Mafia #13 - The Witches of ACville- the play

[IceH2O]

For now, I guess I will put my vote in for BrkD. I see he hasn't been here since 2ish am this morning so I am curious to see how he reacts to the votes. I would like him to convince me that I am incorrect in my thoughts. I am open to accepting that he is a townie if I feel by his explanations, that he is.

As far as DC, I am also concerned to see what his defense would be as he is who I will probably change my vote to due to his unhelpful posts and the drunk one. The problem is, I just don't think it's a lot to go on in calling him witchy but I am watching him.

Ice, I was more so leaning Ice witchy yesterday but these posts today seem to change my mind. I don't know if it is him being helpful or him trying to lead the town away. He is a leader and knows how to direct the group. For that, I am afraid and is what makes me nervous about him.

Ice, I do have a question I would like you to clarify for me. Why is it if B is found witchy, that plant is cleared and probably innocent?

For now, I vote to burn BrkD at the stake

If Plantling was a witch having Bk vote for her put it very close to getting her lynched. If LG had switched in time plantling would be gone. I don't think they'd chance it on the 1st night if ever.

 

[Dangerdoll]

if LG would have moved her vote to Plant, the votes would hve been tied for Judge and Plant. I find it hard to believe that they would think LG would move her vote so close to the end of the night or any other innocent for that matter.

 

[IceH2O]

if LG would have moved her vote to Plant, the votes would hve been tied for Judge and Plant. I find it hard to believe that they would think LG would move her vote so close to the end of the night or any other innocent for that matter.

It was 5-4 JM over Plantling. If LG switched it would have been 5-4 Plantling over JM.

There have been many last minute changes throughout these games.

LG even posted that she was considering it.

Ice you are not helping me...are you saying you do or you don't think she is a witch? Now you are making me question myself, she was on DD pretty hard at one point though, but her not posting at all is just buggin the crap outta me. Like I said though, switching at this point does nothing but put one more vote to plant it wont change the outcome..so I should just stay where I'm at. AHHHH I feel the:screwy: ness coming on!!!!

A couple of posts later it will change the outcome. So if she felt strongly enough she could have.

 

[Dangerdoll]

:crazy: guess that's why I suck at math huh...

 

[ZSandmann]

Ice: I'm willing to accept you doubt of me for voting JM, I didn't have any better suspects and I had to vote for someone. I just haven't seen anything to suspect me of plantling other than your analysis of Rb's spells and how she is going after you. A lot of times when two players go at it like that you can think that one must be an Evil but after my experiences with Swayde and BKW (remember the mousepad) I try to no longer give myself tunnel vision like that.

Right now I believe jpappy, DD, Charlie, and Ice are Innocents. On the opposite end of the spectrum I have DC, sploke, BrkD, leaning Witch. The rest of the players aren't so clear cut. No scaled list worth showing right now, assume anyone I didn't name is a 5. I would like to say that I will follow along with everyone on Brk right now but we still have over 24 hours and it would be good to have someone else down to increase conversation.

I vote to burn at the stake DeputyChief

On the counts of drunken posting, following, and general anti-town vibes. Subject to change upon further review, all patent's pending, not valid outside the contiguous United States.

 

[ZSandmann]

I'm still interested in seeing who the Warlock has used a spell on.

 

[IceH2O]

I have DC listed as one of my top contenders. I think all the reasons have already been stated.

There seems to me to be a connection between Ice and DC. I still like Ice as a witch, so that pushes DC to witchiness as well.

As to the fourth and/or possible fifth witches. I have no idea at this point.

I vote to burn brk

Can you explain the connection of me and DC? I think it would help the town see what you see. I have no clue myself and am interested.

Ice: I'm willing to accept you doubt of me for voting JM, I didn't have any better suspects and I had to vote for someone. I just haven't seen anything to suspect me of plantling other than your analysis of Rb's spells and how she is going after you. A lot of times when two players go at it like that you can think that one must be an Evil but after my experiences with Swayde and BKW (remember the mousepad) I try to no longer give myself tunnel vision like that.

Right now I believe jpappy, DD, Charlie, and Ice are Innocents. On the opposite end of the spectrum I have DC, sploke, BrkD, leaning Witch. The rest of the players aren't so clear cut. No scaled list worth showing right now, assume anyone I didn't name is a 5. I would like to say that I will follow along with everyone on Brk right now but we still have over 24 hours and it would be good to have someone else down to increase conversation.

I vote to burn at the stake DeputyChief

On the counts of drunken posting, following, and general anti-town vibes. Subject to change upon further review, all patent's pending, not valid outside the contiguous United States.

I can accept that, I just wonder more about why you kept asking for the information when she did in fact post 2 lists.Its like you dismissed them as never being made.

 

[ZSandmann]

No I saw her lists but she never provided what she said "all in due time" about. At least not in so many words. If you look at my comments, I didn't think she was continuing to hide things, it was more the fact that she never addressed what she thought she had early on. I mean after reading her after death post its clear she was just busy, but when Night was approaching she didn't offer any sort of feedback. That in my experiences is not like her at all, usually if someone even brings up her name they get scathing replies back almost instantly.

 

[ZSandmann]

Hey Brk see ya down there. I'm very interested in how you feel about the votes on you and who you think are the Witches.

Hi JL. Hi cooldude.

 

[ZSandmann]

i was only speaking the truth when i posted i was in my room. it was not a metaphor for anything else

and yes i had no reason to vote for plantling except for me to stay in the game. i withdrew my vote against charlie because i just didnt think he was suspicious anymore.

as of now i dont even know where to start and who to suspect. i will read on and see what happens.

This is Brks last post, right around 20 hours ago.

I'm ok with your reasoning for taking your vote off Charlie, but your reasoning for voting plant is lame. When you removed your vote, Charlie had no chance of being burned, there were two leaders: plant and JM. You chose to vote for the lesser of the two, in effect adding nothing. Your vote was just as good on Charlie.