I kind of assumed that with Kash being DET she would invest Wiz first. Be easier on her to know what his role was. If innocent then just don't point a finger. If evil build some type of case.
Mafia #64 ? Cabin Fever - The Play
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
I kind of assumed that with Kash being DET she would invest Wiz first. Be easier on her to know what his role was. If innocent then just don't point a finger. If evil build some type of case.
To JL, but he has been quiet all game, cept for a few posts here and there. Although he has been more active since night 1...
Wiz
Rich
Ice
Razz
JL
Dawg
FF
DD
Dag
4 of which are evil. An innocent lynch and an unprotected hit they win.
Rich
Ice
Razz
JL
Dawg
FF
DD
Dag
4 of which are evil. An innocent lynch and an unprotected hit they win.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Some quotes from Dagamoth (normally I hate long posts - sorry)
Agrees with Kash enough to retract vote off of FF. Also complements the madman for "using too much strategy when they picked out the first kill. For that reason I think that we need to focus our attention on someone who has a more intelligible posting style with direct and clearly made points."
Does not like the fact that there was no analysis on Ice (there were other players there was not a detailed analysis on, but only Ice was pointed out).
The old "bad feeling" vote. The rest of the reason is almost like "she is posting different".
FALSE
I think he knew.
Very helpful!
Dagamoth has moved up my suspect list.
Agrees with Kash enough to retract vote off of FF. Also complements the madman for "using too much strategy when they picked out the first kill. For that reason I think that we need to focus our attention on someone who has a more intelligible posting style with direct and clearly made points."
Does not like the fact that there was no analysis on Ice (there were other players there was not a detailed analysis on, but only Ice was pointed out).
The old "bad feeling" vote. The rest of the reason is almost like "she is posting different".
FALSE
I think he knew.
Very helpful!
Dagamoth has moved up my suspect list.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
He is building his case against me JL. I think that is what he means any way.
Dag is LRs brother that is correct. He made a point of not voting her. Maybe it was not the sibling thing maybe he did not want to be on an innocent.
Dangerdoll
Global Moderator
the problem I have with this is like I said earlier in the game, Wiz and Kash are a couple... perhaps with Kash being the detective, she didn't feel she needed to investigate Wiz first.... maybe she felt she could see the signs in their every day real life... I dont know.... just a different view of it... another thought, with Wiz voting Annie so close to nightfall, he may have used the hope that we would believe Kash would investigate him first and since he voted to save her, we would think of him as in the clear. Nice strategy.
good points
with this thought in mind, brings me back to Kash and Wiz. It's sort of the same situation that JL noted on below
I think Dag and Wiz are my top suspects at this point. I would be comfortable voting either one of them.
For the record, Ice has moved down my suspect list because of the many times he's pointed out that he was not in fact left off Kash's list, though Dag (maybe someone else too) seemed to insist she left him off the list.... and did not mention the others that were included in the same paragraph as Ice, conveniently editing off that part in Kash's list. Does it clear him, of course not. That would be foolish of me, he's just not my top anymore.
wow tonight sucks again :cry: to answer some questions that were raised:
I said kashta didn't psycho analyze Ice like she did for the other people as in she didn't write out his name and then give a few sentences on her thoughts about him like she did for almost everyone else. The reason I picked up on Ice not being there was that he had been taking some heat in the posts around when i made that comment and he was a person in particular that I was looking for comments on.
The big issue is tonight is the night that matters, if we don't get right and knock off an evil they will win. I assume that the next night fall is sunday night (at least i hope so because i'll be best-manning a wedding all day tomorrow) I will be rereading the majority of the game up till that point to try and pick up on anything that i might have missed but after seeing that kashta really was an innocent I am very inclined to go with her suspicions on Ice but will have to wait and see if anything else pops out at me while i reread.
I said kashta didn't psycho analyze Ice like she did for the other people as in she didn't write out his name and then give a few sentences on her thoughts about him like she did for almost everyone else. The reason I picked up on Ice not being there was that he had been taking some heat in the posts around when i made that comment and he was a person in particular that I was looking for comments on.
The big issue is tonight is the night that matters, if we don't get right and knock off an evil they will win. I assume that the next night fall is sunday night (at least i hope so because i'll be best-manning a wedding all day tomorrow) I will be rereading the majority of the game up till that point to try and pick up on anything that i might have missed but after seeing that kashta really was an innocent I am very inclined to go with her suspicions on Ice but will have to wait and see if anything else pops out at me while i reread.
****! This has been a very tough game. We lost 3 innocents night one, and 3 townie pr's tonight. That only leaves the dr. I sure hope they know who to protect.
It seems to me, if kashta was still inclined to believe Ice was evil she would have voted for Ice, especially when Annie was already set to be banished ahead of her.
Kashta asked before voting what the count was.
So who else did she suspect?
It seems to me, if kashta was still inclined to believe Ice was evil she would have voted for Ice, especially when Annie was already set to be banished ahead of her.
Kashta asked before voting what the count was.
So who else did she suspect?
