Mafia #57: The Great Mafia War- The Game
- Thread starter jpappy789
- Start date
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
Well, since a train isn't two votes, then is it three votes? Cause until you switched to me, Annie had three votes. Of the two with two votes, my best vote was RB.
That's OK John, I've had you as a teammate before and your team, has probably already given you up as nuts. I'm guessing they're writing the death script for you right now
:
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I really hate long posts with a bunch of quotes, but the conversation and actions of Ogre before nightfall has my interest. I am not going to quote it, but really wanted to.
I think Ice made some interesting points about Ogre's vote on Annie.
Then Ogre puts it into a "three way" tie (it was really a 5 way tie). Not because he sees the error in his logic, but to put it into a tie. Why he was unwilling to lynch Annie or was willing to put Rb into the mix is unknown. Annie did not have to save themselves, he went from 100% odds to 20%. Much better odds thanks to Ogre. Ogre tieing it up is as bad as a singleton vote, really worse. We might as well all vote for someone different and leave it up to a coin toss. Ogre could have went to a lone vote or even put anyone else into the mix. Then Annie would have been up to 25% odds. Why back to Rb? I thought the whole putting days into ties was Rb's thing.
I think Ice made some interesting points about Ogre's vote on Annie.
Then Ogre puts it into a "three way" tie (it was really a 5 way tie). Not because he sees the error in his logic, but to put it into a tie. Why he was unwilling to lynch Annie or was willing to put Rb into the mix is unknown. Annie did not have to save themselves, he went from 100% odds to 20%. Much better odds thanks to Ogre. Ogre tieing it up is as bad as a singleton vote, really worse. We might as well all vote for someone different and leave it up to a coin toss. Ogre could have went to a lone vote or even put anyone else into the mix. Then Annie would have been up to 25% odds. Why back to Rb? I thought the whole putting days into ties was Rb's thing.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Thanks for this list Ice. Of the three that are left from the coin toss. Two of them have a little bit attention to them.
I think I would place the three of them more leaning not mafia. Of my list of four, that just leaves Luv and Ogre.
I am for lynching both. I can't see voting for anyone else.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
I am not sure what post you are referring to, I have post quite the flurry pf posts. I do agree with some of the posts that Ice has made. I don't understand how he has the people that have voted for Annie today above you.
johnlarson66
These Pandas Rock
Well, since a train isn't two votes, then is it three votes? Cause until you switched to me, Annie had three votes. Of the two with two votes, my best vote was RB.
That's OK John, I've had you as a teammate before and your team, has probably already given you up as nuts. I'm guessing they're writing the death script for you right now
You tell me Ogre how many votes is a train. There can be something said about the third vote placer. Even better, when someone is the first vote on someone and then switches after there are lots of votes. Those have historicly good votes to watch.
I think anyone that halfway knows me would say that I am a little nuts. Which I pride myself in.
I vote to lynch ICE
To be clear, I haven't had time to read through the thread and am in danger of UD'ing. This vote means absolutely nothing and is based on absolutely nothing.
I apologies for slacking, I've been too busy and I'm really a little worried about being able to keep up with a bit complex of a rule set than we had last time I played.
To be clear, I haven't had time to read through the thread and am in danger of UD'ing. This vote means absolutely nothing and is based on absolutely nothing.
I apologies for slacking, I've been too busy and I'm really a little worried about being able to keep up with a bit complex of a rule set than we had last time I played.
Was Annie taking a risk and playing the numbers by allowing himself to go up against the roll? I think Annie is fairly unpredictable, I wouldn't rule that out. Annie and I have played about the same number of games here I think. My last game, I was in a similar situation as annie this time. I pulled a move where I sacrificed someone else to save my own hind-end. That turned out to backfire pretty badly.
As it is, I'm torn on the Annie situation. He's certainly not off my list, but I think there are others to look into right now.
With that said, my buddy who was visiting this weekend has gone home. I'll be able to read the thread more closely now.
As it is, I'm torn on the Annie situation. He's certainly not off my list, but I think there are others to look into right now.
With that said, my buddy who was visiting this weekend has gone home. I'll be able to read the thread more closely now.
I retract my vote for Rocker, and vote to lynch Luv.
I agree with what Ice said in previous posts regarding Luv. No time to quote them now.
I also agree with John, Luv will crack with a few votes.
My top suspects at this point:
Ogre- a player always in need of careful scrutiny.
DD- her posts trying to create a case from my vote changes on night one does seem to me like a willy vet looking for a convienient excuse to hang a citizen.
LG- same reason as DD.
Guess they skimmed the post where I explained I wanted the vote change record. I was kidding about giving Jpap fits. That was not my reason. I was also determined for my vote to finally land somewhere where my neck would not be saved by it.
I am aware my reasons to suspect these players is weak at best.
I have Ice and JL leaning innocent at this point.
I agree with what Ice said in previous posts regarding Luv. No time to quote them now.
I also agree with John, Luv will crack with a few votes.
My top suspects at this point:
Ogre- a player always in need of careful scrutiny.
DD- her posts trying to create a case from my vote changes on night one does seem to me like a willy vet looking for a convienient excuse to hang a citizen.
LG- same reason as DD.
Guess they skimmed the post where I explained I wanted the vote change record. I was kidding about giving Jpap fits. That was not my reason. I was also determined for my vote to finally land somewhere where my neck would not be saved by it.
I am aware my reasons to suspect these players is weak at best.
I have Ice and JL leaning innocent at this point.
