Mafia 92: Night of the living Mafia... the play

[jm1212]

Which of these is your teammate? You guys always name drop one in a list don't you?

try again. if you know anything about any past games, you'll know that all three of them are players that do the most digging.

so i name a few people, and you think one of them MUST be a mafia, including myself? ok, that makes sense.

that said, it's pretty early to start talking about lists and teammates...you trying to make something of nothing? you're getting pretty worked up about this, and you have not explained why you chose to vote for me.

 

[jbradt]

seems odd that everyone has been ganging up on razz, or there has at least been a lot of posts aimed his way.....

Yet another question about the zombie mechanic, can lynched PR's get a zombie hit? Or is it just plain old townies?

Technically, townie PR's are still innocent townies, so yes... as per the rule they would become a zombie and get a hit the following nightfall.

9pm in which time zone?

9p eastern... the only one that counts. =)

Votes as I have them:

Razz: (1): Mad
Ice (1): FF
JM (1) Doomsday

 

[the wizard]

First off, I want to post this before I lose my train of thought.

The below post i pulled for the content of FF's post as this is the one he was referring to.

Its never to early to be watching players. I'm watching everyone just wanted these 3 to know I was particularly interested in them due to what was said and respond to.

You have a problem with me watching those 3? Same to you FF, I see you also had a post questioning me about my watching post. Is there a reason you 2 are worried?

I don't follow... the less innocents, the closer the mafia are to victory. Zombies take out innocent, magia happier. Seems simple to me.



Honest mistake (to the :first posts/first post thing).



I know, it's pathetic... i get tired and boom, screw myself over. I'm going to be sleeping tonight (stayed up til 1 yesterday watching Gabriel Iglaisias(?) on U-tube )



Ices very first post in the game was dead on serious, it took me by surprise. So I commented on it. He made no reply, and I didn't bother to move forward with it, my comment had been more joke then real thought. Here's the comment:

"Wow, kinda jumping in there aren't you, Ice?" - Notice, it's in question form.

The Jm commented on it with "Ice, don't you think its kinda early to already be "watching" 3 other people?"- again, in question form. Ice got all defensive when the second person noticed his behavior and defended that with


A very aggressive and over defensive post. he could have brushed it off with ease (it's what I would have done) but instead he reacted with that. Not only did he defend himself, but he then proceeded to attack Jm and myself, though he had completely ignored my earlier post. So, in sumary, I think Ice is scum because he was way defensive when the situation didn't need it. Thus, I voted him. Satifactory?

Ok. No it isn't satisfactory. I need to go back and reread as I have seen much that caught my eye. There may be something there or there may not.

However, FF, you keep saying that Ice was over defensive and attacked you and JM and the post I pulled first is the one you say he did it in. Maybe I am blind but I just don't see it. It appears to me that he just answered a question. You stated that your post to him was more of a joke, yet you kept harping and needling.

That on the surface would appear as though you were trying to keep it in the forefront. Kind of like if you post it often enough then more people would get it stuck in the back of their head and think that way.

What I would like from you FF is to explain it to me as if you were explaining it to a 5 year old how that post was defensive and attacking you and JM.

It appears to me, that he answered JM's question then asked if JM and you were worried.

 

[[AC] Doomsday998]

try again. if you know anything about any past games, you'll know that all three of them are players that do the most digging.

so i name a few people, and you think one of them MUST be a mafia, including myself? ok, that makes sense.

that said, it's pretty early to start talking about lists and teammates...you trying to make something of nothing? you're getting pretty worked up about this, and you have not explained why you chose to vote for me.

You're the one making lists, I'm just wondering why. I voted for you because you got a PM that said scum. What say you to that?

 

[the wizard]

Now to go back through the posting.

Questions will follow as they arise.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Sorry for my lack of participation, life is crazy right now. Freaking movers broke 3 of my fish tanks that they supposedly packed appropriately. Oh well, c'est la vie.

Game wise, FF's pity party and talk of quitting seems to be something he does when scum and someone puts a bit of pressure on him. Razzle's posts also have an off feel to them. The aggressive play from Ice and Mad doesn't strike me as odd at all, they'd both play that way no matter what their role.

I know I have not made a case on anyone, but right now from what I've read, FF is acting most scummy to me. I have no clue how much I'll be able to get on tomorrow so I'm going to go ahead and vote. I vote to lynch FF.

 

[the wizard]

1) The zombies will use their hits the nighfall after they are linched so they should watch that days events and (with some hopeful loyalty) make a good dicision. I know they have no connection to either team but i would hope that they would work in the towns favor....... Although it would be the town who voted them off. Now I've just confused myself even more! Haha

2) I guess I should have reworded my original statement. It is not really solid advice mut more of a suggestion that I hope people will consider when using their zoombie hits.

Raz, my question to you is why, after clarified by JB that zombies are no longer aligned with the town would they care if the town is doing good. It appears to me as if you are trying to keep the zombie discussion going instead of moving on to kick bushes and find scum.

This is something that we see the scum do quite often and not very pro town.

 

[the wizard]

seems odd that everyone has been ganging up on razz, or there has at least been a lot of posts aimed his way.....

Yet another question about the zombie mechanic, can lynched PR's get a zombie hit? Or is it just plain old townies?

Tell me how questioning inconsistency in someones posting is ganging up on them.

Do you not see anything to question with Razz's posts?

 

[the wizard]

After going back through the thread there are a few issues that concern me.

I wish JB weren't so secretive about how many scum we are facing since the number of players involved in what concerns me is pretty high for them all to be scum.

My first concern is that JB clarified the zombie allegiance issue, yet, we still have players discussing if or how zombies should use there hit clear up to almost this evening pacific time. They are also discussing who would or wouldn't want the zombies to use their hit and why.

At this point in the game all that discussion does is muddy the water and distract from hunting scum.

Personally, I think that at least one maybe two scum keep popping in on that subject for that very reason. The question is who. It does appear that Mad has been very involved in that discussion but, reading through his posts I cannot state that his involvement was for the purpose of distraction. Some of his posts in that discussion were in answer to questions or pointing out contradictions in other player's posts.

I would be more concerned with the players that have been either popping in to ask a question after it appears that subject has died down (and I need to go back through and check the timing of those posts before I can get a good feel of it) or contradicting himself in his own post.

 

[the wizard]

Sorry for my lack of participation, life is crazy right now. Freaking movers broke 3 of my fish tanks that they supposedly packed appropriately. Oh well, c'est la vie.

Game wise, FF's pity party and talk of quitting seems to be something he does when scum and someone puts a bit of pressure on him. Razzle's posts also have an off feel to them. The aggressive play from Ice and Mad doesn't strike me as odd at all, they'd both play that way no matter what their role.

I know I have not made a case on anyone, but right now from what I've read, FF is acting most scummy to me. I have no clue how much I'll be able to get on tomorrow so I'm going to go ahead and vote. I vote to lynch FF.

This is another concern of mine. LR, this is your second post in the game if I remember correctly. Your first being your game on post.

Now while I agree with you (did I actually say that?) that FF"s play has had a slimy feel to it, and I can't fault your D1 vote for reasons stated, you said you read the thread but you didn't ask any questions.

Don't get me wrong I do understand being busy especially with moving but, did you not see anything worth questioning?

Basic Mafia 101 is that you ask questions when trying to root out scum. You have been busy IRL before when playing and done a better job than this. It just seems un Labby like.

g/o sorry for your broken tanks it is getting harder to find good prices for them on craigs list now too g/o