I do however, have some thoughts:
Joander- is on alot of lists because of his early vote, yet this is a sound tactic IMHO. As Ice said last game, votes=responses=answers. I have reviewed Jo's posts and nothing is really jumping out at me.
Mee Mee- her defensiveness always concerns me, and if i had to vote now she would be the lucky winner. Of note: She was also defensive last game and was innocent. However, as Mad pointed out,
Emma- still no post??? what happened here?? did she forget she's playing??? I am almost sure Ice would not let her be president (random or not), although she may very well be rebel. It irks me when players commit to playing.

A little more reserved? Again, problems with mee-mee being defensive, but look at the first two lines of this post.

my isnt this interesting. Your lynching someone because they called us townies instead of citizens??? Hmmmmmmmm seems pretty weak to me, and the timing is HIGHLY suspect. Lets hope you never get jury duty. Danger starts a Jo train and Deputy is quick to get onboard. Note: I called people townies last game. Apparently, they were supposed to be called villagers.

still defensive and still offering no useful info

my list now as it stands:
mee mee- overall defensiveness
deputy- quick to hop on trains, but doesnt seem to be trying to find any evidence
i dont have a solid third now, but emma lack of posting yet concerns me
Note: when i was mafia i asked for people lists all the time, as i wanted to know if i was on their list. Are you asking because you wanna see if your on any lists yet RB?

Pot, kettle

Cory everytime a wolf was lynched you posted "i had a gut feeling since the beginning about them". Your "gut feeling" about Mike came last game when there were four players left, and was a controversial after death post. There are now twenty players. You wants us to lynch Ogre because of a gut feeling??? I have a gut feeling that following you would end in disaster. If you wants us to follow you post "EVIDENCE" not "GUT FEELINGS". Much obliged.

Agreed, but you think I'm a rebel now?

heres something else i found strange. Plantling took the whole "vote for noone" scenario by JL and turned it into a case against him. Are you trying to find rebels or eliminate citizens Plantling??? You seem to be trying to turn what i thought to be only slightly suspicious and stretch it into a case.

I'm not sure what to make of this post-night. A case of rebels seperating or a case of lucky picking names?

sorry guys i had some computer trouble, i had to take my comp to the place i bought it and have windows re-installed. i could not even start in safe mode. mee mee is still my top suspect, but im not going to hop on that train just yet, i still have to run down some leads. now who was it that started that jo train????

BTW: You KNOW who started the Joander train. You posted it a few posts up.

i apologize for my non vote, i had some computer issues, and would have voted mee mee. i realize this appears to be rebel activity, but i assure you i would never purposely miss a vote.

I think everyone, at this point, knows how hard you are pushing mee-mee

as you can see, before the vote i said i think joander isnt looking that guilty, but plantling is.

I think you said JohnLarson. Asking who started the joander train isn't saying he's innocent.

i could not have been visible online, because i was not online. i was getting windows re-installed due to a power interruption that killed it. i am sorry i didnt vote sooner, i thought i had more time and wanted to wait to see what developed.

Ah my beloved Dangerdoll. We really need to work out our trust issues if this relationship is going to work. I admit, i didnt trust you most of last game and here we go again. So tell me again why its a good idea to lynch Jo? Oh yeah, he called us townies. Burn the witch!!! Hmmmmmmm i'm gonna keep a close eye on you Double Dee, maybe both:naughty:

Ah, he remembers who started the Joander train.

Great Caesers Ghost!!! i have posted my suspicions of mee mee and deputy. havent you been reading, or have no need to read all the posts??? i could post a list for you. here it is:
innocent- charlie stubbs
suspects-everyone else
its day one for crying out loud. had you been reading you would have noted i suspected plantling was guilty for trying to stretch a little suspicion of JL into a full blown case, and that joander wasnt a great suspect in my opinion. dont worry, my hairy friend, i will make a case when there is one to be made, for now i watch for suspicious posts. Like yours, for example. Welcome to my suspect list.

Your suspisions for Deputy consist of 'low useful posts'

Hmmmmmm seems like you discovered some evidence of rebel activity here Madcrawdad.

Quick to jump on me.

