Mafia #51 - Mafia Citizens - The Play

Eh...where is this bs about Ice being anything but town coming from ? I note the reference to him being rich and I don't think this is meaningless (he was called a rich citizen right)...but town...surely to gawd.
 
Madcrawdad said:
It sure looks like you were saying it, Z. You say 'when PRESUMABLY two townies already lie dead.' The use of the word 'presumably' implies uncertainty, right? You presume it was two townies, but you're not sure. Then you go on to say that you still 'weren't sold on what happened to Ice and the mist', which would mean that Ice was the townie in question.

If Ice was maybe not a townie, but not a rebel, what else could he have been?
Click to expand...

Folks can be brought back to life by the Mist and can PRESUMABLY have their roles reversed by the Mist. Plus we added in Mostly. Ice may not be dead dead yet, who knows. I asked if I was reading too much into it and you said yes, now I wonder if you aren't reading too much into what I said about the Mist.
 
I gotta go and not sure if I'm back later...between Kashta and TRS I am sorta reading TRS at this time as more bad player than 'bad' (i.e. rebel player). I wouldn't mind a run on another candidate just to see some vote shaking but that's just me and I probably won't be around to contribute to it, so I'm leaving my vote where it is on Kashta.
 
And DD why you disappear again !!! The quiet people are very much irritating me I don't know if they are just quietly hiding in the white noise.
 
Now that the mist has cleared, the town wonders what has happened?

Rbishop is no longer with us. He was a citizen.
 
ZSandmann said:
Folks can be brought back to life by the Mist and can PRESUMABLY have their roles reversed by the Mist. Plus we added in Mostly. Ice may not be dead dead yet, who knows. I asked if I was reading too much into it and you said yes, now I wonder if you aren't reading too much into what I said about the Mist.
Click to expand...

You're a well-spoken guy, Z. If that's what you meant (that Ice might not be dead, yet) wouldn't you have said 'when two townies lie PRESUMABLY dead'? The way you worded it originally, you're clearly presuming that it's two townies who are dead. Makes a big difference in meaning, based on where you place the word 'presumably'.

ZSandmann said:
I agree with you then on the principal but just not the certainty of the outcome. I kind of feel we need to lynch Kash after all this just to sort out things, but that isn't a good enough reason. You build a good case though. I certainly am expressing hesitation in running strongly at a Day 1 suspect when presumably two townies already lie dead (still not sold on what happened with Ice and the Mist). So if that makes me a suspect I will have to be a suspect.
Click to expand...
 
The ... was in regards to Rb tossing himself to Bala.

Mad, all I can tell ya is that was what I meant, if my words imply something else then you have my clarifications and must take me at my word or choose to believe I am being deceitful.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom