Sorry this is actually my final post for a while. Vote count from last night :-
Vote count
Narwhal-(1)-Hammer
Chupa-(1)-Wizard
Rickets-(1)Chupa
Wizard-(1)-Tree, Fire
Tree-(3)- Wingnut, C-note, Driver
Mael-(2)- Gunslinger, Rickets
Dooms-(1)-HiIQ
Gun-(2)-Narwhal, Scoop
Driver-(3)-Star, Nem, Tree
Wingnut-(2)-BadHaggis, UhOh
HIIQ-(1)-Dooms
C-note-(0)-Mael
No vote- Tib
15 minutes till nightfall.....PM's as required
Fire-(0)-Nem
Nem-(1)Mael
For Tree to be scum, that would have to mean, I think, that I am and so is Star.
That's based on my thinking that if they were facing a lynch on the first night they would never be happy to leave it as a tie, but if me, Tree and Star are scum, then there was nothing else 'we' could do because Star and me were already on Driver.
If there was a witch in the firing line I believe there would have been a lot more activity to get them out of trouble.
My thinking above, (me, Tree and Star are witches) would also mean that the watches are a team of three and no more which I dunno seems maybe a little low, or that if there are more they don't have good communication with at least one member.
Also, presume your perfect witch plan has none of them on the innocent to be lynched and that they would have to be pretty unlucky to end up with a witch in the firing line on the first day.
Based on this I'm inclined to lean Tree Hugger innocent. I also have the mildest leaning of Wing-nut and C-Note as innocent, if Tree is in fact innocent, based on the idea that the scum team don't usually have to pile on an innocent on the first day - the town does this for them. Also if Tree
was a witch
and Wing-nut or C-Note were, they would not have let Tree go to a tie by keeping their vote on Tree - they would at least have switched off and onto
someone else if not Driver.
Taking this a step further, you could make a similar comment about any player whose vote was not already on Driver, that they could have switched onto Driver to save Tree from a tie.
As I type this out and think it through I'm inclined towards the view that Tree is probably innocent.
This doesn't take into account use of a spell last night - the one with the voting power doubled if I recall correctly. I'll be going back to read the rules again to see if we would have been told about that in some way.