I have reviewed all your posts, my discontented friend, and i find alot of finger pointing and word twisting. Considering the position we are in, doesnt seem responsible behavior for a "concerned citizen" to run around blowing smoke at all he sees. Hell, even i have toned it down a shade as i dont want to cause any duststorms the rebels can use as camoflage. Sounds more like the actions of an angry rebel hellbent on anarchy and trying to take down the man. You and all your scummy rebel co-conspirators have barked up the wrong tree this time. I think Braveheart said it best. You can take my life, but you cannot take my Freedom

Now he 'reviews all the posts' by hooked and declares him suspect number 1.

i vote to lynch HN

And votes.


My thoughts: He defends himself, then accuses those who defend themselves. He has a superhigh suspect, but then picks out two others, then votes for someone completely new.

I'm real curious what will today bring.

Is some of this a case of separation from fellow rebels? Hmmm... plantling was killed by the rebels. Are you FBI, you mafia spy-master?

So are DD and deputy your fellow FBI?

In conclusion: Not a whole lot to charlie. Absent for much of day one, but kind of flopping around so far on day two.

I vote to lynch charlie_stubbs.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I am just trying to follow any inconsistencies I see in postings, DD. I am detailed oriented and relentless, by nature. Folks either own up or run. I don't but Deputy's excuse of being drunk. I don't buy the excuses of the non voters, who were visible on line, but didn't vote, or who were in chat but to busy to vote....guess I'm anal and a realist....

I don't think any of my posts were inconsistent, rb.... maybe of a different opinion than others, but inconsistent, no.

IMHO, don't lose the realist and anal part of you for you, it works

Ah my beloved Dangerdoll. We really need to work out our trust issues if this relationship is going to work. I admit, i didnt trust you most of last game and here we go again. So tell me again why its a good idea to lynch Jo? Oh yeah, he called us townies. Burn the witch!!! Hmmmmmmm i'm gonna keep a close eye on you Double Dee, maybe both:naughty:

Yes, chaz... I don't know what it is. What draws us so close pushes us so far. I don't know what it is. I will be watching you dea but not sure if it's because I like to or if it's because you draw major suspicions.

I still would like to know why mee-mee was on people's list yesterday and why she hasn't posted much since. Did she say she was going somewhere or is she "having pc problems" too.....

and hn, yep, the more you guys point out, the more he looks guilty to me.

there you have it. My list of suspicions is mee-mee but watching her only due to the consensus last time.
HN for the points already presented and they are quite telling.
RB for selecting folks and seemingly driving hard into them for reasons of being just different in my eyes
Ogre for different posting patterns.

 

[charlie_stubbs]

Charlie



Accusing



Accusing



Suspect because of the way charlie played as mafia



Defending himself



then accusing mee-mee of defending herself



Curious, I realize there were computer problems, but you still didn't vote so we have none of that info on you.





Again with the invisible non-invisible thing. Let it go.





Why is this necessary?



A little more reserved? Again, problems with mee-mee being defensive, but look at the first two lines of this post.



still defensive and still offering no useful info



Pot, kettle



Agreed, but you think I'm a rebel now?



I'm not sure what to make of this post-night. A case of rebels seperating or a case of lucky picking names?



BTW: You KNOW who started the Joander train. You posted it a few posts up.



I think everyone, at this point, knows how hard you are pushing mee-mee



I think you said JohnLarson. Asking who started the joander train isn't saying he's innocent.





Ah, he remembers who started the Joander train.



Your suspisions for Deputy consist of 'low useful posts'



Quick to jump on me.



Now he 'reviews all the posts' by hooked and declares him suspect number 1.



And votes.


My thoughts: He defends himself, then accuses those who defend themselves. He has a superhigh suspect, but then picks out two others, then votes for someone completely new.

I'm real curious what will today bring.

Is some of this a case of separation from fellow rebels? Hmmm... plantling was killed by the rebels. Are you FBI, you mafia spy-master?

So are DD and deputy your fellow FBI?

In conclusion: Not a whole lot to charlie. Absent for much of day one, but kind of flopping around so far on day two.

I vote to lynch charlie_stubbs.

my isnt this a helpful post. i mention i think your a rebel and you invest a great deal of effort making me look like one instead. while i still believe mee mee is a great suspect, in this game things can change with just one post. perhaps this is pre-emptive strke. whatever the case, im not going to use the tired old "investigate me" line, because an investigation on me wont help the town. i am not the president or bodygaurd. i am a concerned citizen and nothing more.