Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[Lady G]

LG, for one. I explained this at least 3 times. Read back when I first posted the theory. Around page 90

Be kinda hard for me to find page 90, being I only have 27 pages on my screen.

 

[Lady G]

Because that was how the first death was...

Actually Hay, that was the death of the Slinger. The person who was shot at was Chill who obviously didn't die.

 

[jpappy789]

Sorry I didn't see. My top 3 are JS, rich and now LG after knowing kash's role

Following the shot on Kash you named these three as your top suspects.

I've been going back and looking as JS because he is still one that stands out big time to me.....


Now this was from the very start of the game...at that point Rich had only posted a few times, he (JS) kinda just draws Richs name out of nowhere.


I am wondering what in the "previous" mafia game made him say Rich? Also remember the part about reading the previous game....




These two posts, make me feel he was wanting a feel for others thoughts of who could be mafia...yes we need to do that, but I am feeling more like the MAFIA wanted to know who we were looking at.
Now Rich is off his list, and I am randomly thrown on. Again, what about me made him pick my name. So far he has drawn Rich and my names (2 that are commonly thrown around in games and cases get built easily on).


Here, he thinks Ice because "Kash" pointed it out...oh and he admits I was just random, but why me over any other player in the game?


Again with the "more thoughts"


Well 2 posts later....no one has answered so he adds it yet again.


Now this one really stood out to me, and it did when he first posted it. For me it was more the "color coding" that got my attention. His first game and already he is color coding?


Oh, he put my name because 3 sounded like a good number?


But random and needing 3 names is significant I spose.


Now for yet another "back peddling" thought, now he states he has read other games too.

Yesterday LG pulled Js's posts because she is concerned about him.

I agree with you LG about JS aswell.

You agreed with her about Js.

Rich
LG
JB
FF

These are your top 4 who you would shoot in rapid fire.

I know Chill said to name 4 names just off the top of your head but I'm curious as to whether you think these are the four remaining mafia or if it's just a list.

I asked if you thought these were the people you thought were the last four on the mafia team. I thought maybe you were thinking that if you were wrong about Rich and LG that JB and FF were the last two. Not that we would still be around but I wanted to make sure that wasn't your thought process.

I think they are the remaining mafia

And you confirmed my original suspicion, that you believe these four to be in cahoots with Kash.

My one question is, what made you drop Js from your list even after agreeing with LG about him yesterday? Why did you add Jb and FF instead?

 

[Lady G]

Kash I take it by your suspect list you neither strongly suspect Rich nor do you buy into his Ice/Jpap theory?

To answer your question... Kash was pretty subtle when she was getting 'jumped' on about her posts but then got worried when she was about to get shot. But yes, I do think she was giving team to build off from her death. But how? I'm still trying to figure that out.

You feel kash was going for the win? Not leaving you and your scummies something to build upon to win the game? Hmm...

You know what I think... I think kash purposly put in "vote for rich" before she died because that would make people think that he is innocent. Whereas it could of been a very very sneaky underlying scum tactic. Think about it...

To win the game for your team? This answer is quite sus rich. She knew she was getting shot so why not distance you to "seal" the win?

It was just a theory. Calm your farm. Lol. But you getting all defensive about it makes me think it might be plausible.. And if she was 95% certain she was going to die, why would she still try get chill to change to you? The more logical approach would be to distance fellow mafia. Eg. You.

OK, here are your posts after Kashs death. So you think it was distancing is what it boils down to.
Yes, there is that possibility...although, she put a pretty BIG case out there on Rich it was IMO to big for distance. If she would of got Chill to change his mind all she would of done was kill off a team mate. I really don't think with as close as they were to winning she would of took that chance. Because even if Rich was shot and turned scum, really it wouldn't of cleared her, she had way to much scumness to her.
She picked a name that was on most lists, she knew Chill was looking at Rich also and she built what she felt was a case that may sway Chill from shooting her.

 

[Lady G]

That top quote from Chill wasn't suppose to be there.

I had it originally multi-quoted because I was going to comment on that was Chills question to her before her long post about Rich and why she thought he was Mafia.

 

[Lady G]

Well, i gotta get going to work. I wont be back before the shot is taken so

GOOD LUCK CHILL!!!!!!

 

[Chill]

Wow FF I'm impressed with your restraint, but it would be nice if you passed a few comments. What do you think of Kash's post below. Would you read her as defending Dag here? Possibly trying to keep Wiz from focusing on him too much?

Wizard, I'd say Dag should have posted more content than he did, so maybe it's significant that he didn't. This isn't the usual day or two of fluff posting on Day 1. But it's still real early in the game, so that makes it easy for us to pick something out and blow it out of proportion.

My advice to you is take your time. Take the full 48 hours you get. A lot of people are going to get finger-pointy anyway and we already know 5 of them are trying to point your shot the wrong way.

 

[Chill]

Chill, you have asked for input. Here's mine. Look at those who followed the crowd telling Wizard to shoot Ice. And look at those who've jumped onto me, conveniently, for making a simple mistake. Those are the people pretending to be vocal and active... In reality, they're not helping us at all.



This came from last night's posts after nightfall. Lady G and I discussed the goof I made about an old game. She didn't seem overly concerned about this at that time. And she went on posting other comments about other people.



She discussed this again (with Taysius) this morning acting like she was questioning Taysius picking me as your next shot.... but nicely managed to escalate the importance of my error.

Yes, G... you have been here the whole time. Good for you.



Nice touch there, Lady G... how very opportunistic of you. lmao.

My other suspects are: #2 Taysius. And #3 something of a toss up between Dag, FF, and Jspigs.

OK before I speciifically asked her about Rich, here is Kash's suspect list. I'm inclined to think must scum include at least one or two of ther team on any list they offer.

So town what are your thoughts on this list?

 

[Chill]

must = most

 

[Chill]

When I asked her about Rich I also asked her about Rich's theory on Ice/Pap she wrote it off as a pile of crap. Do you think that was an arguement of convenience to cement her case on Rich, or an attempt to cast doubt on Jpap/Ice?