Hmm.. I'll break these down to separate questions.
1. Kash, who would you hit first? JB or Dawg?
I don't know yet.
2. What makes lab and sand on your non mafia list? Ice seems to be on labs tail about being mafia, yet you think she is innocent?
Right. My theory... the mafia knows LR is innocent and went after her (among others) early on. LR showed up again in the thread and had a bunch of people already bouncing her name around as a suspect.. or possibly scummy. LR found herself in a position where she had to defend herself. She took each accusation in turn and IMO the responses she gave sound reasonable. I'm also more suspicious now of those trying to possibly set her up. I see nothing else LR has posted that sounds scummy to me (so far).
3. I agree with jpap being a townie, but usually you and him are trying to get each other killed.
We are? I don't believe that's true, Red. You'll have to point out which games, then... I don't see it like that with Jpap. I'm almost always undecided about him until at least half way through a game... because he's a good player who is very difficult to read. He's also a heavy poster so there's a lot of material to digest trying to pin him down on one side or the other.
4. Why do you only like the low posters as people you think might be mafia. (there is nothing wrong with that, just want to see where your coming from)
I don't think ONLY the low posters are people who might be mafia. They're just the ones we can't figure out until very late in the game because they won't post anything (rotten cowards.. lol). By the time we get to them... all/most of the active players have been killed off already and the game lags. Hardly anyone is posting then and it sucks. It's also hard to wrap up a game when there's one last mafia scumbag to track down and most of our best players aren't around anymore to help flush them out.
Active posters are more likely to be killed off... usually. And in most mafia games, we lynch innocents one after another on Days 1 and 2. Looking at the vote analysis I make later in these games... I've also seen that most of the leading vote getters even when it's a 3-way tie turn out to be all townies. It's very difficult (usually) to lynch a mafia player on Days 1 and 2.
This format is new and different. Early on, I noticed either Dawg, JB, Jpappy, or Zsand were up to something no good... but couldn't decide between them yet because any of them could just be distancing themselves. All 4 of them (along with myself) are most active here. The ones who are mafia know the innocents and set out to create suspicion where it doesn't belong... so I was wary of Ice shooting any of them at first until we had something tangible to base that choice on. With Annie gone now and re-reading the earlier posts again... my impression is that both JB and Dawg are trying too hard to build weak cases. So they get my vote as being scummy.
