THE PLAY: Mafia #16 'Till death do we part...

[Lady G]

On the left, the list of players judge posted in the sign up thread plus the addition of the last two to join. Notice the list is in sequence with when they posted in the thread.

Then the list that is posted in this "play" thread, which appears to be to have been started after the PMs went out.

Could it hold any info in regards to the decision on who got what rolls since she made such remarks regarding checking and double checking that all PMs went out? Sounds as if she had to have a list she was working from...in some order of priorities...?

charlie charlie
blue blue
rb rb
lady lady
joan joan
hook hook
ice ice
plant DD
DD clown
clown liz
liz kuhli
kuhli jpap
jpap aka
jl66 niko
aka sploke
niko deputy
deputy jl66
sploke plant

the thing I notice on this Rb is Plant went to the bottom and everyone else moved up one once you get to the "change"

 

[Lady G]

the thing I notice on this Rb is Plant went to the bottom and everyone else moved up one once you get to the "change"

Oops I left off except for JL and Sploke

 

[Hooked Newbie]

I have to get this out there, I do think Blue is posting more like her first game. No one thought anything of it when I brought it up in that game, really there is no one thing that stands out to post on, but it is more a "feel" of her post...if that makes sense to anyone.

I know we don't want to jump all over the newbs but I'm sorry guy's Kuhli is not sitting right with me, Liz had me going back and forth on my thoughts of her...first I thought oh newb mistakes, then I thought for sure mafia, then I thought maybe she figured the game out well and was trying, in her own kinda way to help, I'm not sure I think she is mafia and of them I would pick Kuhli over Liz at this point. Atnixon, really I have no feeling on him one way or the other and wouldn't of mentioned him but figured since I was talking about the newbs I needed to include my thought on him also. Really there is no reason they wouldn't be "randomly" picked.

Jo and Ice have me concerned big time, and really I don't think they are both mafia..but I can't decide which I feel is.

Right now I would have to say my main concerns are:

Chaz
Ice
Jo
Blue
Kuhli

Anyones thoughts on them? I would also like to point out that I to like the picking between 2-3 players and discussing them. I was gone at that point last game and when you guy's did that I thought it was great.

I like this list, but at this point mine would be...

Blue
Chas
Rb
Ice
Jo

My vote will probably be changing to Blue or Charlie.

 

[plantling]

the thing I notice on this Rb is Plant went to the bottom and everyone else moved up one once you get to the "change"

LOL, I was going to comment on this list as well. When I first noticed the change in the lists, I thought I was the only one, too. I thought Jmax forgot about me when retyping the list, then added me on at the end. Then I noticed JL wasn't in order either. That's why I thought him to be innocent this game was because we were left out.

 

[Rbishop]

Love the details hooked..don't try to shift the discussion to a childish blame of my red name.....

up until about post 659 from day 2 start..posts...

hook 24
rb 20
jo 19
ice 18
jpap 17
lady 14
blue 13
clown 7
niko 5
cs 4
kuhli 3
plant 3
dc 1
brains 1


Yep, I am a low poster.....

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Love the details hooked..don't try to shift the discussion to a childish blame of my red name.....

up until about post 659 from day 2 start..posts...

hook 24
rb 20
jo 19
ice 18
jpap 17
lady 14
blue 13
clown 7
niko 5
cs 4
kuhli 3
plant 3
dc 1
brains 1


Yep, I am a low poster.....

Thanks for calling me childish. Now look at the whole game post numbers old wise one.

 

[Rbishop]

and Liz with just 2

 

[Lady G]

This is not a case on Blue, just making my point that Rb should add her to his list of ppl who post a vote with "I agree" and no real thoughts of their own.

I have to agree with you LG.

I vote to lynch Liz (subj to chnage)

I agree fully with Charlie.

I vote to lynch Jo. (subj to change at any time)

 

[Rbishop]

Thanks for calling me childish. Now look at the whole game post numbers old wise one.

Since the game dynamics didn't really start until the marriages, with the actual level of mafia, it doesn't matter, IMO.

But feel free to post them if it proves anything....

 

[Lady G]

I like this list, but at this point mine would be...

Blue
Chas
Rb
Ice
Jo

My vote will probably be changing to Blue or Charlie.

Speaking of Charlie, has he posted since his vote? Now I have to go see.