DD, and others I snipped the quote not because I suspect her, but I'm not following the quotes given. DD did you mean to post all of these because it looks like some didn't have replies or questions from you and I'm a bit confused trying to follow some of what you're saying.
DD, you have valuable information when you're innocent and I dont want me or anyone else to miss it.
Looks like your minds are set. I just hope they don't hit JM tonight...at least some good will come of this.
Either:
1. You're an innocent townie and enjoying BEEPing withour minds
2. You're the detective and you've now given mafia
two innocents to hit
3. You're mafia and protecting a team member.
Any way I look at it I will not change my vote on you because I think any of the above is reason to vote you out.
seems some quotes popped into my post....
Quote:
I continue to hear more about secrets being held in people coming to their decisions and frankly, am finding it extremely Mafia-ish for folks to keep saying "I have this secret" or "I noticed this and will say what I suspected later".... either you are bluffing or you are holding things from us. If you are trying to help us, why keep things to yourself. And for the excuse already used in this game, the excuse that "so I can use it for other game", I think by Clownie, is a load of crap.... sorry clownie... if you can use it, we could. Bottom line is, you are withholding information that could be beneficial to finding the mafia.
DD, not sure if you saw my answer regarding this type of thing yesterday or not but at one time I thought JM might have gave a hint that she was the detective when she posted the following. She has confirmed however that she sent to clue and I have no problem showing why I thought it because of that. I'd hope you would understand why I would not have made it obvious if she had been hinting at it. The thread where I explained this was
1255
It's only anti-townie cause you're a paranoid freak. Stop smoking. :headshake2:
Um, if anyone is smoking crack or weed right now ...it sure isn't the name bkw that comes to mind.
Why do you have to survive for us to know this, why include Z?? Are you trying to say you and Z are part of a new mafia group...is that the supposed reason for you loosing your Detective role???:headshake2:
Beth this is EXACTLY what I have been thinking this entire time I am trying to get through these posts. I was thinking how suspicions were growing on Grins, then the whole Mal thing started (granted she caused much of it), then the same today. The only other thing that keeps going through my mind is Jmax is right in the middle of it both times too, one of the two OR both have to be mafia IMO.
Well this is going to defend JM as well but fair is fair...Mal's words were her own last night. I didn't put them into her mouth and neither did JM. It is impossible for innocents other than the Doc/Det to communicate and we now know who the doctor was. So that is out since we now know Mal was just a confused innocent. I'll give her a little slack for that since we are all confused. But LC? I'm not giving him the same kind of slack. And if you're going to insist the scenerios are the same then once again please explain how I could be responsible for what he types? Shoot, last I checked the boy had gone off his rocker and went from voting for Blue to Me. By the time I hit send he'll probably have voted for Joander.
Well since you're all going to take my words out of context and put meaning in them that isn't there, here's something more for you paranoid freaks:
I retract my vote for Blue and vote to lynch Grins
Guess what, this makes me want you out even more. And it isn't because of the vote on me but how obviously you're playing mind games with us
all. Put down your crack pipe and review for a moment LC:
1. first you're the detective
2. then you were the first dective but Bob replaced you and you can now reveal who your first investigation was without putting the detective role in jeopardy
3. then you were only saying the 2nd to confuse us because you are still the detective and you didn't want to put the role in jeopardy for the town
4. then you weren't the first detective but rather the second one
5. and then you say the first detective will probably UD tonight...um lets see so no surprise who you are inferring will be the no show tonight so you've also outed them?
not only is that whole flip flopping thing ridiculous for anyone to believe in my mind but then there is this:
1. you see that people start thinking that whomever you
don't mention in your "secret knowledge as detective" is thought to be your boss (my name was sure tossed around and I'm still shaking my head over it)
2. so then you decide to have more fun messing with everyone's head to make them start to shift off of me and go to JM or shoot anyone.
What is next LC? Are you going to suggest that Mal is the don?
Z, I looked back and it was game 14...he WAS in it. I stated that in one of my posts to Mad. I just didn't remember him ever playing in a game with me before, and before I took it any farther with that thought I had to go back and look...it was a Old/New school mafia game.
Thanks for clearing that up.
Alright, based on that post, I'm assuming that you're claiming to be the former detective...
You're assuming too much based on his last post. I know you're busy but if you catch up on his posts you'll see he has thrown one claim after another. And frankly Mad you're better than that as an innocent.
Sorry I have to go with my first choice: I promise I won't change again.
I retract my vote on LC
I vote to Lynch Grins
if she goes and is innocent I will accept full ownership
If you sincerely think I look more mafia than LC does right now, go right ahead.
unfortunately, the inconsistencies do make it difficult to sort through.
Also, to get it out there I vote to lynch Grins
Could change. I may talk myself into voting for Ice instead...
At this point, my top pics for mafia would be:
Ice
Grins
Clown
maybe DD? for the 2nd day in a row, she's kind of swooped in and voted for the candidate of the moment
I've already given reasons for Ice and Grins, Clown will follow in a later post.
Do the town a favor and show us who the other 3 mafia might be. There are six right now with 2 teams of 3. Surely more than 3 people look suspicious to you, especially if you're willing to not include LC.
with this tied at 6-6, and three left to vote, i am willing to move my vote, if someone else votes one of them, ..To keep it tied, either or, whom ever the non voters vote for.
lol, you're so generous Julz.
There's going to be an innocent UD tonight, that, as well, I can pretty much guarantee.
What? How on earth could you guarantee this sort of thing?
It's about time for Grins to play the "you're not the Detective, I'm the Detective" card isn't it?
Bueller?
Not going to happen.
Just because I enjoy a full inbox......
I would like to make it perfectly clear, to all players, I have not posted a single clue to anybodies identity or role in this game. None, Nada, Zero, Zilch.
I made some posts I thought were funny. That's it. Sorry if you were expecing somethng secret, but if you think you have found something, it has been fabricated by the poster.
UGH, can we block Bob from posting in the thread?
Well there might not be a UD tonight afterall...I'll keep ya'll posted.
Let me guess LC, you know this because you're now Bala and the player emailed you.
